Mixing Tires
#16
Originally Posted by Father of 3
What about on a toyota minivan? I have some toyos on the front but are having a hard time finding them for the rears. Mix and match on a minivan okay?
#17
Three Wheelin'
If you mix tires the car will feel VERY unstable at high speed. I experienced this with mixing Yokohama's S1 Z in the front and Yokohama AVS N1 sport in the back. Bought a set for the front and all is good now.
Regards
Regards
#18
Rennlist Member
I had an awful mix of tires for awhile, and even though the car was not at its best, for street use I got away with it.
Of course, I'm driving the car close to 10K miles a year, so tires are not the long term commitment as they are on other vehicles.
Of course, I'm driving the car close to 10K miles a year, so tires are not the long term commitment as they are on other vehicles.
#19
Rennlist Member
Well Terry....writting...
Originally Posted by Terry Adams
Martin, glad we caught you in the right mood for a response.
#20
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
what you guys have to think is that in a normal situation where everyone is driving at 5/10ths calling it fast, you may not notice an issue. Come an emergency situation though like an avoidance and mixed tires will have a detrimental effect. It happened to me with a rented Boxster a few years ago with mixed tires. I can tell you it was not pretty and it scared the living daylights out of me. You have to think that different compounds and tread have different characteristics on the limit. The 911 is already an oddball in weight distribution. Different compounds will have a detrimental effect on the limit and how the car responds.
Never play with different compounds on a 911.
Never play with different compounds on a 911.
#21
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Originally Posted by Martin S.
dictates that you replace with the same brand, or transition to a new brand with all four (4) new tires. You are NOT driving a goddam'd Pinto, it's a PORSCHE 993.
You know you can walk around with different shoes on your feet. Why on the left foot, you could have a nice shinny wingtip from your grandpappy, and on right foot, assuming your feet differ left to right, you could wear a clown shoe. It would be functiuonal, but, you'd look like an idiot...get my drift????
PS I am on pain killers (Vicodan) {bad Tooth ache}, so I may be a little off color...I just can't help it.'
You know you can walk around with different shoes on your feet. Why on the left foot, you could have a nice shinny wingtip from your grandpappy, and on right foot, assuming your feet differ left to right, you could wear a clown shoe. It would be functiuonal, but, you'd look like an idiot...get my drift????
PS I am on pain killers (Vicodan) {bad Tooth ache}, so I may be a little off color...I just can't help it.'
#22
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Originally Posted by DJF1
what you guys have to think is that in a normal situation where everyone is driving at 5/10ths calling it fast, you may not notice an issue. Come an emergency situation though like an avoidance and mixed tires will have a detrimental effect. It happened to me with a rented Boxster a few years ago with mixed tires. I can tell you it was not pretty and it scared the living daylights out of me. You have to think that different compounds and tread have different characteristics on the limit. The 911 is already an oddball in weight distribution. Different compounds will have a detrimental effect on the limit and how the car responds.
Never play with different compounds on a 911.
Never play with different compounds on a 911.
#23
Phlat Black Guru
Rennlist
Lifetime Member
- Times 2
Rennlist
Lifetime Member
- Times 2
Join Date: May 2001
Location: Back In RI...............
Posts: 4,484
Likes: 0
Received 1 Like
on
1 Post
Originally Posted by Greg Fishman
Yet another good post. It would pay others to listen to these two guys.
I read on the al gore web that its cool, and ok to mix tires plus it save lots of money.. oh, and I also read that the stock shocks on a 993 will last forever......
#27
Three Wheelin'
PUH LEEEEZE.
You've got to be smoking your socks if you think "mixing tires" with matching pairs on each axle in and of itself creates a magically dangerous situation. Now if you're leaving a pair of tires on the car that are dry rotting from age or are crappy tires to begin with, I understand. But when you've got good tires like P-zeros on the front and good tires like PS-2s on the rear - I'm trying to figure out what physics makes this so dangerous.
On the track, the car is going to behave differently. Is it that different from changing sway bars or brake pads? Running different tire pressures?
Help me out here!
You've got to be smoking your socks if you think "mixing tires" with matching pairs on each axle in and of itself creates a magically dangerous situation. Now if you're leaving a pair of tires on the car that are dry rotting from age or are crappy tires to begin with, I understand. But when you've got good tires like P-zeros on the front and good tires like PS-2s on the rear - I'm trying to figure out what physics makes this so dangerous.
On the track, the car is going to behave differently. Is it that different from changing sway bars or brake pads? Running different tire pressures?
Help me out here!
#28
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by black ice
PUH LEEEEZE.
You've got to be smoking your socks if you think "mixing tires" with matching pairs on each axle in and of itself creates a magically dangerous situation. Now if you're leaving a pair of tires on the car that are dry rotting from age or are crappy tires to begin with, I understand. But when you've got good tires like P-zeros on the front and good tires like PS-2s on the rear - I'm trying to figure out what physics makes this so dangerous.
On the track, the car is going to behave differently. Is it that different from changing sway bars or brake pads? Running different tire pressures?
Help me out here!
You've got to be smoking your socks if you think "mixing tires" with matching pairs on each axle in and of itself creates a magically dangerous situation. Now if you're leaving a pair of tires on the car that are dry rotting from age or are crappy tires to begin with, I understand. But when you've got good tires like P-zeros on the front and good tires like PS-2s on the rear - I'm trying to figure out what physics makes this so dangerous.
