SHIFTING QUESTION
#31
Ironman 140.6
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Seriously, stop and ask yourself why you are doing this? Seems that every noob at the track wants to impress their instructor with their downshifting prowess. Instructors are quick to discourage this activity btw. Are you slowing the car down with each downshift approaching the corner or something (hopefully not). Approaching a corner you should be braking to reduce the cars speed and then rev match/downshift into the appropriate gear for the speed that you just slowed down too.
-Paul
-Paul
This has nothing to do with impressing anyone (no one else in the car to impress). It has far more to do with a driving rhythm around the track. As far as your statement
"Are you slowing the car down with each downshift approaching the corner or something (hopefully not)."
As I indicated in my original post I am rev matching the downshifts while braking at the same time. It may sound like a lot to someone who does not track their car, but in practice it happens very quickly and it helps insure that I don't screw the pooch with a mechanical over rev. As far as your assertion that this is a "novice" way around the track I have watched a lot of drivers that are faster and more experienced than me do it the very same way. Even F1 cars (with sequential automatic transmissions) hit each gear on the way down. I will occasionally skip a gear on the way down, but I prefer to touch them all.
Now the street is an entirely different story. I skip gears going up and down all the time.
#32
Ironman 140.6
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#33
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
hmm. You are entitled to your opinion. Also, didn't mean to call you a noob. However, why not and ask this question on the Race/DE forum about sequentially downshifting through the gears approaching a corner. FYI: I am normally at the track up to 2 weekends a month and instruct, not that it matters.
FWIW: I am pretty sure that telemetry data would prove that if your are threshold braking right up to the corner and only downshift once your are likely faster than trying to do say 2 heel-toe downshifts while slowing down. Let's say the two approaches prove absolutely equal due to a fabulously coordinated driver with perfectly crisp downshifts, isn't it still wearing out the equipment when the brakes are really doing all the work? Now, I have never had any trouble getting my car's into gear so I am not familiar with a 996 gearbox heating up issue.
FWIW: I am pretty sure that telemetry data would prove that if your are threshold braking right up to the corner and only downshift once your are likely faster than trying to do say 2 heel-toe downshifts while slowing down. Let's say the two approaches prove absolutely equal due to a fabulously coordinated driver with perfectly crisp downshifts, isn't it still wearing out the equipment when the brakes are really doing all the work? Now, I have never had any trouble getting my car's into gear so I am not familiar with a 996 gearbox heating up issue.
Last edited by Paul 996; 09-19-2007 at 12:30 PM. Reason: I hate typos
#35
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
hmm. You are entitled to your opinion. Also, didn't mean to call you a noob. However, why not and ask this question on the Race/DE forum about sequentially downshifting through the gears approaching a corner. FYI: I am normally at the track up to 2 weekends a month and instruct, not that it matters.
FWIW: I am pretty sure that telemetry data would prove that if your are threshold braking right up to the corner and only downshift once your are likely faster than trying to do say 2 heel-toe downshifts while slowing down. Let's say the two approaches prove absolutely equal due to a fabulously coordinated driver with perfectly crisp downshifts, isn't it still wearing out the equipment when the brakes are really doing all the work? Now, I have never had any trouble getting my car's into gear so I am not familiar with a 996 gearbox heating up issue.
FWIW: I am pretty sure that telemetry data would prove that if your are threshold braking right up to the corner and only downshift once your are likely faster than trying to do say 2 heel-toe downshifts while slowing down. Let's say the two approaches prove absolutely equal due to a fabulously coordinated driver with perfectly crisp downshifts, isn't it still wearing out the equipment when the brakes are really doing all the work? Now, I have never had any trouble getting my car's into gear so I am not familiar with a 996 gearbox heating up issue.
Jim
#36
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Jim,
Jim, Sounds good. Sound a little like you your talking about a little engine trail braking to rotate the car (a little drag in the back) which is completely useful....Really curious about rowing the gears w/o releasing the clutch.. What exactly does that accomplish or benefit? (honest question here). Feel free to PM if your so inclined as I am genuinely interested in things that I don't know.
FWIW: I used to row the gears performing spectacular sounding heal/toe downshifts into corners (with and w/o the clutch even) but then I learned better in using the brakes at 100% to slow the car down quickly and while doing so engaging the appropriate gear for my end speed. Now, initiating the rotation of the car using either a trailing brake (or Left foot braking) or engine braking is another thing altogether and a good one at that.
Maybe it is just a preference thing... but I stand by the fact that you are wearing out your equipment much less doing it my way.
BTW: Jim, I think my car is quickly and accidentally becoming your clone...3.6 X51, etc
Jim, Sounds good. Sound a little like you your talking about a little engine trail braking to rotate the car (a little drag in the back) which is completely useful....Really curious about rowing the gears w/o releasing the clutch.. What exactly does that accomplish or benefit? (honest question here). Feel free to PM if your so inclined as I am genuinely interested in things that I don't know.
FWIW: I used to row the gears performing spectacular sounding heal/toe downshifts into corners (with and w/o the clutch even) but then I learned better in using the brakes at 100% to slow the car down quickly and while doing so engaging the appropriate gear for my end speed. Now, initiating the rotation of the car using either a trailing brake (or Left foot braking) or engine braking is another thing altogether and a good one at that.
Maybe it is just a preference thing... but I stand by the fact that you are wearing out your equipment much less doing it my way.
BTW: Jim, I think my car is quickly and accidentally becoming your clone...3.6 X51, etc
![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#37
Three Wheelin'
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I've put it into first gear in several corners. One of them is on Buttonwillow. I don't think I've ever been over 4th gear though (on the track).
#38
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#39
Three Wheelin'
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Wow, those must be some fast tracks. I probably wouldn't have needed to use first gear if I had been using DOT tires, but with street tires I had to get the speed way down and then power out.
