955 Engine is Dead - but I love this car! (Engine Swap Thread)
#31
Banned
Join Date: Mar 2011
Location: Spring Lake, NJ, US of A
Posts: 10,085
Received 1,143 Likes
on
759 Posts
If you are using a propane heater in a garage - please DO be careful with gasoline. The fumes from it like to run along the floor and gather in the lowest spot. If the propane heater is near that spot or in the path you'll learn that in an unpleasant way. A radiant propane heater mounted high in the garage facing the workplace and tools is actually much more effective in making it a pleasant work environment - and also safer.
#32
Get a big overhead radiant heater or 3 parabolic heaters and do it in your own garage. I would hate to be a part of the plan that gives your car 48 hours on the work lift before it must be rolling again. This is a 40+ beer project, man!
#33
Go figure, I actually replaced the mounts only 1000 miles ago.
One idea I've had that might reduce the pressure is to remove the front clip. While this would undoubtedly add time to the job, it would allow me to pull the engine out the front after dropping it, meaning that I'd only have to get the car a foot or so in the air and not need a lift.
The ability to work on it at home would be significantly beneficial... but at the same time, the garage at home isn't heated, and it's still winter in Michigan. Using the lift would be easier but leaves little margin for error if I only have a 2 day window to use it.
Any thoughts as to either approach?
One idea I've had that might reduce the pressure is to remove the front clip. While this would undoubtedly add time to the job, it would allow me to pull the engine out the front after dropping it, meaning that I'd only have to get the car a foot or so in the air and not need a lift.
The ability to work on it at home would be significantly beneficial... but at the same time, the garage at home isn't heated, and it's still winter in Michigan. Using the lift would be easier but leaves little margin for error if I only have a 2 day window to use it.
Any thoughts as to either approach?
#34
Burning Brakes
Cheering you on here. If you can pull this off as cost effectively as you seem like you're able to, it will be a bit of a game changer for figuring out how to own these trucks.
I have not done that level of work yet on my 04 S, but from work on many other cars over the years, I'll echo the suggestions you're getting to avoid doing it under time pressure. You'll get it done better without the pressure, and it will be a lot more fun.
Side benefits for the forum - the no-lift option is probably more common for most readers here, and you'll have more time to take pics. Thanks in advance.
I have not done that level of work yet on my 04 S, but from work on many other cars over the years, I'll echo the suggestions you're getting to avoid doing it under time pressure. You'll get it done better without the pressure, and it will be a lot more fun.
Side benefits for the forum - the no-lift option is probably more common for most readers here, and you'll have more time to take pics. Thanks in advance.
#35
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Yeah, y'all are right, and I kinda knew the at home project was the best option as I was writing last time.
I've put out a couple feelers to friends to see if there's a heated garage I could occupy for a little while. I've looked into rental garages/bays but there isn't anything within a reasonable distance to me. Worst case scenario I do it at my house but my garage layout isn't ideal (but it is workable).
Got a couple shopping items for tools - thanks for the above advice. I have a limited set of Snap On triple squares but no short ones.
What are everyone's thoughts on a combined front/drop approach? I have a number of low profile transmission jacks that I could use to lower the entire cradle out, and then slide forward out of the engine. Would make the separation of transmissions and engine easier, and removal easier in general I would think.
I've put out a couple feelers to friends to see if there's a heated garage I could occupy for a little while. I've looked into rental garages/bays but there isn't anything within a reasonable distance to me. Worst case scenario I do it at my house but my garage layout isn't ideal (but it is workable).
Got a couple shopping items for tools - thanks for the above advice. I have a limited set of Snap On triple squares but no short ones.
What are everyone's thoughts on a combined front/drop approach? I have a number of low profile transmission jacks that I could use to lower the entire cradle out, and then slide forward out of the engine. Would make the separation of transmissions and engine easier, and removal easier in general I would think.
#37
Having done it- out the front is the way to go. No need to remove the front cradle. just need an engine hoist as is typical.
Putting the front end into "Service Position" is not very difficult or time consuming and will open things up a alot to make removal of engine better.
The torque converter bolts are a bit of a pain to reach - the access is hiding behind the drivers side cat converter.
Putting the front end into "Service Position" is not very difficult or time consuming and will open things up a alot to make removal of engine better.
The torque converter bolts are a bit of a pain to reach - the access is hiding behind the drivers side cat converter.
#38
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Been about two weeks, with no updates - sorry about that! There is progress! First, a friend of mine has a heated garage... and to boot, he used to be a mechanic. I moved the car to his garage and we've been getting into it as time allows.
