I'm old school, so I have to say get the 6 speed. But it's your car, do what you want, I have driven a 996TT tip and I was impressed, but just not for me.

 

6 speed.

 

Russ, you should also check out the search function on the bar at the top of the page. It can point you toward many lengthy threads on the subject. FWIW, I went with the manual and couldn't be happier. I too am old school and it's hard to beat the car / driver interaction you get with the manual. The hydraulic clutch in the 997tt is also very light and won't wear your leg out in traffic.

 

Go tip.

 

I am European and tip or automatic's were always expensive options on cars....I also felt it was for old people....BUT since I moved to the States and have been driving automatics and now a P with Tip...I don't think I would ever go back.....tooooo much traffic and the automatic's really improved (6 speeds and now even a 8 gear on the Lexus).......I also read that the tipped TT was faster than the manual one.....I think you will be happier with a tip.