#40
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Jim,
Jim, Sounds good. Sound a little like you your talking about a little engine trail braking to rotate the car (a little drag in the back) which is completely useful....Really curious about rowing the gears w/o releasing the clutch.. What exactly does that accomplish or benefit? (honest question here). Feel free to PM if your so inclined as I am genuinely interested in things that I don't know.
FWIW: I used to row the gears performing spectacular sounding heal/toe downshifts into corners (with and w/o the clutch even) but then I learned better in using the brakes at 100% to slow the car down quickly and while doing so engaging the appropriate gear for my end speed. Now, initiating the rotation of the car using either a trailing brake (or Left foot braking) or engine braking is another thing altogether and a good one at that.
Maybe it is just a preference thing... but I stand by the fact that you are wearing out your equipment much less doing it my way.
BTW: Jim, I think my car is quickly and accidentally becoming your clone...3.6 X51, etc![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
Jim, Sounds good. Sound a little like you your talking about a little engine trail braking to rotate the car (a little drag in the back) which is completely useful....Really curious about rowing the gears w/o releasing the clutch.. What exactly does that accomplish or benefit? (honest question here). Feel free to PM if your so inclined as I am genuinely interested in things that I don't know.
FWIW: I used to row the gears performing spectacular sounding heal/toe downshifts into corners (with and w/o the clutch even) but then I learned better in using the brakes at 100% to slow the car down quickly and while doing so engaging the appropriate gear for my end speed. Now, initiating the rotation of the car using either a trailing brake (or Left foot braking) or engine braking is another thing altogether and a good one at that.
Maybe it is just a preference thing... but I stand by the fact that you are wearing out your equipment much less doing it my way.
BTW: Jim, I think my car is quickly and accidentally becoming your clone...3.6 X51, etc
![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
As for running through the gears, in an enduro or even a 30 minute club race, the transmission would get hot enough that when skipping gears you would go to stick it in 2nd or 3rd and it would be like there was no gate. It just felt like mush. This only happened in high speed to low speed corners like 5th to 2nd shifts. Adding solid motor mounts helped but didn't solve the problem. A better grade of trans fluid didn't have much impact. Adjusting the cables did nothing. The only real solution to smooth shifting all the time was running through the gears. My mechanic explained it but I'm sure I'd quote him incorrectly. As I said before, I tried the method after the discussion on the racing/DE forum and was amazed how much smoother the shifting was. The side benefit was that you always know what gear you are in. Again, give it a try. It might not be for you. BTW, there are many corners where I skip gears. It all depends on what works best in a certain spot.
Jim
#41
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
They are pretty fast tracks.
Daytona has two different spots where you hit 6th. I hit a top speed there of 161. That's according to my data acq. The speedo read much higher. It's extra exciting because it's very rough banking and there's a wall a few feet to your right.
At Road America you're only in 6th for a couple of moments on the front straight. In a stock car you won't get out of 5th but it is a very fast track.
At Brainerd you hit 6th on the mile long front straight and carry the speed through T1. In my 996 I downshift to 5th for T2 but that's almost as fast. In my cup car I leave it in 6th for both. Sort of crazy actually.
Jim
#42
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Jim,
Interesting stuff, something to keep in mind if I ever start having weird transmission probs. I know what you mean about the motormounts.. Sometimes 3rd is hard to find mid corner accelerating out of long sweeper in 2nd due.
The x51 is coming by way of a new 3.6 being put into my 99 where a 3.4 used to breathe and live.
Cheers man
Interesting stuff, something to keep in mind if I ever start having weird transmission probs. I know what you mean about the motormounts.. Sometimes 3rd is hard to find mid corner accelerating out of long sweeper in 2nd due.
The x51 is coming by way of a new 3.6 being put into my 99 where a 3.4 used to breathe and live.
Cheers man
![Cheers](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/beerchug.gif)
#43
Burning Brakes
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Anglo-Irish Mongrel in Delaware
Posts: 817
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
So:
Yes, driving causes RPM.
No, you don't have to drive everywhere at maximum RPM.
Every engine has a lifespan. Partly it's the number of hours (which is what they measure for aircraft engines). Partly it's the number of revolutions which each cause a tiny amount of wear. So cruising at lower revs is one way to extend the life of the engine.
To back up Tippy's statement that higher gears extend engine life, here are two overdrive manufacturers and an article on overdrive, all of which state that overdrives (ie higher gearing) extend engine life and reduce wear.
Overdrive article
Ford overdrive unit
Tremec 5-speed add-on
To back up Tippy's statement that higher gears extend engine life, here are two overdrive manufacturers and an article on overdrive, all of which state that overdrives (ie higher gearing) extend engine life and reduce wear.
Overdrive article
Ford overdrive unit
Tremec 5-speed add-on
No, you don't have to drive everywhere at maximum RPM.
#45
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
OK Let me ask this. Any of you guys track your car (or just drive spiritedly)? If so.... do you hit every gear on a decel into a turn? Bet you don't get great track times going 6, 5, 4, 3..... hell it would take half the straightaway just to downshift. You can shift 1 to 4, 2 to 5, 6 to 3....... your not going to hurt anything as long as you don't overrev in the high end and don't lug in the low end.
So going from 5-4-3-2 is pretty simple, and effective, and doesn't affect lap times negatively.
Check this video out to catch a 4-3 / 3-2 down shift at 2:05-2:08: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrEpfVV14gc
At 2:08 the car comes out of a corner in 2nd, runs up to redline, then to 3rd for a brief instant, then back to 2nd for the next turn. Sometimes I hit the rev limiter trying to push the RPMs really high after the turn in (Turn 12).
-td