My 911S compared to my new Audi E-Tron
#16
Rennlist Member
Currently driving a Tesla X and while I really like it, charging sucks. I have been trying to keep it charged as much as possible in case I have to go somewhere. It gave me a warning message yesterday saying that to get the best battery longevity I should only charge it the amount I need for the day. Great, so what if I need an extra 100 miles, you know like a 50 mile trip to pick something up? Sure I can find a supercharger and sit for 1/2 hour but it might not be so simple and could be pretty inconvenient.
The early jet fighters while high performing were limited in range and quite finicky to run/maintain.
The early jet fighters while high performing were limited in range and quite finicky to run/maintain.
To keep the batteries going as long as possible they suggest 80% of max for daily charging. It isn't for everybody, but my wife commutes two days a week and it's been plenty. If we need a long trip....which is rare...we take a different car. Driving an X is a revelation when it comes to ease and lack of driving fatigue. And in a straight line it's faster than my GTS 0-60 by a long shot. In fact faster than a GT3. 3.17 seconds 0-60 for the Tesla. 0-100 7.98 seconds. Ours is a P90D. It ain't a sports car. I got that.
#17
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Fairfax County, Virginia
Posts: 4,328
Received 4,371 Likes
on
1,536 Posts
I bet my dryer sounds better and it doesn't require charging!
Teasing aside, I'm glad you like your new toy.
Does it buzz or emit any sounds whatsoever? Can you upload any sounds you want? This is a serous question.
I would consider an electric car when charging stations become ubiquitous and the cycle as quick as topping off with gas.
That said I'll always have an ICE sports car on the garage, naturally-aspirated one, of course...
Teasing aside, I'm glad you like your new toy.
Does it buzz or emit any sounds whatsoever? Can you upload any sounds you want? This is a serous question.
I would consider an electric car when charging stations become ubiquitous and the cycle as quick as topping off with gas.
That said I'll always have an ICE sports car on the garage, naturally-aspirated one, of course...
#18
I think for commuting that these cars have a place but I can't see having one in my fleet until the ranges get to like 600 miles reliably. I have a few toys and limit my sailer driver to one all around that needs to do everything. As an appliance - I could see getting one for a wife; if I had one but for now I shop for my cars in the men's section.
The following users liked this post:
verstraete (12-29-2019)
#19
I think for commuting that these cars have a place but I can't see having one in my fleet until the ranges get to like 600 miles reliably. I have a few toys and limit my sailer driver to one all around that needs to do everything. As an appliance - I could see getting one for a wife; if I had one but for now I shop for my cars in the men's section.
While I have and do road trip my 991, the Audi is my long-distance car, hence I need the range without worrying about a charge.
I love Audi. The 14 SQ5 has been flawless. Certainly nothing against the marque
The following users liked this post:
verstraete (12-29-2019)
#20
Burning Brakes
If the e-tron S was here already, with good product options, I’d have already made my move.
The 991.2 is for sunny days.
#21
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2002
Location: Fairfax County, Virginia
Posts: 4,328
Received 4,371 Likes
on
1,536 Posts
Agreed. My SQ5 goes to Tahoe and around town; I don’t commute.
While I have and do road trip my 991, the Audi is my long-distance car, hence I need the range without worrying about a charge.
I love Audi. The 14 SQ5 has been flawless. Certainly nothing against the marque
While I have and do road trip my 991, the Audi is my long-distance car, hence I need the range without worrying about a charge.
I love Audi. The 14 SQ5 has been flawless. Certainly nothing against the marque
Upcoming Q4 should look similar to their Geneva Car Show vehicle
The following users liked this post:
BlackOptic (12-28-2019)
#22
Racer
Join Date: Dec 2017
Location: 90 Miles East of Sonoma Raceway
Posts: 421
Received 38 Likes
on
24 Posts
I test drove an E-Tron and have a Tesla Model 3 LR. No doubt the interior on the Audi is much nicer compared to all Teslas but Audi needs to rethink their acceleration mapping on the E-Tron. I had a friend with me who owns a Viper and a Corvette track car. We both drove the E-Tron and he drove my Tesla after driving the Audi. The Audi felt quite sluggish and isn't effectively using the torque of the motor to take advantage of what's available. Audi seems to be targeting a car more similar to an ICE and I get that. But why not take advantage of the instantaneous torque available from an EV? Anyway enjoy your new Audi.
#23
Racer
Join Date: Dec 2017
Location: 90 Miles East of Sonoma Raceway
Posts: 421
Received 38 Likes
on
24 Posts
The following users liked this post:
AlexCeres (12-29-2019)
#24
Rennlist Member
At least if you buy a Tesla you have a great network of superchargers.... Not so much with VAG, despite the $2B they were forced to spend on Electrify America as part of the diesel-gate settlement.
#25
I have a 991 TT S and the way I drive it I would be lucky to get 200 miles on a tank of gas. I love the vehicle. I also fully expect to turn over the family fleet to EV over the next 5 years and thought that transition would start in 2019. I drove the Jag (talk about odd noises), Tesla (every other vehicle in Seattle-area is now one....the 4 wheel drive 3 is the one I would favor), and I even tracked down a Kia Niro EV that was very hard to find. I was on the list for a new etron as I have owned many Audis over the years too (own a 2013 A6 too) and when it came in the dealer let me have it for a day. It was very nice, a bit sterile (as mentioned earlier), the low speed sound is a tad annoying. But at the end of the day what did it for me was the price.....$78,000, and when I look at what I can get for much less, for what is going to be a utility vehicle, I can't yet justify it. Same with the others....the Kia Niro was $47,000!!! you can buy a fully loaded hybrid Kia Niro hybrid for $28,000.....economics don't make sense and I elected to wait one more generation of cars when hopefully the EV equivs get closer to reality on pricing
#26
I test drove an E-Tron and have a Tesla Model 3 LR. No doubt the interior on the Audi is much nicer compared to all Teslas but Audi needs to rethink their acceleration mapping on the E-Tron. I had a friend with me who owns a Viper and a Corvette track car. We both drove the E-Tron and he drove my Tesla after driving the Audi. The Audi felt quite sluggish and isn't effectively using the torque of the motor to take advantage of what's available. Audi seems to be targeting a car more similar to an ICE and I get that. But why not take advantage of the instantaneous torque available from an EV? Anyway enjoy your new Audi.
#27
Burning Brakes
Despite my moaning about charging I do like the free supercharging. I don't bother to plug in at home.
#28
Three Wheelin'
I test drove an E-Tron and have a Tesla Model 3 LR. No doubt the interior on the Audi is much nicer compared to all Teslas but Audi needs to rethink their acceleration mapping on the E-Tron. I had a friend with me who owns a Viper and a Corvette track car. We both drove the E-Tron and he drove my Tesla after driving the Audi. The Audi felt quite sluggish and isn't effectively using the torque of the motor to take advantage of what's available. Audi seems to be targeting a car more similar to an ICE and I get that. But why not take advantage of the instantaneous torque available from an EV? Anyway enjoy your new Audi.
#29
Burning Brakes
The following users liked this post:
verstraete (12-29-2019)
#30
Rennlist Member
I don't think sh*tty comments about "no soul" and all that are called for unless you have more experience with one. The range thing IS overblown for many people including me. VAG will own the market I'm guessing...for good or bad because I'm not a fan of their business ethics, and I am a big fan of Tesla. But facts are they have the money. And the technology. Their new charging system will rip. Whether or not it's good for the battery is another question.