On the track, the car is going to behave differently. Is it that different from changing sway bars or brake pads? Running different tire pressures?
Help me out here!
Like the threads where people ask about whether it's okay to patch a tire for the track, you'll find lots of different responses. Part of the issue in mixing tires is making sure that grip and response levels are the same between two different types of tires. Mix an old pair of Goodyear F-1 tires on the front with a set of fresh Hoosiers and you will definitely experience some unusual handling characteristics...if you push it hard enough. Part of being a good driver (and I know we're all phenomenal drivers, right?) is knowing to to adapt to changing handling situations. On the track, your car may be understeering for an hour and then suddenly become tail happy. As a driver, on the street or on the track, it is up to you to be aware of this and compensate for it. Now, factor in a situation where the handling characteristic may have changed from the past five years to different handling after changing tires; I maintain that, as a driver, one should be able to adapt to this relatively untaxing dynamic scenario.
On this board, it is highly unpopular to make this statement, but I have mixed two different types of tires and, gasp, driven them on the track, yes, the track(!) with zero histrionics or catastrophic situations. Just like saying that it is always okay to mix different types of tires, it is just as incorrect to state that mixing tires will result in disaster and/or is always inadvisable. One must assess the individual case and make an assessment based on the facts, not sweeping generalizations.
Flame on. Don't care.
#29
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Originally Posted by Mark in Baltimore
I could not agree more.
Like the threads where people ask about whether it's okay to patch a tire for the track, you'll find lots of different responses. Part of the issue in mixing tires is making sure that grip and response levels are the same between two different types of tires. Mix an old pair of Goodyear F-1 tires on the front with a set of fresh Hoosiers and you will definitely experience some unusual handling characteristics...if you push it hard enough. Part of being a good driver (and I know we're all phenomenal drivers, right?) is knowing to to adapt to changing handling situations. On the track, your car may be understeering for an hour and then suddenly become tail happy. As a driver, on the street or on the track, it is up to you to be aware of this and compensate for it. Now, factor in a situation where the handling characteristic may have changed from the past five years to different handling after changing tires; I maintain that, as a driver, one should be able to adapt to this relatively untaxing dynamic scenario.
On this board, it is highly unpopular to make this statement, but I have mixed two different types of tires and, gasp, driven them on the track, yes, the track(!) with zero histrionics or catastrophic situations. Just like saying that it is always okay to mix different types of tires, it is just as incorrect to state that mixing tires will result in disaster and/or is always inadvisable. One must assess the individual case and make an assessment based on the facts, not sweeping generalizations.
Flame on. Don't care.
Like the threads where people ask about whether it's okay to patch a tire for the track, you'll find lots of different responses. Part of the issue in mixing tires is making sure that grip and response levels are the same between two different types of tires. Mix an old pair of Goodyear F-1 tires on the front with a set of fresh Hoosiers and you will definitely experience some unusual handling characteristics...if you push it hard enough. Part of being a good driver (and I know we're all phenomenal drivers, right?) is knowing to to adapt to changing handling situations. On the track, your car may be understeering for an hour and then suddenly become tail happy. As a driver, on the street or on the track, it is up to you to be aware of this and compensate for it. Now, factor in a situation where the handling characteristic may have changed from the past five years to different handling after changing tires; I maintain that, as a driver, one should be able to adapt to this relatively untaxing dynamic scenario.
On this board, it is highly unpopular to make this statement, but I have mixed two different types of tires and, gasp, driven them on the track, yes, the track(!) with zero histrionics or catastrophic situations. Just like saying that it is always okay to mix different types of tires, it is just as incorrect to state that mixing tires will result in disaster and/or is always inadvisable. One must assess the individual case and make an assessment based on the facts, not sweeping generalizations.
Flame on. Don't care.
My self I'm driven by my own personal experience on the matter. The fact is that noone can say for sure that mixing tires is safe. It may work, it may backfire. Just think in slippery conditions the effect of the different compounds, tread and character of a tire. It effects braking, balance and adhesion.
Granted a good driver will drive around most of the issues, but you have logged thousands of hours probably on your 911, not many people can say that even on this very board...
Respectfully then, I believe that the correct advise is not to mix tires, playing it on the safe side always...
#30
Instructor
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Flatlands of Illinois
Posts: 245
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by DJF1
Hey Mark, you know how much I respect you and your opinion. I feel that this particular situation is a very sensitive area to give an otherwise advise on a public forum contrary to what the manufacturer states, as at the end of the day it is a safety matter.
My self I'm driven by my own personal experience on the matter. The fact is that noone can say for sure that mixing tires is safe. It may work, it may backfire. Just think in slippery conditions the effect of the different compounds, tread and character of a tire. It effects braking, balance and adhesion.
Granted a good driver will drive around most of the issues, but you have logged thousands of hours probably on your 911, not many people can say that even on this very board...
Respectfully then, I believe that the correct advise is not to mix tires, playing it on the safe side always...
My self I'm driven by my own personal experience on the matter. The fact is that noone can say for sure that mixing tires is safe. It may work, it may backfire. Just think in slippery conditions the effect of the different compounds, tread and character of a tire. It effects braking, balance and adhesion.
Granted a good driver will drive around most of the issues, but you have logged thousands of hours probably on your 911, not many people can say that even on this very board...
Respectfully then, I believe that the correct advise is not to mix tires, playing it on the safe side always...
Pete