Notices
Cayenne 955-957 2003-2010 1st Generation
Sponsored by:
Sponsored by:

increase in 1st time posters with mechanicals

Thread Tools
 
Search this Thread
 
Old 06-02-2018 | 12:53 AM
  #46  
deilenberger's Avatar
deilenberger
Banned
 
Joined: Mar 2011
Posts: 10,084
Likes: 1,164
From: Spring Lake, NJ, US of A
Default

Originally Posted by vandal968
The valve covers are definitely plastic on the 4.5 as Mr. Haney points out. They may have planned to make them out of magnesium and printed some advertising materials based on that info, but that isn't what made it onto the car. First hint, magnesium is magnesium colored. The valve covers are black and they are black throughout the material. That's why the inside (unpainted part) of the valve cover is black, and why if you have any little chips in your reinforcement ribs, they are black there too. The outside surface is painted silver so that proud new Porsche owners don't realize how much Porsche cheaped-out on this expensive part. I designed injection-molded plastic parts for a living for many years, and I promise you that I can recognize injection-molded plastics.

cheers,
c
You aren't reading what I posted - the information on the valve covers from the technical manual was for the 92A Cayenne, AKA 958. This was not advertising materials - it was a technical manual written to introduce the 958 series to the technicians who would be working on it. And the covers on my '11 CTT are metal... I'd assume magnesium - there is a bare metal edge around the oil fill hole.
Old 06-02-2018 | 10:28 AM
  #47  
J'sWorld's Avatar
J'sWorld
Three Wheelin'
 
Joined: May 2014
Posts: 1,767
Likes: 184
Default

Originally Posted by deilenberger
You aren't reading what I posted - the information on the valve covers from the technical manual was for the 92A Cayenne, AKA 958. This was not advertising materials - it was a technical manual written to introduce the 958 series to the technicians who would be working on it. And the covers on my '11 CTT are metal... I'd assume magnesium - there is a bare metal edge around the oil fill hole.
Yeah, but Don, this is the 955 forum now. You know I'm a rule follower. I'm just trying to be fair.
Old 06-02-2018 | 12:09 PM
  #48  
Dan87951's Avatar
Dan87951
Nordschleife Master
 
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 6,431
Likes: 33
From: Lansing Michigan
Default

Originally Posted by nodoors
Most of the clueless new owners who are stepping into these because they can get a 4 digit priced Porsche are going to get their *** handed to them at the first or second repair bill months down the road.

At 15 years and counting there are going to be a lot of maintenance and deferred maintenance items showing up. Few of the 3rd and 4th hand owners will be prepared for the complexity and cost. There are countless parts on these beasts that are going to be increasingly subject to failure as they age. We know about the early common ones like hatch struts and coolant pipes, but with age there will be things that switch from rare to common. Most notably some of the accessories that are regularly and easily replaced on other vehicles, but not this one. One in particular comes to my mind because I am one a small group on the boards who has had to replace my alternator early. I don't think the brushes wore out on mine, but they certainly will on all alternators with enough hours. There are countless small items, though...

All the plastic parts that get heat cycled and mechanically stressed are going to start failing. The coolant pipes in the intake were the canary in the coal mine. They failed early because they experienced the most extreme heat cycles due to their location. The Tee's behind the engine on the CTT's were the second canary because they were the second most prone to extreme heat cycling. The vacuum lines under and around the intake have become more prevalent and in time all will need to be replaced. You can bet your *** that the rest of plastic connections and fittings for the vacuum and cooling systems will follow as they continue to age and experience the high heat that is produced under the hood of these vehicles.

Many of the rubber parts will fail as well. The numerous electric motors will have brushes and bearings wear out (stepper motors in the interior, cooling fans, throttle body blade motors, vacuum pumps, aux electric coolant pumps, fuel pumps, air compressors, transfer case stepper motors, etc.) - some of these are already pretty common like the HVAC blower and fuel pumps, electromechanical relays all over the place - we have seen early signs of the major PITA ones on the steering column lock already, and as people keep adding more miles to these V8's we will see more bore scoring just like with the other affected Porsche models.

These cars see extraordinary heat under the hood due to the nature of the vehicle and the way it is all so tightly packaged. Has anyone ever run temperature tests to see if running without the plastic belly pans might possibly reduce the under hood temps and heat soak of all the components? I am also going to look into getting my fans programmed to come on earlier to try to limit the under hood temps to some degree as well. Over time I have replaced many, many plastic and rubber parts, however the list seems endless and at $35-$200 per grossly overpriced part and with such limited access due to packaging it is daunting.
I think you nailed it! Porsche's cheapness in materials will be the achilles heel for new "budget minded" owners. I never laughed so hard when the dealer told me they wanted over $220 for two small sections of plastic tubing. It seems Porsche is better at being comedians than making quality cars. I miss the 80's and 90's...
Old 12-19-2018 | 02:13 PM
  #49  
Pillow's Avatar
Pillow
Racer
 
Joined: Sep 2018
Posts: 491
Likes: 49
From: NoVA
Default

Originally Posted by nodoors
Most of the clueless new owners who are stepping into these because they can get a 4 digit priced Porsche are going to get their *** handed to them at the first or second repair bill months down the road.
As a new owner of a seemly clean CS, yes you expect some hidden repairs as you figure the PO sold it for a reason... Just how expensive was that reason is the question!

