Biggest difference in exhaust volume....cats or headers?
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Biggest difference in exhaust volume....cats or headers?
I'm really loving the sound of the PSE on the 991.2 GTS. Trying to decide which will give me more volume in the sound of the exhaust. Headers or cats?
Which is the best bang or the buck, if you could only choose one of them? Will there be a noticeable change with just cats?
Which is the best bang or the buck, if you could only choose one of them? Will there be a noticeable change with just cats?
#2
Instructor
Excellent question, and one I’ve been trying to hunt down myself. From what I’ve been able to piece together, sport cats yield big improvements in both exhaust volume and tone. Headers - particularly for the turbo engines - result in noticeable power increases.
It it seems there’s some synergistic effect to doing both mods, which is why many on the forum choose to do both (which is where I’m leaning). But if I were limited to one of the two, based on my limited knowledge and my primary goal of improving exhaust I’d go with the sport cats. Curious to see the input from those more knowledgeable.
It it seems there’s some synergistic effect to doing both mods, which is why many on the forum choose to do both (which is where I’m leaning). But if I were limited to one of the two, based on my limited knowledge and my primary goal of improving exhaust I’d go with the sport cats. Curious to see the input from those more knowledgeable.
#3
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Thank you. That was my thought as well. I'm sure both work great together. However, I just assumed that cats had a bigger impact on the volume and headers had a bigger impact on performance. Obviously, cats also affect performance (and headers on sound).
Really, I'm just looking for more volume right now. Leaning towards cats for the time being.
Really, I'm just looking for more volume right now. Leaning towards cats for the time being.
Excellent question, and one I’ve been trying to hunt down myself. From what I’ve been able to piece together, sport cats yield big improvements in both exhaust volume and tone. Headers - particularly for the turbo engines - result in noticeable power increases.
It it seems there’s some synergistic effect to doing both mods, which is why many on the forum choose to do both (which is where I’m leaning). But if I were limited to one of the two, based on my limited knowledge and my primary goal of improving exhaust I’d go with the sport cats. Curious to see the input from those more knowledgeable.
It it seems there’s some synergistic effect to doing both mods, which is why many on the forum choose to do both (which is where I’m leaning). But if I were limited to one of the two, based on my limited knowledge and my primary goal of improving exhaust I’d go with the sport cats. Curious to see the input from those more knowledgeable.
#4
Rennlist Member
Cat, because that's is going to be you bottleneck down the exhaust line.
Say if you have a bigger header, you are still restricted by the volume of the cat
(obviously do both if you can LOL, but for us with the crazy CA emission restriction, i would not dare to touch the cat due to smog reasons)
Say if you have a bigger header, you are still restricted by the volume of the cat
(obviously do both if you can LOL, but for us with the crazy CA emission restriction, i would not dare to touch the cat due to smog reasons)
#5
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Join Date: Mar 2017
Location: Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Posts: 2,484
Received 689 Likes
on
438 Posts
I'm really loving the sound of the PSE on the 991.2 GTS. Trying to decide which will give me more volume in the sound of the exhaust. Headers or cats?
Which is the best bang or the buck, if you could only choose one of them? Will there be a noticeable change with just cats?
Which is the best bang or the buck, if you could only choose one of them? Will there be a noticeable change with just cats?
Take a listen to the sample with our Sport cats and carbon tips and let me know what you think!! Feel free to reach out to me regarding any questions, and Forum pricing!!
>>>
#6
I'm really loving the sound of the PSE on the 991.2 GTS. Trying to decide which will give me more volume in the sound of the exhaust. Headers or cats?
Which is the best bang or the buck, if you could only choose one of them? Will there be a noticeable change with just cats?
Which is the best bang or the buck, if you could only choose one of them? Will there be a noticeable change with just cats?
Headers will change the engine pulses which can change the exhaust note. Currently have fabspeed but want to switch to Kline or Vektor(they have proven nice gains).
#7
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Sport Catalytic Converters are a prime choice to increase both turbo sound and engine sound while improving power slightly. HJS HD 200 cell catalysts prevent fumes and check engine lights.
Cat Bypass Pipes sound incredible if you want to go even further, but you'll need either O2 spacers or an ECU tune to prevent a check engine light
The headers will not offer as great of a difference in sound, but do pair well to increase power and sound if you are looking for both after that upgrade.
