andrewk34

Hi,

I'm having trouble deciding between the 2S and the 4S 991. I have read the various threads, but I'm wondering which one has less understeer. I will not be getting pdcc. I have owned a number of 2 wheel drive 911s in the past, and I was going to do the same again. However, Evo and some other magazines prefer the 4S, but it could be because pdcc makes the car feel more numb on the 2S.

Motortrend drivers car of the year tests (2012 versus 2013) seem to show that the 2s understeers MORE, which is surprising. But Motortrend conjectures that the 2s understeered so much because of pdcc.

I would test drive them and decide, but you cannot push a car on a test drive, and it is hard enough to find a 4s coup on the lot in CA. Weather is not a issue.

LexVan

What do you intend to do with the car? Autocross? DE? Weekend toy?

Oversteer and understeer has a lot to do with driving skill and how hard you are going to push it.

I love the C4S's slightly wider hips, rear light bar and lower rocker panels.

I ordered a C2S cab because I'll never drive in the rain and the cars are stored for the winter.

chuckbdc

991s of any configuration do not understeer the way prior 911s did- not at all. Anyone having such a problem needs to get the right balance of air pressures front to rear. Moreover they are all excellent in the wet.

The C4S, when pushed hard, vectors torque to the front wheels. That, the wider rear track and the wider rear wheels with larger tires (305 vs 295) than the C2S adds to cornering security. The C4S weighs more than the C2S. Sport PASM or PDCC would have their own effects. Randy Pobst declared each of them the best driving cars back to back last year and this. He loved them each while blasting around Laguna Seca. (Google: "pobst+991 + laguna seca" and you should find the vids). I have never seen a direct comparison test of otherwise equal cars/drivers/conditions so cannot point you to data or comparative comments.

sfo

get the 911-50

2S with the wider rear

nmurray22

There are some other small differences.


CS2

+ easier to be a hooligan (over steer, drift, steep the rearout)
+ slightly better fuel econ
+ slightly cheaper
+ slightly more trunk space
+ slightly higher top end

CS4


+ planted and safe, very hard to get out of line
+ looks a little cooler with wider rear and light bar on rear
+ bigger gas tank
+ slightly better weight balance and steering due to extra driveshaft
+ better takeoff grip

kosmo

ok so Ive drive both 2 and 4s on the track back to back.
short answer is that up about 8/10 you cant tell any difference, after that the 4 does understeer more.

its really amazing on 2 points: 1. the 2 is extremely planted and 2. the 4 does not feel like an AWD car


i like the 911-50 otherwise, man up and get the 2

rpilot

Close, but I have an incredibly hard time accomplishing the first with my C2, the grip is just that good, or maybe I am not driving hard enough...

991 C2S

Easy, The C2S is faster

llstuey

What do you mean by slightly more trunk space? In the front boot?

fester

And C4S is quicker

nmurray22

Yes the front trunk in the CS4 or C4 is smaller to fit the driveshaft and other stuff for 4WD

chuckbdc

I guess it translates to CSS vs CSSSS.

JohnnyBahamas

Personally, if it were my purchase, I'd buy the C4S... but that is because I believe that more grip is better for mountain twisty driving, always.

But, if you're torn, there is a solution. Look to Colin Chapman's words, "Simplify, then add lightness."

Which of the two is most simple? Which of the two is lighter?

Buy the one that is the answer to the above and you can NOT go wrong.

MerlinsGarage

The gas tank is bigger in the C4S?

Just J

Yes. Apparently, the four wheel drive system in the 4 wheel drive cars (including the Turbos) forces a smaller trunk, and keeping the straight sides of the trunk creates extra fuel tank space.