Cost & difficulty of transmission valve body replacement...
#16
Instructor
Joined: Jun 2009
Posts: 225
Likes: 65
From: A Swede in the Canary islands, Spain (on the African coast)
??
I'm still confused!
Is it posible to put in a gear box 09D 300 038H from 2006 in the 2004 model that use as original the 09D 300 36P box will it work with the original control box or has I to change it?
Sorry if I'm a bit slow :-)
Is it posible to put in a gear box 09D 300 038H from 2006 in the 2004 model that use as original the 09D 300 36P box will it work with the original control box or has I to change it?
Sorry if I'm a bit slow :-)
#17
Hey there having the same problem with mine too 05 cc turbo, would http://www.revmaxconverters.com/ valve body would be swap does it come with updated control module too, Westmont Porsche in Chicagoland wants $4700 all work i think way too much they can suck my d, Fluid motor union gave me quote for $1999 or smthg, have mechanic to do this job, but need some info as far as buying one from revmax right model and where i could get that control module, any info would be appreciated.
#18
The tcu and valve body must be mated. So for instance since I have an 2004 if I get a rebuilt VB that is compatible with 05+ then I need a new TCU.
As long as you get the identical valve body to your year but with the rebuilt sonnax parts you should not have to update the TCU. $2k is an acceptable price if you are including a new tcu. Otherwise $1500 would be closer to what I'd expect. The labor itself to swap VB's, filter, gaskets and drain and refill fluid is only a few hours. Its the VB and the fluid (and tcu) that represents most of the cost. $4700 is beyond robbery BTW.
As long as you get the identical valve body to your year but with the rebuilt sonnax parts you should not have to update the TCU. $2k is an acceptable price if you are including a new tcu. Otherwise $1500 would be closer to what I'd expect. The labor itself to swap VB's, filter, gaskets and drain and refill fluid is only a few hours. Its the VB and the fluid (and tcu) that represents most of the cost. $4700 is beyond robbery BTW.
#19
Thank you, endless so if undestand right if its a remanufactured its just a swap if upgraded then i would need to get new tcm for it. Its ok to pay 2k but $4700 for everything is just robbery they are one close to me but so many turndowns from them, Westmont Porsche is just a disapointment for whole Porsche network.
#20
They dont call 'em stealerships for nuthin!
I have been living with rough downshifts for about a year. I look forward to doing mine soonish and plan to get a revmax valvebody. I think its far superior to get a rebuilt unit with all the sonnax updates than the dealer who is going to put a new VB in with all the same defects as the original.
I have been living with rough downshifts for about a year. I look forward to doing mine soonish and plan to get a revmax valvebody. I think its far superior to get a rebuilt unit with all the sonnax updates than the dealer who is going to put a new VB in with all the same defects as the original.
#21
I believe if you get this one you dont need a new TCU. Why not call revmax and verify?
Just for reference
rebuilt VB
Transmission Filter
Transmission filter o-ring
Pan gasket
Filler plug and seal
Drain plug and seal
All necessary transmission fluid for a complete fluid change
Will be about $1050-1100.
I dont see why labor would exceed 4 hours.
This is why its a ~$1500 job.
Just for reference
rebuilt VB
Transmission Filter
Transmission filter o-ring
Pan gasket
Filler plug and seal
Drain plug and seal
All necessary transmission fluid for a complete fluid change
Will be about $1050-1100.
I dont see why labor would exceed 4 hours.
This is why its a ~$1500 job.
#22
The tcu and valve body must be mated. So for instance since I have an 2004 if I get a rebuilt VB that is compatible with 05+ then I need a new TCU.
As long as you get the identical valve body to your year but with the rebuilt sonnax parts you should not have to update the TCU. $2k is an acceptable price if you are including a new tcu. Otherwise $1500 would be closer to what I'd expect. The labor itself to swap VB's, filter, gaskets and drain and refill fluid is only a few hours. Its the VB and the fluid (and tcu) that represents most of the cost. $4700 is beyond robbery BTW.
As long as you get the identical valve body to your year but with the rebuilt sonnax parts you should not have to update the TCU. $2k is an acceptable price if you are including a new tcu. Otherwise $1500 would be closer to what I'd expect. The labor itself to swap VB's, filter, gaskets and drain and refill fluid is only a few hours. Its the VB and the fluid (and tcu) that represents most of the cost. $4700 is beyond robbery BTW.
#23
When I put in a rebuilt one from RevMax, you need to send them yours or remove the tranny filter and give them the number to make sure you get one that matches the TCU. Even then there was a very slight almost unnoticeable hesitation when fully accelerating up to 100 mph on one of the upshifts. Took it to the dealer and they put in the latest updates and all was good. Call revmax and they can tell you what you need to do. Easy to deal with. There was a slight change in valve bodies around late 2005 to 2006, so the number on it becomes important.
EDIT: After reading your question again I see I didn't answer it.
EDIT: After reading your question again I see I didn't answer it.
#24
Yea the post is 3 years old, but I figured I would toss in some useless info for the sake of some other sucker reading it in a few years (like me).
