Recap of the SAI circuit
#288
Burning Brakes
Fantastic! Looks like my kit will be mailed to me sometime this week. In prepping for the installation, I went back and re-read this entire posting. Early on, someone speculated that the firmware design for the 97 and 98 model 993's might be different from the earlier 993's and that the CPU might be looking for a "change" in voltage rather than a drop to zero. There were several messages exchanged on this bit of speculation; but, no solution mentioned, though Lewis thought that it would be a simple redesign of the circuit that is currently being fabricated.
So, I have a couple of questions:
1. How long will it take to experience a "failure" of the device to prevent a fault code and CEL trip? Will I see the failure instantaneously?
2. How difficult will the redesign be and will it be a modification to the existing circuits installed for this test? Or, would it be better to get a newly wired assembly?
Just trying to anticipate the worst case scenario since the posters seemed to understand the technology but were unsure of the firmware design differences.
Sorry for the long post. And, for my paranoia!
So, I have a couple of questions:
1. How long will it take to experience a "failure" of the device to prevent a fault code and CEL trip? Will I see the failure instantaneously?
2. How difficult will the redesign be and will it be a modification to the existing circuits installed for this test? Or, would it be better to get a newly wired assembly?
Just trying to anticipate the worst case scenario since the posters seemed to understand the technology but were unsure of the firmware design differences.
Sorry for the long post. And, for my paranoia!
#289
Lewis,
Thanks again to you and your wonderfull wife for your efforts.
I am wondering if the two of you would accept a Starbucks gift card as a token of my appreciation on this project?
Thanks,
Phil
Thanks again to you and your wonderfull wife for your efforts.
I am wondering if the two of you would accept a Starbucks gift card as a token of my appreciation on this project?
Thanks,
Phil
#291
"In summary, each unit cost $10.74 to fabricate and ship. I have tried to keep the unit cost as low as possible".
Lewis
Are you kidding me?I can't believe this is all you are charging us for these!!We all need to get together and send you some Costco/ Starbucks gift cards with are payments.I think if we all send Costco gift cards and everybody does it you can buy your wife something nice for Xmas.You guys in?
____________
Lewis
Are you kidding me?I can't believe this is all you are charging us for these!!We all need to get together and send you some Costco/ Starbucks gift cards with are payments.I think if we all send Costco gift cards and everybody does it you can buy your wife something nice for Xmas.You guys in?
____________
#293
Super Moderator
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
"In summary, each unit cost $10.74 to fabricate and ship. I have tried to keep the unit cost as low as possible".
Lewis
Are you kidding me?I can't believe this is all you are charging us for these!!We all need to get together and send you some Costco/ Starbucks gift cards with are payments.I think if we all send Costco gift cards and everybody does it you can buy your wife something nice for Xmas.You guys in?
____________
Lewis
Are you kidding me?I can't believe this is all you are charging us for these!!We all need to get together and send you some Costco/ Starbucks gift cards with are payments.I think if we all send Costco gift cards and everybody does it you can buy your wife something nice for Xmas.You guys in?
____________
I have about 80 hours of labor into this batch of 100 (schematic capture, PCB layout, parts selection and ordering, soldering/assembly, electrical test, PCB washing, packaging/shipping/paperwork tracking).
80 hours (4800 minutes) soundsl like a lot, but for 100 units, it comes out to about 48 minutes per unit.
To be honest, I never expected so many members would be interested in such a thing. I went into this thinking I would build a few, but it became apparent early on that this was a much more useful tool for folks.
(I am mechanically challenged, so I don't work on my cars, not even oil changes. I won't even be keeping one for myself)
As I stated early on in this thread, I am not a RL sponsor, so I can not charge more than my costs for these units.
#294
Super Moderator
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
#295
Super Moderator
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
The next shipping date is this Monday (11/22).
My wife and I will be packaging up the units this Sunday for those who have sent their name/shipping address via PM since the last shipment went out.
My wife and I will be packaging up the units this Sunday for those who have sent their name/shipping address via PM since the last shipment went out.
#296
Burning Brakes
OK guys - here's the deal. Larry is not allowed to charge more than his cost, but we are not precluded from sending more if we wish to. So, what would be an appropriate amount? Or, we can each make that call individually, and that's OK with me.
#297
Just a thought
I know Lewis can not or won't ask for a reasonable amount of money for his time doing this for all of us Rennlisters,but that does not stop us from including something extra.I will be paying him and his wife $25.00 for each of the three units he has sent me.It is the right thing to do and still a very cheep price to pay for the issue it resolves.I hope everyone will do the same.
#298
Super Moderator
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs More Cowbell
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
I know Lewis can not or won't ask for a reasonable amount of money for his time doing this for all of us Rennlisters,but that does not stop us from including something extra.I will be paying him and his wife $25.00 for each of the three units he has sent me.It is the right thing to do and still a very cheep price to pay for the issue it resolves.I hope everyone will do the same.
I did this for the RL 993 community simply because it's something I was able to do (I've been doing electronics since before I was 10 yrs old) and therefore felt that offering to do so was the right thing to do.
My regret was simply not having enough waking hours in a day to finish these more quickly, that's all. I didn't want folks waiting or thinking I forgot. I didnt want to accept payment until the member received it and was happy with it. That is why I have tried to post regular updates.
I will upload all of the design files (schematic and PCB files) so anyone else can produce these. All of the part numbers are on the schematic and the enclosure info has been posted as well.
#299
Rennlist Member
I recently searched regarding the dreaded SAI Check Engine light. Unfortunately, mine came on during one of the final runs of the season. If there is a second run, could you put me down for one complete unit plus enclosure?
I am completely amazed by your ability and generosity. I am anticipating sending more than the cost of the unit for your engineering ability and time that went into creating these.
I am completely amazed by your ability and generosity. I am anticipating sending more than the cost of the unit for your engineering ability and time that went into creating these.
#300
Rennlist Member