Seems like an overall meh deal. Look at the original sticker to asking price ratio, the options list is nothing to write home about, and the high miles are offsetting the 2014 build date, which is nothing more than a number in this case.

 

High miles ???
Bought a 2016 Cayman S brand new 3 months ago it now has a sweet 9200 miles on it. A lot of those
were well over 100mph. Track days next spring. Too much fun. We have a decent amount of paint chips and scratches also.

Have a great day!

 

Higher-mileage 991s can be great deals; they are well-built cars. Prices drop off a cliff when the odometer creeps up because most want a low-mileage garage queen.

I think high $60ks is probably about right for the mileage/build, but I would not buy a 911 without PSE, which would add ~$3.5k. I would also want leather interior after having it.

My CPO '12.5 had just over 41k miles when I purchased it; the dealer replaced all four corners (tires, pads, rotors) and did the 40k service

 

Here is Manheim info

Auction Averages
Zeroes Indicate No Recent Auction Sales. See "Transactions"
For Week Ending Nov 9
Above Average Below Sep 2016 May 2016 Nov 2015
Sale Price $64,251 $56,850 $49,449 $59,750 $61,333 $64,440
Odometer 9,404 18,807 28,211 25,370 15,224 13,420
Total Sold All 6 4 3 10
Average Auction Odometer submit changed mileage restore auction mileage
Prices are based on more transactions than shown under 'Transactions', above.
Nov 14 - Nov 21 2016
Above Average Below Dec 2016 Nov 2017
Auction $60,000 $55,400 $50,600 $55,200 $50,100
Est. Retail $72,000 $67,000 $62,000 $67,000 $62,000

 

Thanks, Jeff. From the looks of it auction price is a good deal below what this car is listed for.