When you click on links to various merchants on this site and make a purchase, this can result in this site earning a commission. Affiliate programs and affiliations include, but are not limited to, the eBay Partner Network.
You're probably getting 91 octane and you're absolutely right. My BMW (slightly tweaked 335 442HP@the wheels) was running 94 when I was in Michigan and 91 in Washington. Granted the car was suppose to run on 91 with my tune but it ran like total shiz on Washington fuel. IDK man....I think you're right. I now run 93 BP (because I like what they did to the Gulf) and my car runs amazing. I don't know if they use any ethanol but I think they do.
I suspect your issue is going from 120 Proof ***** Creek to 100 proof. Your car can't handle it especially when smoking a cigar.
I primarily use BP 93 octane too and our cars run great. I started going there many years ago when my BMW at the time started having detonation problems. The dealer blamed the gas I used (typical). The dealer used the BP station across the street to fill all of their cars, so I started going there because I didn't want to hear what I thought was a lame excuse for gas causing my problems. After about 3 fill-ups my problem went away, and I've been going there ever since with our other cars.