Engine warranty closing soon! Keeping me up at night!
#197
I am considering a 2015 with an F series engine that had its heads replaced at 12,000 miles back in July 2017.
The work was done at a Porsche dealer. The car now has 35,000 miles. The CarFax shows regular service with plenty of oil changes at the Porsche dealership.
The car in service date was Dec 2014 so the 10 year warranty will end this Dec.
I am curious if the heads being replaced on the F series engine means it shouldn't have the top end issue?
If I do look closer at this car, I will get a PPI done and will also be sure to get a few track days in this summer to stress test the motor.
I am interested in your opinions.
Thanks,
Carm
The work was done at a Porsche dealer. The car now has 35,000 miles. The CarFax shows regular service with plenty of oil changes at the Porsche dealership.
The car in service date was Dec 2014 so the 10 year warranty will end this Dec.
I am curious if the heads being replaced on the F series engine means it shouldn't have the top end issue?
If I do look closer at this car, I will get a PPI done and will also be sure to get a few track days in this summer to stress test the motor.
I am interested in your opinions.
Thanks,
Carm
#198
I am getting requests for additional info on this problem. I can understand why. This issue is a serious one that could be called a "ticking tine bomb". Will it or won't it?
Fixing it will be expensive. The labor is intensive, special machining is required to the heads to fit the new parts, the parts are expensive and there are 24 pieces of each. So the more information I can provide, hopefully this will arm those with these cars to have a better understanding of the issue, how it is "fixed" and what is involved.
This may take several posts to attached all of the photos.
Factory finger assy's fitted to head. No valves but shows how they fit into head bores.
Factory finger assy. Piston is hydraulic which is pumped with engine oil. This pushes the finger pad into the camshaft base circle removing any lash clearance. No oil can get between finger and camshaft to remove any heat generated by the sliding friction. This is what causes the failures. The images of the head shows the oil spray nozzles on the exhaust side only. This oil has to get past off of the exhaust valve train parts and try to find its way to the Intake side.
This is our replacement parts. These are "solid" types that require lash pads to be used to set the lash between the finger and camshaft. Oil is pushed up through the body and sprayed between the finger pad and the camshaft.
Fixing it will be expensive. The labor is intensive, special machining is required to the heads to fit the new parts, the parts are expensive and there are 24 pieces of each. So the more information I can provide, hopefully this will arm those with these cars to have a better understanding of the issue, how it is "fixed" and what is involved.
This may take several posts to attached all of the photos.
Factory finger assy's fitted to head. No valves but shows how they fit into head bores.
Factory finger assy. Piston is hydraulic which is pumped with engine oil. This pushes the finger pad into the camshaft base circle removing any lash clearance. No oil can get between finger and camshaft to remove any heat generated by the sliding friction. This is what causes the failures. The images of the head shows the oil spray nozzles on the exhaust side only. This oil has to get past off of the exhaust valve train parts and try to find its way to the Intake side.
This is our replacement parts. These are "solid" types that require lash pads to be used to set the lash between the finger and camshaft. Oil is pushed up through the body and sprayed between the finger pad and the camshaft.
#199
What is the cost of the parts and machining of the heads alone, as I guess fitting will be done locally in most cases which can be on the other side of the world.
New parts means: 4 cams (OEM ones or some custom dlc coated?), 24 lifters(these finger followers) and 2 heads machined and sprayers added? is there something else?
Cams need to be replaced if the FF plague did not made its effects yet?
Thanks.
New parts means: 4 cams (OEM ones or some custom dlc coated?), 24 lifters(these finger followers) and 2 heads machined and sprayers added? is there something else?
Cams need to be replaced if the FF plague did not made its effects yet?
Thanks.
#200
Here are photos of the 0.2 finger assy. I need to check but I am sure that the 0.2 heads will fit onto the 0.1 block. Our conversion to the 0.1 heads is converts the 01. heads to an 0.2 head.