Most all the 08-10s we looked at were broken in some really obvious way. Sad and pitiful ownership and maintenance. So yes the "deferred" maintenance angle definitely comes into play here. IDK why but you see the vast majority of used Cayennes being sold ~100k no matter which model 955, 957, or 958.

After 3 days of ownership here is some of the fun things we have found on a seemingly well cared for 2010 CS at 89k:
- Owners Manual not in folder "kit" (off to Ebay to fix this)
- Drivers door lock actuator does not lock... Apparently a common VW shared part issue when the electronic board goes bad.
- Engine Light came on. I believe related to the start up emissions air bypass valve BS stuff, the original "fix" by the dealer was a new gas cap... I guess that wasn't it.
- No spare tire pump (off to Ebay again $50)
- Front and Rear parking sensors are OFF completely... IDK if this is a setup option or the rear control module took a dump... Really weird.
- Needs a second key ($450)

I ordered the standard maintenance goodies from Pelican the other day for filters and oil. So at 90k it will get freshness all over the place and I can control the maintenance from there.
- The brake fluid needs changed out as it is a little dirty. Some fresh ATE 200 should do well here.
- Any tips on coolant replacement intervals?
- Check battery born on date and establish the replacement interval.

Again this is a clean example of a CS! I cannot imagine what a beater would cost to get back in shape!







Old 12-19-2018 | 07:03 PM
  #50  
jeff spahn's Avatar
jeff spahn
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Nov 2009
Posts: 8,611
Likes: 404
From: Dubuque, IA
Default

Originally Posted by nodoors
...snip

These cars see extraordinary heat under the hood due to the nature of the vehicle and the way it is all so tightly packaged. Has anyone ever run temperature tests to see if running without the plastic belly pans might possibly reduce the under hood temps and heat soak of all the components?...snip
I will tell you that removing the belly pans will almost assuredly increase the underhood temps. Where is my data you say? Well I am taking from 928 experience where you see air flow disturbances with the belly pans off that increase the temps quite markedly. Leave them on. If anything, leave your hood open when you get home from more than trivial distances.

Something else we will start to see also comes from the 928 world. Porsches like to have clean grounds. Electrical gremlins will start to appear in the coming years due to poor grounds. This CanBus system will be very susceptible due to the multiple voltage signals on our wires. Then we can be sure of seeing wire degradation causing issues. You've been warned.
Old 12-20-2018 | 03:24 AM
  #51  
RSbob's Avatar
RSbob
Racer
 
Joined: Jan 2005
Posts: 488
Likes: 52
From: Seattle-ish
Default

Not a flipper and not a mechanic either. This is my 5th Porsche. For the last 18 years I have had mostly early 911s and a 914 have been my rides so am very familiar with paying the Porsche Premium. Had my 914 converted with a complete engine rebuild from a six cylinder so am used to shocking bills, or as used as one can become. Am used to doing oil, filter, plugs, brakes, and small mechanical and electrical repairs. The DIY section is so well written here as well as on Pelican that I feel comfortable doing a fair amount on my own. Bought the ties and power steering hose for the inevitable Jimy Fix and am ready when it lets go. So yes I am new and not talented mechanically but am willing to put up the good fight on basic stuff which doesn’t require super specialized skills and tools.

As for engine heat, would opening up the plastic blocking panels in the nose of the pig have any effect or would moisture compromise electricals?
Old 12-20-2018 | 03:39 PM
  #52  
kraeburn's Avatar
kraeburn
Instructor
 
Joined: Mar 2006
Posts: 112
Likes: 0
From: RI
Default

Originally Posted by jeff spahn
I will tell you that removing the belly pans will almost assuredly increase the underhood temps. Where is my data you say? Well I am taking from 928 experience where you see air flow disturbances with the belly pans off that increase the temps quite markedly. Leave them on. If anything, leave your hood open when you get home from more than trivial distances.