We're taking it out the front. So far, it's been fairly trouble free, and slow going just due to time availability. The front end comes off relatively easily. The toughest part was figuring out the best order of disconnecting/draining fluids from the radiator, AC condenser, power steering cooler and transmission cooler - but, all fairly easy. Right now, we're fighting the rusty exhaust nuts/bolts. In order to access the torque converter bolts we're going to be removing the driver's side primary cat. Additionally, we're going to be pulling the secondary cat pipes for both ease of access, and because I'm replacing them with the HHR seconday cat bypass pipes.
We're taking it out the front. So far, it's been fairly trouble free, and slow going just due to time availability. The front end comes off relatively easily. The toughest part was figuring out the best order of disconnecting/draining fluids from the radiator, AC condenser, power steering cooler and transmission cooler - but, all fairly easy. Right now, we're fighting the rusty exhaust nuts/bolts. In order to access the torque converter bolts we're going to be removing the driver's side primary cat. Additionally, we're going to be pulling the secondary cat pipes for both ease of access, and because I'm replacing them with the HHR seconday cat bypass pipes.
#40
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Another quick update - mode of failure discovered.
It had nothing to do with piston slap, cylinder scoring, etc. I'm still trying to determine exactly HOW (engine is still mostly assembled and in the car), but the car suffered a catastrophic "change" in timing. I'm suspecting some kind of failure of either the chain tensioner or one of the pads, but taking the 1-4 cam cover off, there was so much slack in the timing chain that you could pick it up and move it with your hand.
This is also why the project is taking so long - while the engine isn't seize, I can't rotate the crank a full 360 degrees to remove all 6 of the torque converter bolts. Got 4 bolts out, but I'm guessing that on the 5-8 bank, a valve is stuck down preventing the engine from completely rotating.
Also, removing the secondary catalytic converters (necessary to remove the primary cat on the driver's side) has ended up being the most challenging part so far, just due to rusted and seized bolts. Be prepared to cut, hack, etc. if your bolts are as seized as mine.
It had nothing to do with piston slap, cylinder scoring, etc. I'm still trying to determine exactly HOW (engine is still mostly assembled and in the car), but the car suffered a catastrophic "change" in timing. I'm suspecting some kind of failure of either the chain tensioner or one of the pads, but taking the 1-4 cam cover off, there was so much slack in the timing chain that you could pick it up and move it with your hand.
This is also why the project is taking so long - while the engine isn't seize, I can't rotate the crank a full 360 degrees to remove all 6 of the torque converter bolts. Got 4 bolts out, but I'm guessing that on the 5-8 bank, a valve is stuck down preventing the engine from completely rotating.
Also, removing the secondary catalytic converters (necessary to remove the primary cat on the driver's side) has ended up being the most challenging part so far, just due to rusted and seized bolts. Be prepared to cut, hack, etc. if your bolts are as seized as mine.
#41
Another quick update - mode of failure discovered.
It had nothing to do with piston slap, cylinder scoring, etc. I'm still trying to determine exactly HOW (engine is still mostly assembled and in the car), but the car suffered a catastrophic "change" in timing. I'm suspecting some kind of failure of either the chain tensioner or one of the pads, but taking the 1-4 cam cover off, there was so much slack in the timing chain that you could pick it up and move it with your hand.
It had nothing to do with piston slap, cylinder scoring, etc. I'm still trying to determine exactly HOW (engine is still mostly assembled and in the car), but the car suffered a catastrophic "change" in timing. I'm suspecting some kind of failure of either the chain tensioner or one of the pads, but taking the 1-4 cam cover off, there was so much slack in the timing chain that you could pick it up and move it with your hand.
This is also why the project is taking so long - while the engine isn't seize, I can't rotate the crank a full 360 degrees to remove all 6 of the torque converter bolts. Got 4 bolts out, but I'm guessing that on the 5-8 bank, a valve is stuck down preventing the engine from completely rotating.
#43
Rennlist Member
On the subject of storing the 996... try a self storage unit. They have spots that are sized for vehicles.
It it hurts me down inside to see the REAL pigs going down this road with engine issues. I’m glad you’re taking the time to bring this piggie back to market. Best of luck
It it hurts me down inside to see the REAL pigs going down this road with engine issues. I’m glad you’re taking the time to bring this piggie back to market. Best of luck
#44
but the car suffered a catastrophic "change" in timing. I'm suspecting some kind of failure of either the chain tensioner or one of the pads, but taking the 1-4 cam cover off, there was so much slack in the timing chain that you could pick it up and move it with your hand.
It it hurts me down inside to see the REAL pigs going down this road with engine issues.
#45
I have an 05 turbo that died suddenly (valve float - boom). I put in an 08 turbo engine with 8k miles after trying 3 05s only to find varying states of prefailure.
Good luck repairing yours! Great trucks, but the v8s have real issues.
Good luck repairing yours! Great trucks, but the v8s have real issues.