Kain

Which car would you pick?

naptownmike

That AMG c63 coupe looks great.

karimgt3

Saw both in frankfurt, and drove the m4 several times..

The new c63coupe looks really good imo, but I found it to be slightly big and beefy... which is why i prefer the m4 which looks more nimble..

On the other hand u get 80 more hp with the merc..

abcut973

I think I'm bias on that one but the C63 S coup gets it!
Definitely more HP but a wider rear end that was lacking in the previous model. Should be a nice head to head on the track. Can't wait to see comparisons!

Drifting

I hate the tacked on/glued on look of the central navigation screen in all Mercedes models including this one.

What's the price difference between these two cars?

aussie jimmy

easy choice. stuttgart forever.

-eztrader-

I had a 2015 M3....it sucked....could only assume the merc is better

ShakeNBake

BMW has moved the focus of their top engineers to electric. M is suffering. I'd prefer the C63 over an M3/M4 in this generation because it's a more fun car to drive, more luxurious, and better audio. Seems silly since my DD is a X5M right now (I convince myself it works out because I tow the track with it). Hoping BMW pulls out of this nose dive. (still buying GTS though...)

Para82

This.

I would pick neither.

How on earth are people attracted to this new junk being put out from Germany? Especially when you can pick up a great car like the E92 BMW M3. Makes zero sense.

Alan Smithee

I would take an M2 or outgoing N/A C63 over either, but given the choices here, I would take the M4. I don't like anything about the new C-class.

mrsullivan

BMW M lost me many years ago. Too swoopy, too soft, too mainstream. The synthetic engine/exhaust sound through the speakers was one of several WTF moments with BMW M.

I think AMG is just more exciting and fun. Its like the BMW M designers are a bunch of old men and the AMG designers are a bunch of kids. Snortier sounds from engine and exhaust, snap crackle pop on shift, so much torque and sound and fun. More like muscle cars. Fun.

shaytun

Aside from the fact that the M4 is available with a manual, the C63 is the winner. I do think the M4 has a more sporty and coherent design, but the C63 seems more exciting with a V8, better sound, and nicer interior, albeit an ugly navigation screen.

Finlander

Would have much preferred a NA engine, but overall I'm very happy with the M4 as a DD. (although the exhaust note is crap)

shaytun

Nice M4. What wheels and lowering kit did you use.

Finlander

Thanks.... Velos wheels with KW V3.