Oil analysis report - high iron, copper, and magnesium. Should I be concerned?
#46
To the OP, modern performance engines can run 1 qrt per 1,000 miles and still be in spec, I think you mentioned your engine had always used this much.
Enjoy your car and just keep an eye on it, don't let this thread resolve into a rebuild your engine now, or your doomed to a scrapping your engine
Enjoy your car and just keep an eye on it, don't let this thread resolve into a rebuild your engine now, or your doomed to a scrapping your engine
#47
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
To the OP, modern performance engines can run 1 qrt per 1,000 miles and still be in spec, I think you mentioned your engine had always used this much.
Enjoy your car and just keep an eye on it, don't let this thread resolve into a rebuild your engine now, or your doomed to a scrapping your engine
Enjoy your car and just keep an eye on it, don't let this thread resolve into a rebuild your engine now, or your doomed to a scrapping your engine
Yes, I'm not worrying about the oil consumption at all since it's been like that since new. I have heavy oil grim on the outside of the throttle body intake so I think a lot of oil just got sucked into the engine due to the sub par AOS.
#48
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Carmel, CA
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Having just picked up a CPO 2006 C2S with 36,000 miles I have been following this and the IMS threads closely. Before Mobil 1 I used AMZOIL but for the past ten years have had excellent results with Redline in my other cars so would tend to stick with that rather than switching to MOTUL. Porsche recommends 0-40 but several posts on Rennlist suggest 5-40. I plan to switch from the fresh Mobil 1 in the 2006 and am interested in the logic of 5-40 vs 0-40--or some other weight. Any and all suggestions on alternatives would be appreciated.
Also, I am interested in recommendations on a good source for Oil analysis. In a pinch there is always an AMZOIL kit for $32 but I would expect there might me someone who has a better data base on Porsche's.
Thanks for the excellent thread.
Also, I am interested in recommendations on a good source for Oil analysis. In a pinch there is always an AMZOIL kit for $32 but I would expect there might me someone who has a better data base on Porsche's.
Thanks for the excellent thread.
#49
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
Having just picked up a CPO 2006 C2S with 36,000 miles I have been following this and the IMS threads closely. Before Mobil 1 I used AMZOIL but for the past ten years have had excellent results with Redline in my other cars so would tend to stick with that rather than switching to MOTUL. Porsche recommends 0-40 but several posts on Rennlist suggest 5-40. I plan to switch from the fresh Mobil 1 in the 2006 and am interested in the logic of 5-40 vs 0-40--or some other weight. Any and all suggestions on alternatives would be appreciated.
Also, I am interested in recommendations on a good source for Oil analysis. In a pinch there is always an AMZOIL kit for $32 but I would expect there might me someone who has a better data base on Porsche's.
Thanks for the excellent thread.
Also, I am interested in recommendations on a good source for Oil analysis. In a pinch there is always an AMZOIL kit for $32 but I would expect there might me someone who has a better data base on Porsche's.
Thanks for the excellent thread.
The other weight I may try is mobil 5w-50 (also Porsche approved) for its molybdenum. Will see. For oil analysis, Blackstone is quite popular.
#50
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Feb 2013
Location: Carmel, CA
Posts: 2
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Motul
Thanks Ahsai,
I will check out Blackstone.
As Motul is recommended by Porsche ,I would tend to go with that as it is a type 5 oil while Mobil 1 is a type 4. But, having said that, in the 1960s and 1970s before we had synthetic oils, I had great success with MoS2 molybdenum additives, particularly for curing sticky 2nd gearbox problems.
I will check out Blackstone.
As Motul is recommended by Porsche ,I would tend to go with that as it is a type 5 oil while Mobil 1 is a type 4. But, having said that, in the 1960s and 1970s before we had synthetic oils, I had great success with MoS2 molybdenum additives, particularly for curing sticky 2nd gearbox problems.
#51
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by pfbz
A perfectly running engine with moderately elevated copper values reported on a mail-in oil analysis is doomed... Just waiting for the con-rods to come crashing through the engine block?
Originally Posted by rossclifford
Enjoy your car and just keep an eye on it, don't let this thread resolve into a rebuild your engine now, or your doomed to a scrapping your engine
#52
Burning Brakes
That's the way I understood your post -- sometimes I think Flat 6 thinks that an M96 is code for a grenade!!
#53
Rennlist Member
Ahsai,
A thought/question/observation:
I have a C2 cab with 55k miles. Pretty close to your mileage. My UOA shows normal ranges for copper & iron with Motul 5-40. I change at 5k or 6 month intervals and always before winter sets in.
That is when the car drops from 3-4 days use to maybe as little as 1day in 2-3 weeks, depending on salty roads.
Looking back at some of the comments from Macster & others, about acids suspended in the oil, if you are running 5k or 3k oil changes that stretch to a year in the crankcase maybe the acid suspended in the oil is getting too long to work on your internal bits?
A thought/question/observation:
I have a C2 cab with 55k miles. Pretty close to your mileage. My UOA shows normal ranges for copper & iron with Motul 5-40. I change at 5k or 6 month intervals and always before winter sets in.
That is when the car drops from 3-4 days use to maybe as little as 1day in 2-3 weeks, depending on salty roads.
Looking back at some of the comments from Macster & others, about acids suspended in the oil, if you are running 5k or 3k oil changes that stretch to a year in the crankcase maybe the acid suspended in the oil is getting too long to work on your internal bits?