engine cutting out - at the end of my rope (long)
#16
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
When you test/wiggle the wires, are they as hot as when it cuts out? When it cuts out, do the dash lights come on?
#17
Drifting
Thread Starter
When the engine cuts and quickly refires (as in the video I posted), no dash lights but a jumpy tach. However, when it completely dies, the tach doesn't jump around but the ! light does come on.
I picked up a code reader from Prack so will try that in a few weeks when I have a chance to drive it. Chris is thinking poor engine or DME ground so will test that when I have a chance to get the car nice and hot and look for a voltage drop.
#18
Three Wheelin'
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: formerly RI, then MO, now CA
Posts: 1,649
Likes: 0
Received 7 Likes
on
7 Posts
If forgot to physically check last night, but I believe there is a separate relay for the DME and Ignition.
A few weeks ago I had the same symptoms you describe. Tach would jump a few hundred RPM just as the engine cuts out, sometimes it comes right back to life, sometimes I need to crank the car to get it to start and other times it required me to let it sit for a while.
The root cause, in my case, was a faulty Ignition relay. One of the terminal rivets had loosened and would occasionally cut power to the relay's coil.
A few weeks ago I had the same symptoms you describe. Tach would jump a few hundred RPM just as the engine cuts out, sometimes it comes right back to life, sometimes I need to crank the car to get it to start and other times it required me to let it sit for a while.
The root cause, in my case, was a faulty Ignition relay. One of the terminal rivets had loosened and would occasionally cut power to the relay's coil.
#19
Rennlist Member
Ok, read your responses. You might still want to open the boot of FI connector that is most twisted or bent, just to be sure the wires have insulation and are not touching. Otherwise, if the tach is bumping that's good. The sensors are likely good. (I did replace both female sensor connectors as well BTW, mine were crapola.)
The Potentiometer-throttle position sensor (SP?) connected to the throttle body can also have a bad female connector (I'm changing mine next...) and I'm told it might cause symptoms like yours.
You can check the ground/power to the DME and KLR with a cheap multi-meter. Kill the battery and ignition switch. Pull the connectors for BOTH the DME and the KLR so each is already removed when you turn the battery back on. Turn on the ignition and on the DME connector test pin 5 to 35 and then 5 to 18, if you have voltage the groun/power if fine. Then test the KLR from pin 6 to 14 and 6 to pin 20. this will confirm power/ground to the units. If good then you have some other gremlin or the units are perhaps bad. The shop manual has other tests you can do.
Another poster suggested ignition relay and that might be a good fix as well. I am changing mine for the heck of it as it is old.
Good luck. This stuff is soooo frustrating. I have little hair left from my recent experiences...
The Potentiometer-throttle position sensor (SP?) connected to the throttle body can also have a bad female connector (I'm changing mine next...) and I'm told it might cause symptoms like yours.
You can check the ground/power to the DME and KLR with a cheap multi-meter. Kill the battery and ignition switch. Pull the connectors for BOTH the DME and the KLR so each is already removed when you turn the battery back on. Turn on the ignition and on the DME connector test pin 5 to 35 and then 5 to 18, if you have voltage the groun/power if fine. Then test the KLR from pin 6 to 14 and 6 to pin 20. this will confirm power/ground to the units. If good then you have some other gremlin or the units are perhaps bad. The shop manual has other tests you can do.
Another poster suggested ignition relay and that might be a good fix as well. I am changing mine for the heck of it as it is old.
Good luck. This stuff is soooo frustrating. I have little hair left from my recent experiences...
#20
Drifting
Thread Starter
OK Guys. Wanted to revive this thread as I've done a little more troubleshooting. Thanks to all those who responded with their thoughts and experiences.
As I mentioned before, car cuts out abruptly. Sometimes completely dies but will restart. This typically happens under hard acceleration but has done so while cruising and idling. See my first post for parts I've replaced or swapped (pretty much everything).
Lately I've been tapping into the DME harness to try to figure out what is happening. I run small indicator lights from different circuits on the harness to see what is losing power when the engine does. Here's what I've discovered thus far:
- minimal voltage drop across the engine and DME grounds (i.e. few mv each)
- DME stays powered when the engine cuts out (I checked 2 power inputs from the DME relay) as I wanted to eliminate any upstream power interruption
- No KLR/DME error codes are thrown using the small 5-pin code reader in the engine bay
- Fuel injector signal from pin 14 is constant when the car cuts out (I thought the speed or ref sensor wiring was bad because the tach bounces, but I think this eliminates this possible cause)
- *** ignition signal to the coil (pin #1 on the DME harness) DOES cut out when the car cuts out. I found this out on the drive to work this morning.
