HPDE Question
#31
Look, you've instructed, in cars, I haven't. So I'll take your word for it. But I have instructed motorcycle riders and am a current racer. So I don't feel like I'm completely out of line. But if you were my instructor and in my car, I'd follow your instruction and direction.
Either way, back to OP! Enjoy the hell out of the track day and always listen to your instructor. As they will guide you how they wish you to progress. I have no doubt that everyone's too concern is safety, improvement and fun!
Either way, back to OP! Enjoy the hell out of the track day and always listen to your instructor. As they will guide you how they wish you to progress. I have no doubt that everyone's too concern is safety, improvement and fun!
The following users liked this post:
DesmoSD (02-24-2021)
#33
Hypothetically, is trail braking necessarily faster? I'm thinking of two things- first, I've always heard that Jackie Stewart teaches braking in a straight line, and while his active racing career was decades ago it was in cars that might be somewhat closer to "real world" than current race cars (maybe?). Second and very hypothetically at this point, I'm thinking about Fernando Alonso's famous fast turn-in during his world championship years (back when F1 cars had good tires). It seemed like his technique was to get to max cornering energy as fast as possible, so he couldn't have been trail-braking, right? Again, we're way off in the theoretical, but I've also heard that trail-braking is very speed-dependent, good for slow corners but only used to settle the car on fast corners. In short, isn't trail-braking a technique with specific uses, rather than it being "the right way"? BTW, I'm at the "read several books and did several track days years ago" level, at the low-end of expertise on this thread.
#34
Maintenance throttle before apex and unwinding of the wheel? Can't square that; no way. Thats a bad habit to get a driver into and sets them up for failure later coming out of an apex. Your always going to be coasting at some point in the transition through a turn sequence. We would agree you need to be smooth. But just because your entry is slow, smooth isn't a little throttle before your unwinding the wheel. Thats danger in the making.
But hey, looks like your in Texas, likely do COTA a lot. I'm way up north and run at Road America several times over the season. Maybe if your racing or instructing brings you north at Road America sometime, you could take me around for a few laps. I don't have the corner on right, maybe I'm missing something. Sincerely interested.
But hey, looks like your in Texas, likely do COTA a lot. I'm way up north and run at Road America several times over the season. Maybe if your racing or instructing brings you north at Road America sometime, you could take me around for a few laps. I don't have the corner on right, maybe I'm missing something. Sincerely interested.
#35
Hypothetically, is trail braking necessarily faster? I'm thinking of two things- first, I've always heard that Jackie Stewart teaches braking in a straight line, and while his active racing career was decades ago it was in cars that might be somewhat closer to "real world" than current race cars (maybe?). Second and very hypothetically at this point, I'm thinking about Fernando Alonso's famous fast turn-in during his world championship years (back when F1 cars had good tires). It seemed like his technique was to get to max cornering energy as fast as possible, so he couldn't have been trail-braking, right? Again, we're way off in the theoretical, but I've also heard that trail-braking is very speed-dependent, good for slow corners but only used to settle the car on fast corners. In short, isn't trail-braking a technique with specific uses, rather than it being "the right way"? BTW, I'm at the "read several books and did several track days years ago" level, at the low-end of expertise on this thread.
The following users liked this post:
Kineticdg (02-24-2021)
#36
Originally Posted by Kineticdg
Hypothetically, is trail braking necessarily faster? I'm thinking of two things- first, I've always heard that Jackie Stewart teaches braking in a straight line, and while his active racing career was decades ago it was in cars that might be somewhat closer to "real world" than current race cars (maybe?). Second and very hypothetically at this point, I'm thinking about Fernando Alonso's famous fast turn-in during his world championship years (back when F1 cars had good tires). It seemed like his technique was to get to max cornering energy as fast as possible, so he couldn't have been trail-braking, right? Again, we're way off in the theoretical, but I've also heard that trail-braking is very speed-dependent, good for slow corners but only used to settle the car on fast corners. In short, isn't trail-braking a technique with specific uses, rather than it being "the right way"? BTW, I'm at the "read several books and did several track days years ago" level, at the low-end of expertise on this thread.
#37
Originally Posted by ThomasCarreraGTS
Yeah, I have to disagree, but you can drive any way you want. You never want to be coasting on track. You're either on throttle, or on brakes. Coasting gives you zero control over the vehicle, and a 911 in particular is very sensitive to input, with it's massive rear weight bias. Keep in mind, driving in HPDE 1 is very different from competing in Time Trials, which itself is completely different from competing in wheel to wheel racing. I've done them all, and it's important to understand who you are instructing. My goal is to make sure my student has fun, and stays safe. Along the way, he/she learns a lot more about car control than they knew when they started out, and alway end the weekend much faster, safer and more confident than they started. if I'm teaching a race car driver, then we are talking a different set of goals and expectations. Building blocks....
The following 2 users liked this post by cwheeler:
bbinder (02-24-2021),
ThomasCarreraGTS (02-25-2021)
#38
I find trail-braking more necessary in the 911 than in other cars, like the BMW M3 I had before. Basically, the 911 front has no weight and runs on bicycle wheels, which makes it prone to understeer at turn in; the M3 had the engine up front and the same wide track tires on all 4 corners. Much more grip at turn in. But even in 911 cars, I still instruct beginners using the "a car is like a dog" analogy, ie it is willing, but can only do one thing at a time. So brake in straight line, then turn, etc.
Last edited by ThomasCarreraGTS; 02-25-2021 at 12:14 AM.
The following users liked this post:
ThomasCarreraGTS (02-25-2021)