I saw endless_corners went to Hawaii instead of swapping valve bodies (3 years ago), which I sort of did/am doing without the cool vacation piece. We had the crap shifting since the minute we got the car. Long story shortened, wife got it without me looking at it is the reason. I have since come to move past that fact. Anyway, 5 years or more later with a couple trans fluid/filter changes that didn't do jack and the shifting still sucks. I would say it is worse then it ever has been, but it is still functional. We added roughly 80k miles to the tired valve body (she is sitting at 158k now). I do plan to fix it by either a revmax rebuild, or possibly giving the TransGO kit a twirl. First I want to ask the revmax folks if they accept a partially torn down and possibly screwed up valve body as a full core if the TransGO trial doesn't end well for me. Sometimes I wonder if I will miss that 2nd-3rd gear shift that feels like a semi truck just rear-ended me. How I haven't destroyed other stuff in the drive line is a mystery.
I saw endless_corners went to Hawaii instead of swapping valve bodies (3 years ago), which I sort of did/am doing without the cool vacation piece. We had the crap shifting since the minute we got the car. Long story shortened, wife got it without me looking at it is the reason. I have since come to move past that fact. Anyway, 5 years or more later with a couple trans fluid/filter changes that didn't do jack and the shifting still sucks. I would say it is worse then it ever has been, but it is still functional. We added roughly 80k miles to the tired valve body (she is sitting at 158k now). I do plan to fix it by either a revmax rebuild, or possibly giving the TransGO kit a twirl. First I want to ask the revmax folks if they accept a partially torn down and possibly screwed up valve body as a full core if the TransGO trial doesn't end well for me. Sometimes I wonder if I will miss that 2nd-3rd gear shift that feels like a semi truck just rear-ended me. How I haven't destroyed other stuff in the drive line is a mystery.
#25
Yea the post is 3 years old, but I figured I would toss in some useless info for the sake of some other sucker reading it in a few years (like me).
I saw endless_corners went to Hawaii instead of swapping valve bodies (3 years ago), which I sort of did/am doing without the cool vacation piece. We had the crap shifting since the minute we got the car. Long story shortened, wife got it without me looking at it is the reason. I have since come to move past that fact. Anyway, 5 years or more later with a couple trans fluid/filter changes that didn't do jack and the shifting still sucks. I would say it is worse then it ever has been, but it is still functional. We added roughly 80k miles to the tired valve body (she is sitting at 158k now). I do plan to fix it by either a revmax rebuild, or possibly giving the TransGO kit a twirl. First I want to ask the revmax folks if they accept a partially torn down and possibly screwed up valve body as a full core if the TransGO trial doesn't end well for me. Sometimes I wonder if I will miss that 2nd-3rd gear shift that feels like a semi truck just rear-ended me. How I haven't destroyed other stuff in the drive line is a mystery.
I saw endless_corners went to Hawaii instead of swapping valve bodies (3 years ago), which I sort of did/am doing without the cool vacation piece. We had the crap shifting since the minute we got the car. Long story shortened, wife got it without me looking at it is the reason. I have since come to move past that fact. Anyway, 5 years or more later with a couple trans fluid/filter changes that didn't do jack and the shifting still sucks. I would say it is worse then it ever has been, but it is still functional. We added roughly 80k miles to the tired valve body (she is sitting at 158k now). I do plan to fix it by either a revmax rebuild, or possibly giving the TransGO kit a twirl. First I want to ask the revmax folks if they accept a partially torn down and possibly screwed up valve body as a full core if the TransGO trial doesn't end well for me. Sometimes I wonder if I will miss that 2nd-3rd gear shift that feels like a semi truck just rear-ended me. How I haven't destroyed other stuff in the drive line is a mystery.
#27
Help with Indy Trans Shop Recommendation - Chicago Area
Hi Everyone,
Great forum! The advice and guidance I've seen is fantastic.
I'm stuck in a situation where my '04 CS is having the notorious VB issues. I've settled in with using the RevMax rebuilt VB, which I would like my Indy to install. Unfortunately, the owner has had issues in dealing with P!G Transmission Electronics and is balking at my request. I've even shared the DIY procedure I came across as an example of how straight forward the job would be.
So, the ask I have for this community is for any recommendations folks may have for a trustworthy indy transmission shop that I might be able to work with. Being in the Chicagoland area, the recommendations may be widespread. That's OKAY! Any recommendations are appreciated.
Now to relieve my stress..... https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/banghead.gif and get happy https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/drink.gif
Great forum! The advice and guidance I've seen is fantastic.
I'm stuck in a situation where my '04 CS is having the notorious VB issues. I've settled in with using the RevMax rebuilt VB, which I would like my Indy to install. Unfortunately, the owner has had issues in dealing with P!G Transmission Electronics and is balking at my request. I've even shared the DIY procedure I came across as an example of how straight forward the job would be.
So, the ask I have for this community is for any recommendations folks may have for a trustworthy indy transmission shop that I might be able to work with. Being in the Chicagoland area, the recommendations may be widespread. That's OKAY! Any recommendations are appreciated.
Now to relieve my stress..... https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/banghead.gif and get happy https://rennlist.com/forums/graemlins/drink.gif
#30
The VB is easy. Unsure of all the fuss. I scored a discount on a CTT the guy was trying to dump because he thought the transmission was shot. Did the VB (my second Cayenne and third VB too replace... I've put over 400k miles on 2 955s)