Happy to chat if you have more questions!
Cat Bypass Pipes sound incredible if you want to go even further, but you'll need either O2 spacers or an ECU tune to prevent a check engine light
The headers will not offer as great of a difference in sound, but do pair well to increase power and sound if you are looking for both after that upgrade.
Happy to chat if you have more questions!
__________________
SOUL PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS
Quality Exhaust Solutions, Fair Pricing, and Outstanding Service
John Gaydos- Owner, Performance Specialist
Cell - (484) 883-6197
johng@soulpp.com
Jon Wheel - Marketing Manager
jwheel@soulpp.com
SOUL PERFORMANCE PRODUCTS
Quality Exhaust Solutions, Fair Pricing, and Outstanding Service
John Gaydos- Owner, Performance Specialist
Cell - (484) 883-6197
johng@soulpp.com
Jon Wheel - Marketing Manager
jwheel@soulpp.com
Trending Topics
#8
Former Vendor
Thank you. That was my thought as well. I'm sure both work great together. However, I just assumed that cats had a bigger impact on the volume and headers had a bigger impact on performance. Obviously, cats also affect performance (and headers on sound).
Really, I'm just looking for more volume right now. Leaning towards cats for the time being.
Really, I'm just looking for more volume right now. Leaning towards cats for the time being.
#9
Sport Catalytic Converters are a prime choice to increase both turbo sound and engine sound while improving power slightly. HJS HD 200 cell catalysts prevent fumes and check engine lights.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tiko2nXVmk
Cat Bypass Pipes sound incredible if you want to go even further, but you'll need either O2 spacers or an ECU tune to prevent a check engine light
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHSoNmyj2c4
The headers will not offer as great of a difference in sound, but do pair well to increase power and sound if you are looking for both after that upgrade.
Happy to chat if you have more questions!
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3tiko2nXVmk
Cat Bypass Pipes sound incredible if you want to go even further, but you'll need either O2 spacers or an ECU tune to prevent a check engine light
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AHSoNmyj2c4
The headers will not offer as great of a difference in sound, but do pair well to increase power and sound if you are looking for both after that upgrade.
Happy to chat if you have more questions!
To make it louder than that? Idk, center deletes? Mike what you got? haha
#10
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
+1 for Soul Performance. Had the 200 cel cats installed yesterday. You won't notice much of an in cab sound difference (windows up of course), but those outside said it was noticeably different. No drone, perfect if you are looking to up the PSE sound a to be turned up, but don't want your ears to ring while you are driving. You'll definitely hear the turbo's spool more too! The customer service is top notch too.
To make it louder than that? Idk, center deletes? Mike what you got? haha
To make it louder than that? Idk, center deletes? Mike what you got? haha
BMC high flow air filters may give you an ever so slight increase in sound. There's always Cat Bypass Pipes if you want it more aggressive down the line - sounds incredible IMO - but removing the cats presents fumes, a check engine light that needs to be solved, and possibly an issue with the dealership.
#11
+1 for Soul Performance. Had the 200 cel cats installed yesterday. You won't notice much of an in cab sound difference (windows up of course), but those outside said it was noticeably different. No drone, perfect if you are looking to up the PSE sound a to be turned up, but don't want your ears to ring while you are driving. You'll definitely hear the turbo's spool more too! The customer service is top notch too.
To make it louder than that? Idk, center deletes? Mike what you got? haha
To make it louder than that? Idk, center deletes? Mike what you got? haha
#12
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
As the video guy, I stand behind all the cars when they rev - which usually leaves me smelling and hearing worse after. We use HJS HD 200 cell catalytic converters which have a very high precious metal count to allow for high flow while still preventing check engine lights. These cats are the business. McLaren uses a similar cat (manufactured under the same roof / parent company) for their OEM catalytic converters. I don't recall smelling anything from our Sport Cats - or any application using these cats really. The Cat Bypass Pipes did have a smell.
#13
Former Vendor
As others have said, cats will make the more significant impact on sound levels. From observations with our own headers, we see a change in tone and a much less muddled exhaust sound. You hear/feel the pulses vs them sounding like exhaust noise. It's tough to describe, but it's a difference that is very before/after noticeable.
#14
none that I noticed. But seeing you have a cab, I think 200 cel cats would be great. Top down and hear them spool!