Who is running water/meth?
#16
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#17
Burning Brakes
Join Date: Dec 2002
Location: ottawa
Posts: 1,086
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Can't agree more let's see more guys using the system some hard data, before we jump in the water.
#18
Rennlist Member
You can inject before or after the IC, it doesn't really matter.
Slight differences are: if you inject before, there will be slightly less pressure drop through the IC (a good thing). If you inject after, the total heat loss will be greater
There will be no puddling in the IC if you inject before; the combination of hot air coming straight from the turbo (easy evaporation) and high velocity will see to that.
Some people say they like port WI. I think it's unnessesary complication with no benefits. Anti-detonation capability is very good, but with a hair less power.
However, doing all this will basically not improve on anything if you're running out of turbocharger (ie. those that want to go nuts with their stock turbo): A proper WI system will make your charge air denser (this is what we want); but, then your turbo will have to flow even more air to keep the same boost. So, then it will spin even more out of its efficiency range. So, then you're starting with even hotter air and more back pressure, and so on, and so on; you're chasing your tail.
WI is intended to be used on an already efficient turbo system, front to back.
Slight differences are: if you inject before, there will be slightly less pressure drop through the IC (a good thing). If you inject after, the total heat loss will be greater
There will be no puddling in the IC if you inject before; the combination of hot air coming straight from the turbo (easy evaporation) and high velocity will see to that.
Some people say they like port WI. I think it's unnessesary complication with no benefits. Anti-detonation capability is very good, but with a hair less power.
However, doing all this will basically not improve on anything if you're running out of turbocharger (ie. those that want to go nuts with their stock turbo): A proper WI system will make your charge air denser (this is what we want); but, then your turbo will have to flow even more air to keep the same boost. So, then it will spin even more out of its efficiency range. So, then you're starting with even hotter air and more back pressure, and so on, and so on; you're chasing your tail.
WI is intended to be used on an already efficient turbo system, front to back.
#19
I am looking into the smow performance Stage 2 MAF boost cooler.
http://www.snowperformance.net/product.php?pk=9
http://www.snowperformance.net/product.php?pk=9
#20
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
As everyone already knows it, WI has many benefits. I did evaluate the various offerings on the market, some good some are just basic systems. The more control you have the better, so pick your system based on features not just price.
One item I found lacking on most systems, except some of the over $1000 kits, is a fail-safe mode. When your car is tuned to run X amount of boost and ignition advance based on WI, what happens when the WI system fails. Some of the failures are: No water, pump failure, solenoid failure, nozzle clogged etc.. A good system will go to safety-mode by itself. Safety mode can be in the form of dumping the boost to a preset level, setting ignition retard to a preset max value etc.. You add to this list.
To get a system that operates in closed-loop requires good design, good components selection and good testing. A good system without good support and without educating the customer will fail.
There are plenty of systems on the market, do your homework and get a system you can live with.
I have spent some time looking into a WI system for the 951. However, to get it to do what I think a WI system should do, it will drive the price up. At this stage, it's sitting on the back burner. I might end up offering a subsystem that can be used with some of the existing kits. Some of the WI companies sell 500+ units a month, it will be impossible to offer a kit to match their prices.
Great thread, lots of positive input.
One item I found lacking on most systems, except some of the over $1000 kits, is a fail-safe mode. When your car is tuned to run X amount of boost and ignition advance based on WI, what happens when the WI system fails. Some of the failures are: No water, pump failure, solenoid failure, nozzle clogged etc.. A good system will go to safety-mode by itself. Safety mode can be in the form of dumping the boost to a preset level, setting ignition retard to a preset max value etc.. You add to this list.
To get a system that operates in closed-loop requires good design, good components selection and good testing. A good system without good support and without educating the customer will fail.
There are plenty of systems on the market, do your homework and get a system you can live with.
I have spent some time looking into a WI system for the 951. However, to get it to do what I think a WI system should do, it will drive the price up. At this stage, it's sitting on the back burner. I might end up offering a subsystem that can be used with some of the existing kits. Some of the WI companies sell 500+ units a month, it will be impossible to offer a kit to match their prices.