Something else we will start to see also comes from the 928 world. Porsches like to have clean grounds. Electrical gremlins will start to appear in the coming years due to poor grounds. This CanBus system will be very susceptible due to the multiple voltage signals on our wires. Then we can be sure of seeing wire degradation causing issues. You've been warned.
CAN'T WAIT!
Old 12-20-2018 | 03:56 PM
  #53  
wkearney99's Avatar
wkearney99
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 2,131
Likes: 203
From: Bethesda, MD USA
Default

Originally Posted by Pillow
As a new owner of a seemly clean CS, yes you expect some hidden repairs as you figure the PO sold it for a reason... Just how expensive was that reason is the question!

Most all the 08-10s we looked at were broken in some really obvious way. Sad and pitiful ownership and maintenance. So yes the "deferred" maintenance angle definitely comes into play here. IDK why but you see the vast majority of used Cayennes being sold ~100k no matter which model 955, 957, or 958.

After 3 days of ownership here is some of the fun things we have found on a seemingly well cared for 2010 CS at 89k:
- Owners Manual not in folder "kit" (off to Ebay to fix this)
- Drivers door lock actuator does not lock... Apparently a common VW shared part issue when the electronic board goes bad.
- Engine Light came on. I believe related to the start up emissions air bypass valve BS stuff, the original "fix" by the dealer was a new gas cap... I guess that wasn't it.
- No spare tire pump (off to Ebay again $50)
- Front and Rear parking sensors are OFF completely... IDK if this is a setup option or the rear control module took a dump... Really weird.
- Needs a second key ($450)

I ordered the standard maintenance goodies from Pelican the other day for filters and oil. So at 90k it will get freshness all over the place and I can control the maintenance from there.
- The brake fluid needs changed out as it is a little dirty. Some fresh ATE 200 should do well here.
- Any tips on coolant replacement intervals?
- Check battery born on date and establish the replacement interval.

Again this is a clean example of a CS! I cannot imagine what a beater would cost to get back in shape!
Wait, you bought a car without a second key and not having actually tested that the one you have actually locked the doors? Caveat emptor comes to mind.

The owners manual for a 2010 can be found online as a PDF.

Is the Park Assist button light on the upper console turned on? That controls whether the bumper sensors beep or not. Pg 237 in the manual PDF.
Old 12-20-2018 | 06:09 PM
  #54  
Pillow's Avatar
Pillow
Racer
 
Joined: Sep 2018
Posts: 491
Likes: 49
From: NoVA
Default

Originally Posted by wkearney99
Wait, you bought a car without a second key and not having actually tested that the one you have actually locked the doors? Caveat emptor comes to mind.

The owners manual for a 2010 can be found online as a PDF.

Is the Park Assist button light on the upper console turned on? That controls whether the bumper sensors beep or not. Pg 237 in the manual PDF.
Yes, calculated risk absolutely. Risk mitigation = Toyota Appliance. We always budget 1-3k for "fixing" any used car as the POs are usually el cheapos in one way or another. Brakes, tires, deferred maintenance, blah blah neglect and cheapness.

FWIW the drivers door "looks" locked, but it is not. With the sound of the other locks going off you just don't know until you pull the handle.

We were aware of the key and cost of $450 so no shocker there... Same process as with Volvo ($350), proprietary dealer programming garbage.

Let me check on the overhead Park Assist button. (IIRC I could have sworn the parking sensors worked on the test drive. Hopefully chalk that up to ignorant newbie owner pressing the wrong buttons!) Sad truth is that I cannot read half of these buttons w/o reading glasses anyway! Keep laughing, you young bucks will get there when you are over 40! LOL





Old 12-20-2018 | 10:37 PM
  #55  
wkearney99's Avatar
wkearney99
Rennlist Member
 
Joined: Jun 2016
Posts: 2,131
Likes: 203
From: Bethesda, MD USA
Default

Originally Posted by Pillow
Sad truth is that I cannot read half of these buttons w/o reading glasses anyway! Keep laughing, you young bucks will get there when you are over 40! LOL
You are not alone in that regard. And it's just soooo helpful having tiny text on buttons ABOVE the bifocal line of sight....

You'd think with the typical demographic being able to afford to own a Porsche they'd put at least a LITTLE effort into adjusting the ergonomics to account for it. Sadly, no.
Old 12-21-2018 | 10:49 AM
  #56  
Pillow's Avatar
Pillow
Racer
 
Joined: Sep 2018
Posts: 491
Likes: 49
From: NoVA
Default

Originally Posted by wkearney99
You are not alone in that regard. And it's just soooo helpful having tiny text on buttons ABOVE the bifocal line of sight....

You'd think with the typical demographic being able to afford to own a Porsche they'd put at least a LITTLE effort into adjusting the ergonomics to account for it. Sadly, no.
Amen brother! Amen!

I have no hope of reading the seat heater small font numbers... Binary on/off when rolling the wheel up/down!






Quick Reply: increase in 1st time posters with mechanicals



All times are GMT -3. The time now is 01:30 PM.