So my questions:
1) What else would cause the signal to the coil to be interrupted? I think the speed/ref wiring is good based on my results of the fuel injector signal
2) Would a bad ignition relay as 46&2 above mentioned cause this problem or does the ignition relay feed directly to the coil?
As I mentioned before, car cuts out abruptly. Sometimes completely dies but will restart. This typically happens under hard acceleration but has done so while cruising and idling. See my first post for parts I've replaced or swapped (pretty much everything).
Lately I've been tapping into the DME harness to try to figure out what is happening. I run small indicator lights from different circuits on the harness to see what is losing power when the engine does. Here's what I've discovered thus far:
- minimal voltage drop across the engine and DME grounds (i.e. few mv each)
- DME stays powered when the engine cuts out (I checked 2 power inputs from the DME relay) as I wanted to eliminate any upstream power interruption
- No KLR/DME error codes are thrown using the small 5-pin code reader in the engine bay
- Fuel injector signal from pin 14 is constant when the car cuts out (I thought the speed or ref sensor wiring was bad because the tach bounces, but I think this eliminates this possible cause)
- *** ignition signal to the coil (pin #1 on the DME harness) DOES cut out when the car cuts out. I found this out on the drive to work this morning.
So my questions:
1) What else would cause the signal to the coil to be interrupted? I think the speed/ref wiring is good based on my results of the fuel injector signal
2) Would a bad ignition relay as 46&2 above mentioned cause this problem or does the ignition relay feed directly to the coil?
#21
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
A bad relay could cause problems yes. You can check the relay, and also when you do get a spade connector (one of the crappy crimp ones from Autozone/etc) thats the same size as the relay terminals, and try plugging it into each of the female sockets for that relay. Sometimes the female connectors in there get loose.
#23
Drifting
Thread Starter
A bad relay could cause problems yes. You can check the relay, and also when you do get a spade connector (one of the crappy crimp ones from Autozone/etc) thats the same size as the relay terminals, and try plugging it into each of the female sockets for that relay. Sometimes the female connectors in there get loose.
Oddly, neither Paragon nor 944Online carry an ignition relay.
#24
Rennlist Member
Did you open the FI boot like I suggested? In my case the FI "clip" had power -- and pin 14 worked fine...but the wires were intermittently shorting inside the FI boot itself. Keep reading this post but you do not say if you actually opened one of the boots to inspect...
#25
My car had that exact problem for a while and not just on boost. Turned out the DME chip was falling out of the socket LOL. One morning the car just plain wouldn't start so I popped open the DME and "WTF where'd my chip go!"
Check you speed/reference sensors and harnesses. Other than the cutting out, it sounds like its running really well!
Check you speed/reference sensors and harnesses. Other than the cutting out, it sounds like its running really well!
#26
Rennlist Member
My car had that exact problem for a while and not just on boost. Turned out the DME chip was falling out of the socket LOL. One morning the car just plain wouldn't start so I popped open the DME and "WTF where'd my chip go!"
Check you speed/reference sensors and harnesses. Other than the cutting out, it sounds like its running really well!
Check you speed/reference sensors and harnesses. Other than the cutting out, it sounds like its running really well!
#27
Porsche Relays
I have had several problems with relays recently, turned out to be bad / cold soldering on the internal connections. The relays can be opened (carefully with a small jewelers screwdriver) and resoldered. I think the solder that was used in those days is prone to stress cracking over time and the ends just lay against each other and cause intermitant function.
Just an suggestion.
Just an suggestion.
#28
Drifting
Thread Starter
Thanks Guys,
I *think* I might have solved it. I didn't want to post again until I know for sure. The coil signal is definitely cutting out.
I swapped the ignition relay w/ the foglight relay (they're the same) and the seems to have fixed it based upon 1 test drive. I'm going to drive it again this weekend to verify (and put the old relay back in as a test) and let you know the results.
Thanks again for all of your ideas.
I *think* I might have solved it. I didn't want to post again until I know for sure. The coil signal is definitely cutting out.
I swapped the ignition relay w/ the foglight relay (they're the same) and the seems to have fixed it based upon 1 test drive. I'm going to drive it again this weekend to verify (and put the old relay back in as a test) and let you know the results.
Thanks again for all of your ideas.
#30
Drifting
Thread Starter