2018 vs. 2019 Carerra T decision
#1
2018 vs. 2019 Carerra T decision
I've been looking at getting a 911 for awhile now. I had a 2014 4S a few years ago and currently have a Macan GTS. I've been trying to wait for a 992 but would like a MT and my patience is running out so I've decided to get something to hold me over.
Had a chance to test drive a T with a small tune in it and loved the car so heading in that direction. Having said that I don't think I'll have the car too long (maybe 2 years) before I upgrade so while not looking at this as an investment focused on a CPO to try and not lose too much.
The two options I've focused on have very similar builds with one exception - PCCB. The 2018 has about 7k miles and the 2019 about 9k miles....the 2019 also has the PCCB option and after talking to both dealers quite a bit have the price difference between the two down to about $11k.
Quick question I'm looking for input on is would the PCCB and one year newer hold up in two years? I would be plenty happy in the 2018 and potentially save $11k...that said wouldn't mind trying the PCCB for a few years and having a model year newer if I'm not going to lose all that value when I sell/trade in 2 years. I've always seen options on a Porsche as having very little to no value on trade but not sure if that's true when it comes to PCCB.
Appreciate any thoughts....car will be for weekend/fun driving, track a few times a year but not much so do not need the PCCB for any performance reason but have never had them so thought is something I'm considering as long as I'm not throwing $11k away...
Thanks in advance...been reading posts, etc. here for years but first time posting..
Had a chance to test drive a T with a small tune in it and loved the car so heading in that direction. Having said that I don't think I'll have the car too long (maybe 2 years) before I upgrade so while not looking at this as an investment focused on a CPO to try and not lose too much.
The two options I've focused on have very similar builds with one exception - PCCB. The 2018 has about 7k miles and the 2019 about 9k miles....the 2019 also has the PCCB option and after talking to both dealers quite a bit have the price difference between the two down to about $11k.
Quick question I'm looking for input on is would the PCCB and one year newer hold up in two years? I would be plenty happy in the 2018 and potentially save $11k...that said wouldn't mind trying the PCCB for a few years and having a model year newer if I'm not going to lose all that value when I sell/trade in 2 years. I've always seen options on a Porsche as having very little to no value on trade but not sure if that's true when it comes to PCCB.
Appreciate any thoughts....car will be for weekend/fun driving, track a few times a year but not much so do not need the PCCB for any performance reason but have never had them so thought is something I'm considering as long as I'm not throwing $11k away...
Thanks in advance...been reading posts, etc. here for years but first time posting..
#2
Race Car
I love PCCBs, no brake dust, look great (massive rotors), and I like the feel. In normal use, should last the life of the car.
However, I would not get PCCBs if I was going to track the car. They are very expensive to replace.
As for options and resale, it isn’t so much that you get little to no return on options - I think a well optioned car is more desirable for a purchaser and you will get more for it, you just will suffer more in depreciation on the cost of options versus the car itself.
If I was only going to hold onto a car for two years, I would get the cheaper one.
However, I would not get PCCBs if I was going to track the car. They are very expensive to replace.
As for options and resale, it isn’t so much that you get little to no return on options - I think a well optioned car is more desirable for a purchaser and you will get more for it, you just will suffer more in depreciation on the cost of options versus the car itself.
If I was only going to hold onto a car for two years, I would get the cheaper one.
#4
Rennlist Member
Good driver T, little to no track? Go for the PCCBs. Love them on mine for all the reasons above. The "bite" is simply incredible. Such a great addition to a great car. And who knows, you may fall in love with it and keep it! A good companion for the Macan.
#5
x2 - tracking aside, absolutely love PCCB and miss them on my 991.1. Bite, looks, no brake dust - hard to believe but the 9k price of entry was more than worth it for me
#6
Get the PCCB's. Even if you are only going to track once or twice a year. Base brakes are not great on the track. The one thing I regret not getting when I ordered my T. I ended up putting on a Brembo BBK on it because I track more than a few times a year. Plus I think the T with PCCB's will hold value better. Just my opinion though... YMMV...
#7
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Marineland FL
Posts: 12,535
Likes: 0
Received 3,460 Likes
on
2,361 Posts
I wound up getting PCCBs after I ordered my car and I love them, which I think most future buyers will appreciate as well.
Trending Topics
#8
Anything beyond this?
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?m...2F254121569547
#10
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Jul 2001
Location: Marineland FL
Posts: 12,535
Likes: 0
Received 3,460 Likes
on
2,361 Posts
What did it take besides cash?
Anything beyond this?
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?m...2F254121569547
Anything beyond this?
https://rover.ebay.com/rover/0/0/0?m...2F254121569547
#11
If I were planning to have the car ~2 years, from a purely financial perspective I'd go with the cheaper car. You will lose some/most of that $11k difference over 2 years. PCCBs certainly have functional benefits, but from a purely financial perspective, in your case with these two used cars I'd get the cheaper 18. Another way to look at it, if I were a future buyer looking at your used T that is 3-4 years old and has PCCBs and has also been tracked some, I would be very cautious and be sure to have the brakes inspected and measured. If show signs of significant wear I would discount that car rather than pay any premium. So, buying the car with PCCBs would change the way I would use the car and I personally wouldn't want to track it IMHO.
#12
#13
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Get the PCCBs.
Especially if you track.
Especially if you track.
The following users liked this post:
Macduc (09-03-2019)