Floaty at Speed???
The Best Porsche Posts for Porsche Enthusiasts
Yes the M5 feels more stable at higher speeds. It's also lowered. The steering of the Porsche embarrasses the steering feel of the M5...This is no secret. I still have my M5 and love it as well.
I have never heard of this mold theory but I appreciate you both for teaching me something. Also keep in mind that it was a 63 degree day, car had 150 miles on it, and if it matters, brand new asphalt. It wasn't a feel that made me feel insecure, it just felt a little light. Especially that I'm coming out of a 4300 pound autobahn cruiser.
Now there are a couple additional contributing factors (besides the mold release and tread depth factors mentioned at Tire Rack) that will complete the picture: new rubber, new tire shape, new asphalt and PASM.
As tires age the rubber gets harder. Autocross guys all know you will lose time from one year to the next just letting your tires sit in the garage getting harder. The new tread will squish around under load, creating that floaty feeling.
Look at a new tire compared to your older ones. New tires all have a very slight crown or roundness to them compared to worn tires. Soft new rubber combined with the slight crown (and deeper tread) has a lot to do with that great new tire feel of a super smooth ride. It also of course gives a ride that feels less planted.
Now the asphalt comment is really interesting. I missed this first time around because you said "pavement" instead of "asphalt"! New pavement means nothing, new asphalt is a whole 'nother deal. New asphalt has a lot of the same qualities as new rubber. A lot of the petroleum products used to make both are still in there when new. Over time these evaporate off, a big reason both the tire and the asphalt harden over time. Really new asphalt you can even tear up the surface just by driving too hard (cornering, braking) on it. We made the mistake one time of running a DE on asphalt laid down the day before and within an hour had ruined 3A. It looked okay but was not cured enough. What happens is that as you drive across it the surface asphalt binds to the tire more strongly than to the asphalt below. Depending on load it may not tear up, it may just squish around a little. That's why it was interesting to me that you noticed this on new asphalt.
One more piece of the puzzle: PASM.
You're used to a car that has been set up with a single-setting suspension. (If I'm wrong let me know.) Unlike PASM that constantly makes real-time adjustments based on load and driver input, yourM5 is stiff all the time. You could be cruising straight down the road, its stiff as always and giving you that feeling. All the time. Your 991 on the other hand, if you're just cruising along it lets the shocks soften up appropriate to speed and road surface. I'm guessing that new asphalt was pretty darn smooth. So you're feeling, at that precise moment, your suspension being about as soft as Porsche has deemed appropriate for the speed you're at. This to you, being used to single-setting firm response, well it doesn't surprise me you think of it as floaty. Especially combined with everything else.
The beauty of PASM is that it gives you this comfy ride whenever you don't really need it to be racer-responsive, and yet at the same time it is always ready and gives you as crisp a response as you need the instant you need it. (Even in Sport there is enough overlap that the softest Sport ride is nearly as compliant as the normal PASM setting and will feel softer than the ride of a non-PASM 991, that's how much latitude it gives you.) This can be a little disconcerting to one used to the old single-setting feeling, but you will quickly get used to it. By the time you get 500-1000 miles on it, the tires settled in and you're more used to PASM you will no doubt find yourself one day doing 140 and wondering how it suddenly became far more stable than your M5...
Oh, and Thank God you're not doing that "just the tip" break-in BS!
My first test drive in a 911 (997) I had a similar sensation of the very light front end and it may also be described as the car feeling "floaty" at the front and I was used to driving a Boxster at the time.
I wonder if it's just that; you're perception of "floatiness" because of the much lighter front end. The grip is there, but the car is a lightweight compared to the tank like M5. Just something to consider. This feeling will certainly go away as you get used to the car.
I'm also curious where you can do 140 mph in New York? I've done that in my old Boxster S but I was younger then. If I do that now and get caught by the cops, it's bye bye license for a while and car gets impounded for a week.


