limits of auto trans?
#16
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
interesting. since I definitely will not be using a Porsche engine, I am not too concerned with that aspect. I really want to make a 928 monster, but there doesnt seem to be a convincing argument for it.
I have never owned an auto high hp car that was fun to drive in corners and such. That is my main goal. I would like to be able to run laps on an N-Ring type track and have some fun. I am just not convinced that an auto trans will get me there. The whole paddle shifting idea seems pretty cool though. I just wonder how well the paddle shifter kit will work.
I have never owned an auto high hp car that was fun to drive in corners and such. That is my main goal. I would like to be able to run laps on an N-Ring type track and have some fun. I am just not convinced that an auto trans will get me there. The whole paddle shifting idea seems pretty cool though. I just wonder how well the paddle shifter kit will work.
#18
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I have never owned an auto high hp car that was fun to drive in corners and such. That is my main goal. I would like to be able to run laps on an N-Ring type track and have some fun. I am just not convinced that an auto trans will get me there. The whole paddle shifting idea seems pretty cool though. I just wonder how well the paddle shifter kit will work.
#19
Administrator - "Tyson"
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Sometimes lack of vehicle capability adds to the enjoyment.
The best cars in the corners are low(er) HP, and perfectly balanced.
See my avatar, that is Jeremy Clarkson explaining why the Toyobaru BRZ is quite possibly one of the most fun cars to drive in a very long time. If you could somehow give it 500hp without unbalancing the car (and adding weight), it would ruin it.
This coming from the guy that screams "POWER!!!!" every chance he gets.
#20
Race Director
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
+1
Sometimes lack of vehicle capability adds to the enjoyment.
The best cars in the corners are low(er) HP, and perfectly balanced.
See my avatar, that is Jeremy Clarkson explaining why the Toyobaru BRZ is quite possibly one of the most fun cars to drive in a very long time. If you could somehow give it 500hp without unbalancing the car (and adding weight), it would ruin it.
This coming from the guy that screams "POWER!!!!" every chance he gets.
Sometimes lack of vehicle capability adds to the enjoyment.
The best cars in the corners are low(er) HP, and perfectly balanced.
See my avatar, that is Jeremy Clarkson explaining why the Toyobaru BRZ is quite possibly one of the most fun cars to drive in a very long time. If you could somehow give it 500hp without unbalancing the car (and adding weight), it would ruin it.
This coming from the guy that screams "POWER!!!!" every chance he gets.
#21
Developer
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
I side with Mark Donahue on this one... and the epic 917-30. I want the power, and perfect setup and balance. It doesn't have to be either-or. It can be both.
That's what I want, mind you, not what I have. Not yet - but we try.
That's what I want, mind you, not what I have. Not yet - but we try.
#22
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
#24
Former Sponsor
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The automatic is good for 600-ish horsepower (as seen with Andy's GTS), while the 5-speed is good up to 900 CHP (in Carl's racer).
Not sure what a muscle-car shift kit is- different torque converter? Yes, those are available. Hurst quarter stick shifters? No, not available.
I'm not aware of anyone with a paddle-shifted 928.
Switching a manual into an auto is a giant pain in the ***. Lots of threads about it in the archives.
Were I going down this road, I would start with a 5-speed car and do the LSx/Dinsbox conversion.
Not sure what a muscle-car shift kit is- different torque converter? Yes, those are available. Hurst quarter stick shifters? No, not available.
I'm not aware of anyone with a paddle-shifted 928.
Switching a manual into an auto is a giant pain in the ***. Lots of threads about it in the archives.
Were I going down this road, I would start with a 5-speed car and do the LSx/Dinsbox conversion.
That "900hp" engine had something very "inconsistant" (I'm being magnanimous, these days) about it...wouldn't "pull" 5th gear......either at Bonneville or when Mark Anderson drove it.
If you've ever tried to put "a real" 500 ft. lbs. through any "style" 928 clutch, the clutch input shaft, and the torque tube....you would know that nothing there will "handle" than amount of torque, for "extended" periods of time. And even once those problems are solved....there's literally "truck loads" (off road racing) of data about how much power those stock C/V joints and axles will handle.
Whenever any particular vehicle "type" gets modified, there are always "limits" to what the chassis, the brakes, and the drivetrain will handle.
I feel very "limited" in what I can "feed" through the 928 with a manual transmission, right now.....
Yes, I know that there are people, out there, that think or claim to be making big horsepower and big torque out of the 928 engine....with the only proof being a "Dream-O-Meter" dyno chart.
But when the time comes to prove it, they suddenly have a 900hp engine that won't go over 205mph.
What does that "Dream-O-Meter" dyno chart mean when that happens?
Not much.
Last edited by GregBBRD; 02-22-2013 at 07:38 PM.
#25
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
do any of you guys have any idea what amount of power a 3 speed auto could handle? I just want to know the limits so I don't break something and have to put a new one in.
#26
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
That's where that 75% comes from.
You don't do that.
Cornering is steady state stuff. Your braking and shifting is done before turn in to have the car settled from entrance to exit.
Anything else is racecraft, and you're not going to be doing that.
And oh ya..WHEN you change gears..."click"..and it's done...you only need 2 of em.
![Smilie](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/smile.gif)
#28
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
But at the power levels hes shooting for, its his only stable option.
Just..I appreciate he's trying, but he owns all the wrong kit for his big dreams here...and even if he did, he wants to go about it the hard way...which he is welcome to do.
But when it ends up another "Parts for sale from my 10yr GM conversion project.." it'll be sad.
A blown 4.7 would blow his mind, and well, work.