logan2z

In my quest for a 993, I've come across one I'm interested in at an authorized Porsche dealership in Central Virginia (Euroclassics Porsche). Since there doesn't appear to be an independent Porsche mechanic anywhere nearby, the dealer offered to have his master tech perform the PPI. Obviously there's a conflict of interest here, although it seems like Euroclassics and their mechanic (Wayne) have a good reputation here on Rennlist. Under the circumstances, would you feel comfortable having the dealership's own mechanic perform the inspection? Unfortunately, I'm on the West Coast and can't easily view the car for myself.

RallyJon

Only if they'll CPO it.

goofballdeluxe

Nope.

Mark in Baltimore

You've got to be joking.

logan2z

I guess that answers that question

Bull

As much as I would like to believe it could be done and turn out well....no.

cspaldi

I know nothing good or bad about the dealer, but try: http://www.lufteknic.com for a PPI. I also know nothing good or bad about lufteknic, but have seen them at a local car show and they seemed like a nice group.

six gun

+ 1

travanx

I actually wouldn't trust a dealer to fix any problems found from a PPI.

Marv

Some dealers I would feel comfortable. That is, there are a few dealers I feel I could trust. However, that is a case-by-case basis.

It's a two-way street. Good dealers look for good customers. If you worked with them in the past you can build a relationship of trust both ways. There are dealers that place integrity first. Sadly, there are those that don't.

If you haven't already worked with this dealer, then it is a crap shoot. My last car I bought with both a warranty and a CPO. The dealer failed to complete the CPO paperwork, but they made it right, kept me informed of their progress, and resolved the issue quickly. They appreciated my business in the past and want to make sure that I am a returning customer. I will be when the time is right.

Your mileage may vary and it also depends on how disposable your income is. If you earn $500K a year, a $30K gamble is not a big deal. If you earn $50K a year you probably can't afford a mistake.

stace

don't forget to ask for a "Rennfax" - lots of talent out there

Kika

would you let the wolf guard your sheep?

In theory it can work, but there are too many reasons for it not to work.

Get an Independent PPI, of YOUR choosing

Rick J.

As a Porsche tech who has alway's worked for independent shops........NO!! You would ba amazed at some stuff i've seen come out of the dealers.

Reddy Kilowatt

Of course not.

95C4VanIsle

Wayne may be a good, if not great, mechanic. For all I know Wayne could, or could not be, be a contributor to the DIY information on RL. But the bottom line is Wayne gets a paycheck from Euroclassics, a company that sells cars. If Wayne's PPI nix's the sale of the car, it could come back to haunt him, especially with the downturn in the economy.

I was faced with a similar situation purchasing my Porsche 1 1/2 years ago. I decided to pass on the car. A better car came along, passed PPI with flying colours, and I couldn't be happier.

Best of luck on whatever car you purchase.