Restart trouble after re-assembly
#61
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thanks! I was on the verge of actually paying an auto electrician or mechanic to come and help me out, but maybe the gods of tyro car maintenance are finally smiling on me. Must be all those tears of bitter frustration I've wept into the engine bay…
#62
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Since this is local to you have you considered this? If your DME is acting up.
http://www.augmentautomotive.co.uk/a...rsche-944-ecu/
http://www.augmentautomotive.co.uk/a...rsche-944-ecu/
...so I turned my attention to the DME. Cleaned the contacts (there was some corrosion/salts, possibly copper going by the blue colour, at one end of the the two rows of connectors on the DME), sprayed contact cleaner on the multiway connector, and opened up the DME to take a look. No obvious corrosion, damage or cracks, but I sprayed the circuit boards with contact cleaner anyway (there were some brownish deposits) and brushed them clean.
On reconnecting the DME things seem much, much better. Started first time, ran OK, and started again several times after shutting off the ignition. I even ventured a quick ride around the block, and it made it OK. It did, however, die once - so I haven't solved the problem, but feel I'm getting closer.
One other small thing: when the engine is running it's doing a slightly odd thing at low throttle. Idle is smooth, and if I open the throttle up to above 2,500 rpm it's smooth. But in between it seems to suffer a slight dip in revs every 4 to 5 seconds. I'm not going to worry about that too much until the basic starting and running thing is sorted.
On reconnecting the DME things seem much, much better. Started first time, ran OK, and started again several times after shutting off the ignition. I even ventured a quick ride around the block, and it made it OK. It did, however, die once - so I haven't solved the problem, but feel I'm getting closer.
One other small thing: when the engine is running it's doing a slightly odd thing at low throttle. Idle is smooth, and if I open the throttle up to above 2,500 rpm it's smooth. But in between it seems to suffer a slight dip in revs every 4 to 5 seconds. I'm not going to worry about that too much until the basic starting and running thing is sorted.
#64
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Captain's Log, Stardate 201504.31
I'm not quite out of the woods, but fiddling with the DME seems to have almost resolved things. I suspect that as well as whatever was going on there, there were/are other minor problems that might have contributed to all this hassle. I've taken a few test drives and the results were:
• The car has started *almost* every time, on 20-30 attempts. There was one incident where the engine lost power and died. When I tried restarting, it first started (no hesitation), but then died immediately. Next attempt: started and ran OK. On another occasion I pulled into a garage and turned the engine off. It did not re-start on first attempt, but after I gave everything a long, hard stare, and fiddled with a few connectors, it started again.
• It's mostly running well, but while it seems completely healthy with the loud pedal pressed down, under lighter throttle it sometimes seems less happy. Occasionally it seems to suffer a slight loss of power, a sudden drop of a few hundred revs, at about 2,000rpm. Seems slightly more likely to do it under a trailing throttle, though that might be down to my sample size. On a couple of occasions I experienced a bit of kangaroo-ing (?), that is sudden but slight drop in power followed by restoration, repeated over and over for a few seconds.
• With the engine warm, on startup it idles at about 1,400rpm, but immediately starts speeding up to about 2,200rpm. This takes about 10 seconds, video here: http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/4...4/IMG_2927.MOV
So I think I'll put the undertrays back on, use the car for a few days and see how it goes, then do some more investigating.
I'm not quite out of the woods, but fiddling with the DME seems to have almost resolved things. I suspect that as well as whatever was going on there, there were/are other minor problems that might have contributed to all this hassle. I've taken a few test drives and the results were:
• The car has started *almost* every time, on 20-30 attempts. There was one incident where the engine lost power and died. When I tried restarting, it first started (no hesitation), but then died immediately. Next attempt: started and ran OK. On another occasion I pulled into a garage and turned the engine off. It did not re-start on first attempt, but after I gave everything a long, hard stare, and fiddled with a few connectors, it started again.
