Full Face Helmets Bad for Air Bag cars?
#31
Rennlist Member
Not clear where this is heading. The April Fastrack News says:
SOLO II SAFETY
- There is no action pending at this
time to change the Solo II helmet rules.
Additional testing and investigation are
in progress. (ref. 04-143)
SOLO II SAFETY
- There is no action pending at this
time to change the Solo II helmet rules.
Additional testing and investigation are
in progress. (ref. 04-143)
#33
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: MA
Posts: 1,010
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Phokaioglaukos
Not clear where this is heading. The April Fastrack News says:
SOLO II SAFETY
- There is no action pending at this
time to change the Solo II helmet rules.
Additional testing and investigation are
in progress. (ref. 04-143)
SOLO II SAFETY
- There is no action pending at this
time to change the Solo II helmet rules.
Additional testing and investigation are
in progress. (ref. 04-143)
#36
Lifetime Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by JBH
Someone said early on that SCCA requires removal or deactivation of the air bags - what was the reasoning behind that decision?
#37
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: MA
Posts: 1,010
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by Matt Marks
RJ, who is Joe Marko/HMS?
Are the test results available?
Are the test results available?
Joe was a guest speaker at the PCA-NER intro to Driver-Ed and AX meeting recently where he spoke briefly on this subject. He was adamant that he was not making any recommendation to disable your airbags. My impression, however, that this was that motivated more from a legality standpoint than a safety one. Joe tracks a Mini, I failed to ask him what he has done to it in this regard. I'd add I have no idea whether this testing was done with 3 pt belts or harnesses which one might suspect could influence the results.
Just stepping back for a moment, anyone who's been paying attention to discussion here over the past few weeks understands that safety is an extremely complex subject. Were I in a street car, with out race seats and a harness, until there's further data, I, personally, would leave things as they are and hope I never wind up a statistic pro or con in a future study. Again personally, if there were one in my race car where I have a race seat, harnesses, hans device, I, and just what I would do not a recommendation for anyone else, would disable it. I've certainly never seen anyone add airbags to a race car! I don't think enough work has been done yet to come to any fully formed conclusions, but it seems to me that its just common sense to rely on a system of components that have been designed to work together, rather than an ad hoc collection of devices.
#38
Race Director
Originally Posted by SundayDriver
Just to be clear - SCCA has always (AFAIK) required this for race cars per the GCR. The helmet issue is only for those activities (SOLO) where street cars run under rules other than the Racing GCR. The logic seems pretty clear in this case - air bags are untested and unproven with cages, full harnesses and all the other required equipment that has years of study.
My understanding is that there is also a GCR for Solo. Now, I'm not very familiar with Solo so someone can correct me, but that is what I was told.
#39
Lifetime Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by Geo
Actually, it's only for club racing.
My understanding is that there is also a GCR for Solo. Now, I'm not very familiar with Solo so someone can correct me, but that is what I was told.
My understanding is that there is also a GCR for Solo. Now, I'm not very familiar with Solo so someone can correct me, but that is what I was told.
#40
Rennlist Member
The issue is harder for those of us with race seats, rollbars (not cages) and harnesses who do a handful or so DE events each year. Most of the miles will be on the street with 3-point belt and no helmet, but there will be events on the track with 6-point harness and helmet. Seems it might be nice to disable the airbags, at least the front airbags, for those events only.
#41
Race Director
Originally Posted by SundayDriver
I thought that is what I just said using terms like "race car" and "racing GCR".
#42
Instructor
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Leesburg, VA
Posts: 158
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Followed up on this a couple weeks back.
The testing leading to the SCCA notice was in F1 type configuration, and was intended only to review potential use of airbags in F1. You can pull up the test.
IMHO. Based on the above testing which was NOT directly applicable, the SCCA is being extremely premature in even making the announcement, much less considering any rulemaking. Not different than the SFI 2 year belt reaction by the sanctioning bodies.
Geo, you have mentioned a couple of times that you have the SFI testing for belts. I would very much like to read that spec.
Someone mentioned Ford testing; likewise would like to be pointed toward that information.
Concur enthusiastically with the suggestion to go with FIA harness and have done so.
The only good news from all of this is that those running Driver Education now have an endless supply of very reasonably priced harness. At least until the inevitable and lamentable move is made to apply yet more of the racing requirements to DE.
The testing leading to the SCCA notice was in F1 type configuration, and was intended only to review potential use of airbags in F1. You can pull up the test.
IMHO. Based on the above testing which was NOT directly applicable, the SCCA is being extremely premature in even making the announcement, much less considering any rulemaking. Not different than the SFI 2 year belt reaction by the sanctioning bodies.
Geo, you have mentioned a couple of times that you have the SFI testing for belts. I would very much like to read that spec.
Someone mentioned Ford testing; likewise would like to be pointed toward that information.
Concur enthusiastically with the suggestion to go with FIA harness and have done so.
The only good news from all of this is that those running Driver Education now have an endless supply of very reasonably priced harness. At least until the inevitable and lamentable move is made to apply yet more of the racing requirements to DE.
#43
Originally Posted by John Brown
The only good news from all of this is that those running Driver Education now have an endless supply of very reasonably priced harness. At least until the inevitable and lamentable move is made to apply yet more of the racing requirements to DE.
#44
Race Director
Originally Posted by John Brown
Geo, you have mentioned a couple of times that you have the SFI testing for belts. I would very much like to read that spec.
I'll see what I can do.
#45
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Dec 2001
Location: MA
Posts: 1,010
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by mitch236
DE is a safer form of racing but still has the potential for danger and requiring safety equipment in the higher run groups is wise, IMO.