Great thread, lots of positive input.
#21
UAE Rennlist Ambassador
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#23
Intermediate
If im not mistaken the KLR has a limp mode. Wouldnt it be easy to rid a fluid level device to trip the limp mode in the klr when the fluid / pressure / what ever you want reaches a certain point???
Im using a fluid level warning light to trigger an LED on the insturment pannel. the same one that triggers when N2O pressure is to low.
Im using a fluid level warning light to trigger an LED on the insturment pannel. the same one that triggers when N2O pressure is to low.
#24
Intermediate
aagghhh.. meth this and meth that, J/K
just replace the pump, get larger injectors, remap the ecu for e85 and run 28lbs of boost all day long.
problem solved.
(a friend has an eclipse with 650+hp dialy driver on e85 at 28psi with no knock)
just replace the pump, get larger injectors, remap the ecu for e85 and run 28lbs of boost all day long.
problem solved.
(a friend has an eclipse with 650+hp dialy driver on e85 at 28psi with no knock)
#26
Rennlist Member
I just installed a stage 2 kit from: http://www.enginerunup.com/shop.php/...oost-/p_7.html
From the research I did they had the best kit for the price range I was looking at ($400 or below). I am using a 1988 944 winshield washer tank (which is smaller) than the large 944 tanks. The installation was not bad. Planning out where I wanted everything routed was the biggest challenge. I will be using windshield washer fluid at ~ 35% meth currently. I do have a TEC2 so I can adjust timing and fuel parameters and datalog AFR's. I would like to publicly thank Laust for his help and numerous PM's guiding me through this. He has a kick butt port water injection system.
Based on calculations I found that for my performance levels a 4gph nozzle was right in the range with the 150psi pump I have. Browse around the link above, their digital controllers look really nice and adjustment would certainly be a plus. Also guys running meth (alky) through your Aluminum intercoolers will corrode them so put your nozzles after the intercooler. I am hopefully going to get the Callaway back on the road over labor day weekend. I will post my results.
I was going to post a thread once I had everything up but here a few pics as of now.
From the research I did they had the best kit for the price range I was looking at ($400 or below). I am using a 1988 944 winshield washer tank (which is smaller) than the large 944 tanks. The installation was not bad. Planning out where I wanted everything routed was the biggest challenge. I will be using windshield washer fluid at ~ 35% meth currently. I do have a TEC2 so I can adjust timing and fuel parameters and datalog AFR's. I would like to publicly thank Laust for his help and numerous PM's guiding me through this. He has a kick butt port water injection system.
Based on calculations I found that for my performance levels a 4gph nozzle was right in the range with the 150psi pump I have. Browse around the link above, their digital controllers look really nice and adjustment would certainly be a plus. Also guys running meth (alky) through your Aluminum intercoolers will corrode them so put your nozzles after the intercooler. I am hopefully going to get the Callaway back on the road over labor day weekend. I will post my results.
I was going to post a thread once I had everything up but here a few pics as of now.
#27
Instructor
Join Date: Jan 2007
Location: Atlanta, GA
Posts: 201
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The WRX guys are doing a ton of work/tuning with WI and Meth. Check out this forum for enough info to make you dizzy. Some really big results out of meth/water going on though.
http://forums.nasioc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=145
http://forums.nasioc.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=145
#28
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Charlie944, Nice setup. Keep your eyes on the boost activated switch you are using. The manufacturer recommends against using it in the engine bay. Many WI kits include it as it's inexpensive in comparison the the sealed units.
#29
Drive-by provocation guy
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: NAS PAX River, by way of Orlando
Posts: 10,439
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#30
Drive-by provocation guy
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: NAS PAX River, by way of Orlando
Posts: 10,439
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
And for a super fail safe, one can always run WI with no increase of boost or timing and just get the benefits of a cooler charge air, which for every X amount of degree drop of intake temps results in X amount of increased hp and throttle response.