• It's mostly running well, but while it seems completely healthy with the loud pedal pressed down, under lighter throttle it sometimes seems less happy. Occasionally it seems to suffer a slight loss of power, a sudden drop of a few hundred revs, at about 2,000rpm. Seems slightly more likely to do it under a trailing throttle, though that might be down to my sample size. On a couple of occasions I experienced a bit of kangaroo-ing (?), that is sudden but slight drop in power followed by restoration, repeated over and over for a few seconds.
• With the engine warm, on startup it idles at about 1,400rpm, but immediately starts speeding up to about 2,200rpm. This takes about 10 seconds, video here: http://dl.dropboxusercontent.com/u/4...4/IMG_2927.MOV
So I think I'll put the undertrays back on, use the car for a few days and see how it goes, then do some more investigating.
#65
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
and after another few short trips...
I still have a problem with the engine dying, which it has done about once per trip so far. It seems to mostly happen at about 2,000 rpm, and mostly under a trailing or light throttle. The engine idle sometimes climbs to about 2,700 rpm, and a couple of times I've seen a hiccup in engine revs while idling - a sudden drop of a couple of hundred revs that is immediately restored.
Very aggravating...
Because the problem seems related to engine revs, I'm leaning towards an TPS or AFM issue as the explanation. I had previously checked both and they seemed OK... but the problem is intermittent, so maybe I got lucky/unlucky on the tests.
Will gather more data, tinker a bit more, and start a new thread if trouble continues.
I still have a problem with the engine dying, which it has done about once per trip so far. It seems to mostly happen at about 2,000 rpm, and mostly under a trailing or light throttle. The engine idle sometimes climbs to about 2,700 rpm, and a couple of times I've seen a hiccup in engine revs while idling - a sudden drop of a couple of hundred revs that is immediately restored.
Very aggravating...
Because the problem seems related to engine revs, I'm leaning towards an TPS or AFM issue as the explanation. I had previously checked both and they seemed OK... but the problem is intermittent, so maybe I got lucky/unlucky on the tests.
Will gather more data, tinker a bit more, and start a new thread if trouble continues.
#66
Three Wheelin'
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
and after another few short trips...
I still have a problem with the engine dying, which it has done about once per trip so far. It seems to mostly happen at about 2,000 rpm, and mostly under a trailing or light throttle. The engine idle sometimes climbs to about 2,700 rpm, and a couple of times I've seen a hiccup in engine revs while idling - a sudden drop of a couple of hundred revs that is immediately restored.
Very aggravating...
Because the problem seems related to engine revs, I'm leaning towards an TPS or AFM issue as the explanation. I had previously checked both and they seemed OK... but the problem is intermittent, so maybe I got lucky/unlucky on the tests.
Will gather more data, tinker a bit more, and start a new thread if trouble continues.
I still have a problem with the engine dying, which it has done about once per trip so far. It seems to mostly happen at about 2,000 rpm, and mostly under a trailing or light throttle. The engine idle sometimes climbs to about 2,700 rpm, and a couple of times I've seen a hiccup in engine revs while idling - a sudden drop of a couple of hundred revs that is immediately restored.
Very aggravating...
Because the problem seems related to engine revs, I'm leaning towards an TPS or AFM issue as the explanation. I had previously checked both and they seemed OK... but the problem is intermittent, so maybe I got lucky/unlucky on the tests.
Will gather more data, tinker a bit more, and start a new thread if trouble continues.
I think the hiccup you're experiencing is probably the same issue, i.e. the DME. If it still happens with the TPS unplugged, you can eliminate the TPS.
#67
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I'm pretty comfortable with a soldering iron, though I'd want to be absolutely sure that it was the DME itself that was the problem before I re-soldered a lot of joints that were probably OK.
Will the car run OK and be drivable without the TPS connected? I started it before with the connector unhooked, but only let it idle.
My feeling is that because the problem happens in a certain rev range that it's more likely to be a sensor/signal problem than the DME, but on the other hand it was fiddling with the DME that seemed to help.