Oil ports that feed oil into the finger assy.
Jets can be seen on the top of the fingers that feed oil to the finger pad and camshaft.
Finger assy fitted to head
Oil ports that feed oil into the finger assy.
Jets can be seen on the top of the fingers that feed oil to the finger pad and camshaft.
Finger assy fitted to head
#201
What is the cost of the parts and machining of the heads alone, as I guess fitting will be done locally in most cases which can be on the other side of the world.
New parts means: 4 cams (OEM ones or some custom dlc coated?), 24 lifters(these finger followers) and 2 heads machined and sprayers added? is there something else?
Cams need to be replaced if the FF plague did not made its effects yet?
Thanks.
New parts means: 4 cams (OEM ones or some custom dlc coated?), 24 lifters(these finger followers) and 2 heads machined and sprayers added? is there something else?
Cams need to be replaced if the FF plague did not made its effects yet?
Thanks.
The following users liked this post:
cavlino (01-29-2024)
#203
Can't get an extended warranty if it's already out of warranty was my understanding. Plus some of the non-Porsche ones that might potentially cover it have a claim limit, the ones I heard about it was only $20K. You would be better off setting aside the money to purchase the warranty in investments and using it to pay for the engine when needed.
#204
Yes Cams have to be replaced. This is something I did forget to add. The cam profile has to be changed when going from hydraulic to solid valve motions. Its hoped that these will be recut on original cam shafts when damage is not too severe. Included in the conversion design are new cam lobe designs. We did new cam lobe designs for the 02 fingers as well as this was a simple follow on design.
The following users liked this post:
cavlino (01-30-2024)
#206
Yup. If it's ~20K, I'm not even waiting. I'm just shipping the car to them now. If we are closer to 50K, then I am stuck. Does selling and upgrading to the RS or .2 make sense? That's a tough one.
If they offer the kit and then sell it through qualified speed shops, that may make a difference too.
Hopefully, the next few months will help clarify options.
If they offer the kit and then sell it through qualified speed shops, that may make a difference too.
Hopefully, the next few months will help clarify options.
The following users liked this post:
cavlino (01-30-2024)
#207
Here are photos of the 0.2 finger assy. I need to check but I am sure that the 0.2 heads will fit onto the 0.1 block. Our conversion to the 0.1 heads is converts the 01. heads to an 0.2 head.
Oil ports that feed oil into the finger assy.
Jets can be seen on the top of the fingers that feed oil to the finger pad and camshaft.
Finger assy fitted to head
Oil ports that feed oil into the finger assy.
Jets can be seen on the top of the fingers that feed oil to the finger pad and camshaft.
Finger assy fitted to head
1. How much?
2. Works on GT3 RS as well?
3. What are y'all seeing on GT3 RS wear wise on G0 Engines?
4. What would need to be sent to Dundon, heads only?
5. What oil are you seeing the best wear on stock engines?
Thx
#209
[QUOTE=el0designs;19248191]Yup. If it's ~20K, I'm not even waiting. I'm just shipping the car to them now. If we are closer to 50K, then I am stuck. Does selling and upgrading to the RS or .2 make sense? That's a tough one.
If they offer the kit and then sell it through qualified speed shops, that may make a difference too.
Hopefully, the next few months will help clarify options.[/QUOTE
I would bet the upgrade will be upwards to 50k?
If they offer the kit and then sell it through qualified speed shops, that may make a difference too.
Hopefully, the next few months will help clarify options.[/QUOTE
I would bet the upgrade will be upwards to 50k?
#210
Yes Cams have to be replaced. This is something I did forget to add. The cam profile has to be changed when going from hydraulic to solid valve motions. Its hoped that these will be recut on original cam shafts when damage is not too severe. Included in the conversion design are new cam lobe designs. We did new cam lobe designs for the 02 fingers as well as this was a simple follow on design.
Would be awesome to see a separate thread focused on the technical issues - the .1’s design and design issues, solution, etc.