Trifecta
So how long do you expect a water pump to last? Mine lasted a little over 6 or 7 years and I didn't complain about it when I had to pay for it. Still not sure why you are so pissed about it.
And what exactly is "normal" driving? You don't want to see my definition of normal
And what exactly is "normal" driving? You don't want to see my definition of normal

When I first took the car in due to noise, they told me it was probably the water pump. I wasn't upset about that single item going out since I understand that things can break randomly, but when they called back and said pump, and RMS, and differential, and hood struts, I was pissed.
Most important thing here to me is that you shouldn't let the dealer do repairs out of warranty. That's just plain foolish in my opinion. Get a good independent and I'll bet the bill is close to half what you'd pay at the dealer. I'll bet you wouldn't be as pissed if it were only $1600 for all of that work.