The frustrating thing here is that while I have made progress, I haven't replaced or fixed any clearly malfunctioning thing. Cleaning the DME multiway connector and contacts, and opening up the DME for a clean, seem to have made a big difference, but I didn't find anything clearly broken, and also those steps haven't 100% resolved things.
Will the car run OK and be drivable without the TPS connected? I started it before with the connector unhooked, but only let it idle.
My feeling is that because the problem happens in a certain rev range that it's more likely to be a sensor/signal problem than the DME, but on the other hand it was fiddling with the DME that seemed to help.
The frustrating thing here is that while I have made progress, I haven't replaced or fixed any clearly malfunctioning thing. Cleaning the DME multiway connector and contacts, and opening up the DME for a clean, seem to have made a big difference, but I didn't find anything clearly broken, and also those steps haven't 100% resolved things.
#68
Three Wheelin'
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I'm pretty comfortable with a soldering iron, though I'd want to be absolutely sure that it was the DME itself that was the problem before I re-soldered a lot of joints that were probably OK.
Will the car run OK and be drivable without the TPS connected? I started it before with the connector unhooked, but only let it idle.
My feeling is that because the problem happens in a certain rev range that it's more likely to be a sensor/signal problem than the DME, but on the other hand it was fiddling with the DME that seemed to help.
The frustrating thing here is that while I have made progress, I haven't replaced or fixed any clearly malfunctioning thing. Cleaning the DME multiway connector and contacts, and opening up the DME for a clean, seem to have made a big difference, but I didn't find anything clearly broken, and also those steps haven't 100% resolved things.
Will the car run OK and be drivable without the TPS connected? I started it before with the connector unhooked, but only let it idle.
My feeling is that because the problem happens in a certain rev range that it's more likely to be a sensor/signal problem than the DME, but on the other hand it was fiddling with the DME that seemed to help.
The frustrating thing here is that while I have made progress, I haven't replaced or fixed any clearly malfunctioning thing. Cleaning the DME multiway connector and contacts, and opening up the DME for a clean, seem to have made a big difference, but I didn't find anything clearly broken, and also those steps haven't 100% resolved things.
The fact that disturbing the DME connector has improved things is what makes me think of the solder joints, especially the pins for the main harness connector.
#69
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thanks, I'll try driving without the TPS and see what that feels like.
Driving this evening I experienced another loss of power incident, this time with a backfire just as the car slowed to a stop.
Driving this evening I experienced another loss of power incident, this time with a backfire just as the car slowed to a stop.
#70
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
After a few short trips with TPS disconnected... i think it has to be the cause of the problem. Or at least the most significant remaining factor in my engine trouble.
Running without the TPS it has started every time, never cut out, and never stumbled. Idle is too high.
I've already tried installing another TPS - but it was used and turned out to also not work. So I gritted my teeth and ordered a new wildly overpriced potentiometer.
Running without the TPS it has started every time, never cut out, and never stumbled. Idle is too high.
I've already tried installing another TPS - but it was used and turned out to also not work. So I gritted my teeth and ordered a new wildly overpriced potentiometer.
#72
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Did you ever get a noid light to test power to the injectors? I had bad injector connectors on one of my cars that gave me the exact symptoms you are having, I believe the injectors share the same ground used by the DME to create spark. I have 2 turbos and both of them when peeling back the boots on the injectors revealed blueish corrosion and one was completely shorted. The connector ends are cheap on ebay and can be installed with but connectors if you cant solder but soldering is preferred. I say worth doing anyway as they will fail at some point if they are original. I ran one of my NA cars without the TPS with no issues.
#74
Pro
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thanks for the suggestions chaps.
Battery voltage: yes, checked that, and there's no problem there.
Idle stabilizer is an interesting idea - I'll check that out. (And no, I didn't get Noid lights and do that test because I'm sure it's a spark problem - though for the sake of completeness I should do it.)
