Engine Failure @ 32k miles Cayman S
#16
I read up on the brake booster and saw a post about it failing (catastrophically) on a 987.2 (same engine, same part), but it didn't damage the engine. I guess in your case, the part inside the block is what broke off.
The fcp euro page for the part says recommended replacement at 60k miles. Has anyone done that?
The fcp euro page for the part says recommended replacement at 60k miles. Has anyone done that?
#17
I wonder what the chance it would break before the 60k miles? This thread alone 100%, fist one I have seen though and have not seen many 60k+ miles on 981. Damn, I shoulda purchased the 100k mile warranty on my used 30K mile CS, it was $5k that I would gladly throw away if my car makes the 100k miles.
Can an intermediate DIY'er replace this part?
Can an intermediate DIY'er replace this part?
#18
Rennlist Member
Yeah so the shop is saying I’m going to need a new engine dropped in. “Engine came apart on left front, Cam blew out of the housing blowing shrapnel everywhere”
Insurance adjuster is going to take a look Monday. Worried they won’t cover it as there’s no external damage at all, but so far everyone that’s seen the picture including the dealer thinks there’s no way the engine did that itself. BGB quoted me 30k to put in a 911 3.8L. May go that route if insurance doesn’t work out.
Edit: thank you for all the kind replies. My friends weren’t as nice :/ think they’re just jealous.
Insurance adjuster is going to take a look Monday. Worried they won’t cover it as there’s no external damage at all, but so far everyone that’s seen the picture including the dealer thinks there’s no way the engine did that itself. BGB quoted me 30k to put in a 911 3.8L. May go that route if insurance doesn’t work out.
Edit: thank you for all the kind replies. My friends weren’t as nice :/ think they’re just jealous.
#19
I have 83K miles on my 2014 BS, including a fair number of track days. This is the first I've even heard of this part, much less seen any reports of it failing, even among my track junkie friends.
Now that you know what it is, were there any signs ahead of time that this thing was on it's last legs, or was it just working fine until it wasn't?
Now that you know what it is, were there any signs ahead of time that this thing was on it's last legs, or was it just working fine until it wasn't?
#20
I have 83K miles on my 2014 BS, including a fair number of track days. This is the first I've even heard of this part, much less seen any reports of it failing, even among my track junkie friends.
Now that you know what it is, were there any signs ahead of time that this thing was on it's last legs, or was it just working fine until it wasn't?
Now that you know what it is, were there any signs ahead of time that this thing was on it's last legs, or was it just working fine until it wasn't?
just way too many wearable items that can go boom.
#21
I have 83K miles on my 2014 BS, including a fair number of track days. This is the first I've even heard of this part, much less seen any reports of it failing, even among my track junkie friends.
Now that you know what it is, were there any signs ahead of time that this thing was on it's last legs, or was it just working fine until it wasn't?
Now that you know what it is, were there any signs ahead of time that this thing was on it's last legs, or was it just working fine until it wasn't?
The following users liked this post:
Sajan (05-02-2022)
#22
Rennlist Member
Sometimes things just break for no apparent reason. I mean there’s always a reason, but it’s not like it’s somebody’s fault, a lack of maintenance, or someone trying to hide something.
#23
Rennlist Member
An auction early in life isn't necessarily bad. Sometimes it's just a matter of circumstance. Some cars get traded in at the wrong time for it and they sit on the lot. If it doesn't sell for one reason or another then off to auction it goes.
My Carrera GTS Cab went to auction after the 1st owner traded it in in mid August at 4,000 miles. It's Speed Yellow so not for everyone's taste, so it sat until October when it was sent to auction. It had 2 strikes against it, the color and everyone wanted the new PDK. It was subsequently picked up by a Porsche Dealer and CPO'd twice. It is a highly spec'd 6 speed car with every desirable option. But once, it was un-loved and unwanted and relegated to the back lot of an auction house somewhere. I don't see myself ever getting rid of it.
My Carrera GTS Cab went to auction after the 1st owner traded it in in mid August at 4,000 miles. It's Speed Yellow so not for everyone's taste, so it sat until October when it was sent to auction. It had 2 strikes against it, the color and everyone wanted the new PDK. It was subsequently picked up by a Porsche Dealer and CPO'd twice. It is a highly spec'd 6 speed car with every desirable option. But once, it was un-loved and unwanted and relegated to the back lot of an auction house somewhere. I don't see myself ever getting rid of it.
#24
An auction early in life isn't necessarily bad. Sometimes it's just a matter of circumstance. Some cars get traded in at the wrong time for it and they sit on the lot. If it doesn't sell for one reason or another then off to auction it goes.
My Carrera GTS Cab went to auction after the 1st owner traded it in in mid August at 4,000 miles. It's Speed Yellow so not for everyone's taste, so it sat until October when it was sent to auction. It had 2 strikes against it, the color and everyone wanted the new PDK. It was subsequently picked up by a Porsche Dealer and CPO'd twice. It is a highly spec'd 6 speed car with every desirable option. But once, it was un-loved and unwanted and relegated to the back lot of an auction house somewhere. I don't see myself ever getting rid of it.
My Carrera GTS Cab went to auction after the 1st owner traded it in in mid August at 4,000 miles. It's Speed Yellow so not for everyone's taste, so it sat until October when it was sent to auction. It had 2 strikes against it, the color and everyone wanted the new PDK. It was subsequently picked up by a Porsche Dealer and CPO'd twice. It is a highly spec'd 6 speed car with every desirable option. But once, it was un-loved and unwanted and relegated to the back lot of an auction house somewhere. I don't see myself ever getting rid of it.
what would concern me is if it was traded in at a p dealership and they didn't CPO it..and send it off to auction.