Maintenance: Spark Plug and Ignition Coil Replacement
#61
Burning Brakes
Yeah, I was hoping to avoid it, but I guess that's not possible. I find this Workshop Manual a bit strange at times. Some of the job descriptions are overly detailed that I wonder, "Do you really need to describe this?" Others like this with no mention of downloading the exhaust are incomplete IMO.
Sean
Sean
#62
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Central Massachusetts
Posts: 1,796
Likes: 0
Received 352 Likes
on
183 Posts
Yeah, I was hoping to avoid it, but I guess that's not possible. I find this Workshop Manual a bit strange at times. Some of the job descriptions are overly detailed that I wonder, "Do you really need to describe this?" Others like this with no mention of downloading the exhaust are incomplete IMO.
Sean
Sean
#63
Rennlist Member
Sean
Last edited by Sniff; 05-27-2014 at 02:00 PM.
#64
Burning Brakes
The problem is that, at least with my 1/4" torque wrench, there's no way to torque the pugs and coil bolts with the mufflers in place. Even with the muffler out, I could not get my torque wrench to fit on the most aft coil pack bolt on the right side. If one is not planning to torque everything to the correct amount, then muffler removal isn't necessary. But not torquing to spec could lead to its own problems.
#65
Avoid removing exhaust manifold(EM) if you have any plans to do so. Few weeks back I removed EM on right side for replacing plug/coil and one EM bolt snapped. I tried to remove stuck stud for many hours using various extractors/drill etc.. and finally ended up having indy shop drill out the stubborn stud(Charged me $350). You don't need to remove EM for coil/plug torqueing. With flex head ratchet/socket extension/universal joint combos, you should be able to torque them properly. Good luck.
I had my rear wheels off the other day and saw the coil packs and thought they looked fairly easy to get to (well at least the front and middle plugs). I think I will try to do it first without downloading the exhaust and see how far I get, knowing full well it's highly probable I will have to drop the mufflers. Thanks.
Sean
Sean
#67
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Apr 2008
Location: Sarasota, FL. Home of Florida Man.
Posts: 1,268
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Quick question about ignition coils - I had a coil go on one cylinder that was replaced by the dealer under warranty. I am told that the coil they put in is a new design and that there is a likelihood the others will fail.
Is this correct? I've got a 997.2, 2009. I have 24k miles and it seems pretty early to be worrying about coils.
thanks!
b
Is this correct? I've got a 997.2, 2009. I have 24k miles and it seems pretty early to be worrying about coils.
thanks!
b
#68
Instructor
Join Date: Jun 2008
Location: Lincoln, Nebraska
Posts: 183
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
pretty sure this has convinced me to just pay a shop to do the plugs!!!!
only 34K on the clock, but pretty sure the plugs are original... ('05). this would probably sort out the less-than-perfect idle...
only 34K on the clock, but pretty sure the plugs are original... ('05). this would probably sort out the less-than-perfect idle...
#69
Rennlist Member
I had my rear wheels off the other day and saw the coil packs and thought they looked fairly easy to get to (well at least the front and middle plugs). I think I will try to do it first without downloading the exhaust and see how far I get, knowing full well it's highly probable I will have to drop the mufflers. Thanks.
Sean
Sean
I will say that my car is a factory X-51 with the sport exhaust, so I am not sure if I have more room to maneuver compared to the standard Carerras. That said, I found this job fairly straightforward. I just took my time, analyzed each coil pack very carefully, and came up with a different ratchet set-up using various sized extension rods. I didn't have to remove the wheels . . . just jacked the rear up using my recently purchased Jackpoint jackstands (I highly recommend them by the way).
I think all told I had around 3 hours in the job so I am pretty happy with that. Porsche books this job at 2.5 hours I've been told, so I think I did pretty good for my first time. I will confess I was not able to get a torque wrench on a couple of the coil pack bolts, but at 7.5 ft-lbs, I was close enough. I don't think having the mufflers off would have improved my chances as those bolts were blocked by the muffler bracket (which stays in place) rather than the muffler itself.
I am glad I tried to do it first without removing the exhaust. An old mechanic who is no longer with us once told me that he always tried to do a job by removing the least amount of components possible. He said if removing something wasn't essential to accomplishing the task, he avoided it because it always opened up the door for potential problems.
FWIW, the plugs I removed were not the factory originals. They were the Bosch FGR 5K QE0 plugs and were installed at a Porsche dealership in Southern CA during the car's last major service. I guess not all dealers use OEM.
Sean
#70
Quick question as I don't want to start a new thread and this is pretty on topic:
2009 Carrera S with about 7k miles, will be due for oil in a couple months. At this point Porsche recommends spark plug replacement. Car has always been in California, original owner had it 100% garaged and drove it weekends.
Overkill to do the plugs?
My trusted indy mechanic believes it's massive overkill and believes Porsches recommendation is based on avoiding plug seizures in other climates. I don't mind spending the money but I really don't want to meddle with something that's not broken at the same time. Car looks, smells, drives and was inspected to basically be in new condition. Don't want to mess with it if it's not needed.
2009 Carrera S with about 7k miles, will be due for oil in a couple months. At this point Porsche recommends spark plug replacement. Car has always been in California, original owner had it 100% garaged and drove it weekends.
Overkill to do the plugs?
My trusted indy mechanic believes it's massive overkill and believes Porsches recommendation is based on avoiding plug seizures in other climates. I don't mind spending the money but I really don't want to meddle with something that's not broken at the same time. Car looks, smells, drives and was inspected to basically be in new condition. Don't want to mess with it if it's not needed.
#71
#73
Rennlist Member
My '08 C2S hit 47,500+ miles so I dove into some maintenance items this pass weekend.
<snip>
[/URL]
Originally posted by Luxster
The only thing I would add is to remove the exhaust manifold so you can get the torque wrench in there for the proper sparkplug torque setting.
<snip>
=L=
<snip>
[/URL]
Originally posted by Luxster
The only thing I would add is to remove the exhaust manifold so you can get the torque wrench in there for the proper sparkplug torque setting.
<snip>
=L=
Thanks to the two of you, and others, for taking the time to post.
I'm just in the planning stages of doing "40k" maint on our 2009.
Other than potential P/N differences is the mechanical off and on pretty much the same as detailed for the .1's?
Cheers
Craig
#74
Rennlist Member
#75
Just chiming in - right rear plug is a real PITA to remove due to the upper/aft coil bolt. Very difficult to get at it....finally a goofy combination of 1/4, 3/8, universals, extensions. I then had to plug the coil back in from the top - a blind maneuver and my hand looks like I lost a fight with a cat. Porsche could have VERY easily tweaked the exhaust bracket design to make this job simple. I may mod it next time. The other 5 plugs collectively took the same time as the right rear!
Btw - removed exhaust but not manifolds. I've had the exhaust off before and knew it was super easy to remove. But....this time around the bolts on the clamps were rusted solid and two had to be cut off. Wire brushed threads and soaking with liquid wrench didn't help. Stainless steel exhaust - good. Mild steel bolts - stupid. I replaced with stainless. Didn't want to risk manifold removal for fear of more rusted fasteners.
Btw - removed exhaust but not manifolds. I've had the exhaust off before and knew it was super easy to remove. But....this time around the bolts on the clamps were rusted solid and two had to be cut off. Wire brushed threads and soaking with liquid wrench didn't help. Stainless steel exhaust - good. Mild steel bolts - stupid. I replaced with stainless. Didn't want to risk manifold removal for fear of more rusted fasteners.