NUb question about the valve guide wear & SAI problems
#1
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
NUb question about the valve guide wear & SAI problems
I'm starting the process of trying to learn as much as I can about the 993 so that when I'm ready to buy (Spring or Summer0, I'll have the knowledge to buy a good car (like I did with my 944).
Anyway, I understand that the 993 engines need valve guide / top end work when they hit 80k - 100k(?) miles, to the tune of $10,000. I also have read that the '95's computer doesn't produce the CEL like the later ones.
Question is, if I buy a 96-97 with let's say - 30k miles on it, and eventually put another 30k miles on it - will the CEL problem not be an issue due to the low miles? In other words, if any 993 I buy winds up having less than 80k miles if/when I sell it, does it matter what year car I buy?
Avoiding a top end rebuild would be a nice thing, especially since my wife and two young kids need to eat
Thanks for you patience!!
Anyway, I understand that the 993 engines need valve guide / top end work when they hit 80k - 100k(?) miles, to the tune of $10,000. I also have read that the '95's computer doesn't produce the CEL like the later ones.
Question is, if I buy a 96-97 with let's say - 30k miles on it, and eventually put another 30k miles on it - will the CEL problem not be an issue due to the low miles? In other words, if any 993 I buy winds up having less than 80k miles if/when I sell it, does it matter what year car I buy?
Avoiding a top end rebuild would be a nice thing, especially since my wife and two young kids need to eat
Thanks for you patience!!
Last edited by AndyK; 02-06-2007 at 12:45 PM.
#2
Weathergirl
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I think you're trying to apply precise logic to a highly variable problem. You could buy that pristine 30k mile 993 for top dollar, drive it home and have the CEL come on the next day. Of you could drive it for years and never have the problem.
If I were you, and I was looking for a OBDII 993, I would want a previous owner who was completely aware of the problem and up front about it and had cleaned the ports and replaced the {edit: SAI} valve in the past. Dealers tend to say, "Que? No comprendo" and look at the floor shuffling their feet when you mention the issue.
But the one thing that all 993 buyers must have as a prerequisite for ownership is $5-7k in the bank beyond what you pay for the car. Go into it with your eyes open and a good attitude or you'll worry yourself to death with all the expensive things that can go wrong with these cars.
If I were you, and I was looking for a OBDII 993, I would want a previous owner who was completely aware of the problem and up front about it and had cleaned the ports and replaced the {edit: SAI} valve in the past. Dealers tend to say, "Que? No comprendo" and look at the floor shuffling their feet when you mention the issue.
But the one thing that all 993 buyers must have as a prerequisite for ownership is $5-7k in the bank beyond what you pay for the car. Go into it with your eyes open and a good attitude or you'll worry yourself to death with all the expensive things that can go wrong with these cars.
Last edited by RallyJon; 02-06-2007 at 01:00 PM.
#3
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Austin
Posts: 388
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
First: it is correct to state that 95 models aren't subject to the SAI issue which causes the CEL, due to the fact 95's are OBDI cars.
Second: I do not necessarily agree that 993 engines have a premature valve guide wear problem, any more than any air cooled 911 engine has that problem. It is not a correct statement that 993s generally will need valve guide work/top end when they hit 80k-100k.
Lastly, when you say 'CEL' you are really referring to the CEL caused by SAI. SAI in my view is a separate issue from valve guide wear.
There are those that disagree with this viewpoint, of course.
Second: I do not necessarily agree that 993 engines have a premature valve guide wear problem, any more than any air cooled 911 engine has that problem. It is not a correct statement that 993s generally will need valve guide work/top end when they hit 80k-100k.
Lastly, when you say 'CEL' you are really referring to the CEL caused by SAI. SAI in my view is a separate issue from valve guide wear.
There are those that disagree with this viewpoint, of course.
#4
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by 98993c2s
Lastly, when you say 'CEL' you are really referring to the CEL caused by SAI. SAI in my view is a separate issue from valve guide wear.
There are those that disagree with this viewpoint, of course.
There are those that disagree with this viewpoint, of course.
I agree about having the extra just-in-case $$ for unforseen problems. I just would hate to buy a clean car and have to put another $10k into it a month later!
#6
Rennlist Member
If you pay $10k for a tpo end rebuild you are getting "jacked". I just had mine done a few months back and paid $8k. However, I put in an RS Clutch/FS, cat bypass, wires, plugs, distrib rebuild, and a whole host of other things too. For just the top end it figured out to be about $4250.