Also, I did have one incident the other day of the engine dying again while driving with TPS disconnected, so perhaps the TPS isn't the only thing still at fault...
I still haven't installed a new TPS, and therefore seen how it runs with a definitely-OK unit, as these things seem rather hard to get hold of - albeit I haven't taken the simple but expensive route of getting it from a Porsche dealer. The used one I bought on ebay didn't work, so I ordered a brand new one from an online parts supplier. A few days later they said they couldn't get hold of it, and refunded my money. I've been ringing round and keep being told that it's not in stock, and that the dealer can't get hold of it from Bosch UK or Bosch Germany. So I've just bought another used one from ebay...
(For anyone who might find this useful, the Porsche part number is 951.606.113.00, Bosch part number is 0280120400, Volvo part number is 3517772.)
Battery voltage: yes, checked that, and there's no problem there.
Idle stabilizer is an interesting idea - I'll check that out. (And no, I didn't get Noid lights and do that test because I'm sure it's a spark problem - though for the sake of completeness I should do it.)
Also, I did have one incident the other day of the engine dying again while driving with TPS disconnected, so perhaps the TPS isn't the only thing still at fault...
I still haven't installed a new TPS, and therefore seen how it runs with a definitely-OK unit, as these things seem rather hard to get hold of - albeit I haven't taken the simple but expensive route of getting it from a Porsche dealer. The used one I bought on ebay didn't work, so I ordered a brand new one from an online parts supplier. A few days later they said they couldn't get hold of it, and refunded my money. I've been ringing round and keep being told that it's not in stock, and that the dealer can't get hold of it from Bosch UK or Bosch Germany. So I've just bought another used one from ebay...
(For anyone who might find this useful, the Porsche part number is 951.606.113.00, Bosch part number is 0280120400, Volvo part number is 3517772.)
#75
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Carefully peel the rubber boot back on each of the four injector connectors and then report your findings.
Thanks for the suggestions chaps.
Battery voltage: yes, checked that, and there's no problem there.
Idle stabilizer is an interesting idea - I'll check that out. (And no, I didn't get Noid lights and do that test because I'm sure it's a spark problem - though for the sake of completeness I should do it.)
Also, I did have one incident the other day of the engine dying again while driving with TPS disconnected, so perhaps the TPS isn't the only thing still at fault...
I still haven't installed a new TPS, and therefore seen how it runs with a definitely-OK unit, as these things seem rather hard to get hold of - albeit I haven't taken the simple but expensive route of getting it from a Porsche dealer. The used one I bought on ebay didn't work, so I ordered a brand new one from an online parts supplier. A few days later they said they couldn't get hold of it, and refunded my money. I've been ringing round and keep being told that it's not in stock, and that the dealer can't get hold of it from Bosch UK or Bosch Germany. So I've just bought another used one from ebay...
(For anyone who might find this useful, the Porsche part number is 951.606.113.00, Bosch part number is 0280120400, Volvo part number is 3517772.)
Battery voltage: yes, checked that, and there's no problem there.
Idle stabilizer is an interesting idea - I'll check that out. (And no, I didn't get Noid lights and do that test because I'm sure it's a spark problem - though for the sake of completeness I should do it.)
Also, I did have one incident the other day of the engine dying again while driving with TPS disconnected, so perhaps the TPS isn't the only thing still at fault...
I still haven't installed a new TPS, and therefore seen how it runs with a definitely-OK unit, as these things seem rather hard to get hold of - albeit I haven't taken the simple but expensive route of getting it from a Porsche dealer. The used one I bought on ebay didn't work, so I ordered a brand new one from an online parts supplier. A few days later they said they couldn't get hold of it, and refunded my money. I've been ringing round and keep being told that it's not in stock, and that the dealer can't get hold of it from Bosch UK or Bosch Germany. So I've just bought another used one from ebay...
(For anyone who might find this useful, the Porsche part number is 951.606.113.00, Bosch part number is 0280120400, Volvo part number is 3517772.)