Suspension refresh -- Genuine Porsche versus OEM
#16
i feel so invisable sometimes.
https://www.fcpeuro.com/Porsche-part...b=9&d=15675&v=
https://www.fcpeuro.com/Porsche-part...b=9&d=15675&v=
https://www.fcpeuro.com/Porsche-part...b=9&d=15675&v=
https://www.fcpeuro.com/Porsche-part...b=9&d=15675&v=
#17
Please someone who know more correct me if I'm wrong but I was always of the understanding that your could by parts as Porsche, OE, and OEM. My understanding of OE was that designated that the part was from the original manufacturer of that particular part supplied to Porsche but not the having to pay the "Porsche tax"?
#18
OP - Crap-ton of threads here with plenty of info on who used what and why. If you have the wherewithal to do some ‘footwork’ you’ll save plenty of scratch. If you just want to get it done less painstakingly and now, do what your indie suggests. I had fun researching and gathering all the parts for my suspension rebuild. As someone, not De Jeeper, (of course-he’s invisible) hints at; TRW makes all the OE control arms (including GT3). Meyle and Lemförder, as well as TRW, make nearly all of the rest. OE for top mounts, nuts and bolts. OE links are fine for non-adjustable sways. Pick your poison for the flavor of springs, dampers and sways,; and Bob’s your uncle, your done. Simple, right? FCP usually has a good mix for their kit, but the way parts supply is these days, they may not have the ‘best’ option for a particular part available.
Bottom line: Get OE when it makes sense. Avoid needlessly paying the Porsche tax when feasible. Just a little shopping around will save you at least $500 for a full redo. A fresh suspension is transcendental for a 996.
Bottom line: Get OE when it makes sense. Avoid needlessly paying the Porsche tax when feasible. Just a little shopping around will save you at least $500 for a full redo. A fresh suspension is transcendental for a 996.
Last edited by hatchetf15; 02-26-2022 at 12:40 AM.
#19
Thanks to everyone so far, it's been very enlightening.
Thanks. No problem with doing the footwork, but this site is basically a series of huge silos; this is the 996 silo, and everything relating to that vintage is all piled together. Google does a half decent job even so. Now that I have some idea who the true OE manufacturers are, I can use those as breadcrumbs to dig for more.
I've also run into supply chain joy already, on my first order no less. I'm looking forward to that transcendental moment but it may be more of a wait than I had hoped.
OP - Crap-ton of threads here with plenty of info on who used what and why. If you have the wherewithal to do some ‘footwork’ you’ll save plenty of scratch. If you just want to get it done less painstakingly and now, do what your indie suggests. I had fun researching and gathering all the parts for my suspension rebuild. As someone, not De Jeeper, (of course-he’s invisible) hints at; TRW makes all the OE control arms (including GT3). Meyle and Lemförder, as well as TRW, make nearly all of the rest. OE for top mounts, nuts and bolts. OE links are fine for non-adjustable sways. Pick your poison for the flavor of springs, dampers and sways,; and Bob’s your uncle, your done. Simple, right? FCP usually has a good mix for their kit, but the way parts supply is these days, they may not have the ‘best’ option for a particular part available.
Bottom line: Get OE when it makes sense. Avoid needlessly paying the Porsche tax when feasible. Just a little shopping around will save you at least $500 for a full redo. A fresh suspension is transcendental for a 996.
Bottom line: Get OE when it makes sense. Avoid needlessly paying the Porsche tax when feasible. Just a little shopping around will save you at least $500 for a full redo. A fresh suspension is transcendental for a 996.
I've also run into supply chain joy already, on my first order no less. I'm looking forward to that transcendental moment but it may be more of a wait than I had hoped.
#20
TRW and Lemförder are both owned by ZF. The last set of GT3 LCA's I got were TRW castings in a Lemförder box marked made in Germany. Other Lemförder parts I have recently gotten have been marked made in France, Tunisia, Italy, and Turkey. The Meyle stuff can be a bit of a crap shoot, most is fine and some is trash. I have some Meyle front drop links that are marked made in Turkey, probably in the same factory as the Lemförder ones, which look fine but I can't use them with my adjustable front sway bar. The ones to avoid at all costs IMO are anything by Hamburg Technik which is all Chinese made.
#21
I mostly went through FCP Euro, but they were out if stock on some items. Outside of Pelican, Germanautoparts.com and Autohausaz.com also carry parts in stock. I ordered most last October, I don’t remember what exactly came from where. Rockauto had the best pricing on struts.
#23
Here's a great video from FCP on OE vs Genuine. Around 7:00, you'll notice them mentioning in some cases you'll buy an OE part and it actually has the BMW logo in this case, ground off of it. I have seen this.
The following users liked this post:
wdb (02-26-2022)
#24
Here's a great video from FCP on OE vs Genuine. Around 7:00, you'll notice them mentioning in some cases you'll buy an OE part and it actually has the BMW logo in this case, ground off of it. I have seen this.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=In8LBWBipbk
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=In8LBWBipbk
/thread