#7
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
The worst thing I've read about these SAI / CEL issues is it's an expensive repair that really isn't necessary and doesn't improve performance. Is that true?
Do the OBD1 cars have clogged SAIs, but because the computer doesn't care, the issue never comes up? Is it worth passing on a 96-98 car to avoid the OBDII hassle?
Do the OBD1 cars have clogged SAIs, but because the computer doesn't care, the issue never comes up? Is it worth passing on a 96-98 car to avoid the OBDII hassle?
Trending Topics
#8
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jun 2003
Location: Orange County, CA
Posts: 494
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Keep searching the past threads on this issue.
I got my first CEL due to SAI at about 48K miles. I had the ports flushed for about $1,000.
As I understand the Valve guide issue, it is not an issue unless you are burning excess oil. More than a quart in 1K miles.
Keep searching and asking questions. You will find the right vehicle.
I got my first CEL due to SAI at about 48K miles. I had the ports flushed for about $1,000.
As I understand the Valve guide issue, it is not an issue unless you are burning excess oil. More than a quart in 1K miles.
Keep searching and asking questions. You will find the right vehicle.
#9
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Huntington Beach, CA
Posts: 1,353
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Originally Posted by 98993c2s
First: it is correct to state that 95 models aren't subject to the SAI issue which causes the CEL, due to the fact 95's are OBDI cars.
Originally Posted by 98993c2s
Lastly, when you say 'CEL' you are really referring to the CEL caused by SAI. SAI in my view is a separate issue from valve guide wear.
#10
Weathergirl
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
If your oil consumption is well within spec
#11
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Originally Posted by RallyJon
How will you know that before you have the car? Dealer won't know, and seller might lie. No seller in his right mind would ever allow oil consumption as a sale contingency.
#12
Nordschleife Master
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Neither Here Nor There
Posts: 5,351
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
5 Posts
Originally Posted by RallyJon
If I were you, and I was looking for a OBDII 993, I would want a previous owner who was completely aware of the problem and up front about it and had cleaned the ports and replaced the ISV valve in the past.
The ISV (idle stabilizer valve) is used to maintain a smooth and properly adjusted idle.
I believe you meant the SAI check valve, which can be stuck open, thus permitting exhaust contaminants to travel up the SAI ports and deposit their by-products therein.
#13
Weathergirl
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
If a top end's been done properly you're in the clear. Also, given the irrationality of the used 993 market, you can probably beat the price down more since the car is no longer "pristine" "untouched" "no stories".
Yes, Jeff, that's what I meant.
Yes, Jeff, that's what I meant.
#14
Nordschleife Master
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Neither Here Nor There
Posts: 5,351
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
5 Posts
Originally Posted by AndyK
I guess if a seller has already had the ports cleaned, or, rebuilt the top end, you can guess the issue has been fixed?
Even if the above is properly completed, the fix is more of a "restart the clock" type fix. The system itself remains unchanged in most cases and thus after X amount of miles or other variables, the clogged ports can come back. But with reasonable attention (i.e. periodically changing the SAI check valve), you can skew the odds in your favor.
#15
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Some rebuilders will enlarge the passages to further prevent clogging ... just an FYI.
However, do not assume it's been done correctly, the previous owner of my car spent $3800 with a shop to get the car past emissions. From the paperwork and what I have found, they basically changed out every hose, nut and bolt on the intake, plus the MAF sensor, added a ton of labor, got the car to pass and busted the check engine light so it would stay off. They didn't touch the passages or the check valve. He got hosed, literally.
I'm doing the top-end, but I did get the car to pass emissions. I also negotiated a hefty $7500 discount in the selling price because I knew the ports were still clogged. Frankly, I'd rather buy the car with the ports clogged then start fresh with a fix on it, you get to break it in, you get a warranty with your shop, and you can rest easy know it was done correctly.
However, do not assume it's been done correctly, the previous owner of my car spent $3800 with a shop to get the car past emissions. From the paperwork and what I have found, they basically changed out every hose, nut and bolt on the intake, plus the MAF sensor, added a ton of labor, got the car to pass and busted the check engine light so it would stay off. They didn't touch the passages or the check valve. He got hosed, literally.
I'm doing the top-end, but I did get the car to pass emissions. I also negotiated a hefty $7500 discount in the selling price because I knew the ports were still clogged. Frankly, I'd rather buy the car with the ports clogged then start fresh with a fix on it, you get to break it in, you get a warranty with your shop, and you can rest easy know it was done correctly.