S4 and Greater Fan Control Module
#47
Nordschleife Master
^^^^^^
Don't say that!!! I just got a used one from 928 International... I think I better cross my fingers and hope it lasts till we get some sort of (I hope affordable) replacement!
Don't say that!!! I just got a used one from 928 International... I think I better cross my fingers and hope it lasts till we get some sort of (I hope affordable) replacement!
#48
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Tangent: Folks, make darn sure your fans aren't dragging. The factory piece is more than capable if the loads from the fans aren't excessive. Clean motors with new bearings is a huge part of the solution. Think of the final stages failure as a symptom, dragging motors as the problem. I'm all in on a more reliable module from John, probably two in my case so I can have another working spare JIC. But the fans are where I'll be putting the most effort.
#49
Former Vendor
Tangent: Folks, make darn sure your fans aren't dragging. The factory piece is more than capable if the loads from the fans aren't excessive. Clean motors with new bearings is a huge part of the solution. Think of the final stages failure as a symptom, dragging motors as the problem. I'm all in on a more reliable module from John, probably two in my case so I can have another working spare JIC. But the fans are where I'll be putting the most effort.
My experience would indicate that these fan amplifiers are not nearly as reliable as you think they are....and now that they are getting older, they all seem to be on their "last legs".
A fairly large percentage of these units have the little peened over pot metal "transistor retaining" nubs broken off, which means the transistors no longer make contact with the heat sink.
You can do almost anything you want, with the fans, but if the transistors loose the ability to transfer their heat, I'd guess it is going to be "over" pretty darn quick.
#50
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Damn, Greg. I had one reliable data point. Right up until it failed on one channel, the one that coincides with the dragging fan. I'm on the list of interested replacement unit buyers. I'll fix one that I have, drop one of the new modules into another, and continue to drive on the on the replacement I'd socked away until it fails. Obviously I had plenty of faith in the original, but still CYA'd with a working spare when the opportunity presented itself.
The dragging fan will get bearings, as will the other one.
The dragging fan will get bearings, as will the other one.
#51
Almost Deleted
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
All, lots of progress on the boards. We have a full parts list, multiple source vendors and a sample board design. We're finalizing the circuit through a Spice model. A few questions:
- What is the current requirement for the fans? We need this to verify our model.
- We have yet to find a suitable replacement for the connector head. If we can't find one, then we have two options:
1) setup a refurb system where you send us your dead units and we use your existing connector and housing. we replace the board with a new unit and solder on your existing header
2) we build a completely new unit with a complementary header. We also ship a "pigtail" which you splice into the existing harness. This requires more work from the owner, but removes _all_ of the old components.
Technically speaking, we can probably do both options given enough time in doing the board layout. However, I'd like to see which option is more popular.
- What is the current requirement for the fans? We need this to verify our model.
- We have yet to find a suitable replacement for the connector head. If we can't find one, then we have two options:
1) setup a refurb system where you send us your dead units and we use your existing connector and housing. we replace the board with a new unit and solder on your existing header
2) we build a completely new unit with a complementary header. We also ship a "pigtail" which you splice into the existing harness. This requires more work from the owner, but removes _all_ of the old components.
Technically speaking, we can probably do both options given enough time in doing the board layout. However, I'd like to see which option is more popular.
#52
Rennlist Member
John,
WTH is a "spice" model? Isn't that some sort of look good girl singing group?
Maybe one of the more electron enlightened crowd could chime in on the current requirement. I do
believe that each fan uses a 30 amp fuse, though.
Either way you do it would be okay with me since I and people like me have extras. The "core"method would hurt the folk that do not have an extra and also the onesy's that will occur after the intial rush but contact you when their controller fails, but it would probably be the most economical and I guess, aesthetically pleasing (since it will look like original)
WTH is a "spice" model? Isn't that some sort of look good girl singing group?
Maybe one of the more electron enlightened crowd could chime in on the current requirement. I do
believe that each fan uses a 30 amp fuse, though.
Either way you do it would be okay with me since I and people like me have extras. The "core"method would hurt the folk that do not have an extra and also the onesy's that will occur after the intial rush but contact you when their controller fails, but it would probably be the most economical and I guess, aesthetically pleasing (since it will look like original)
#53
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
John--
I'll plug in my cute little H-F ammeter thingy in the morning. Says it will handle up to 30A. Good test for it.
I'll plug in my cute little H-F ammeter thingy in the morning. Says it will handle up to 30A. Good test for it.
#54
Rennlist Member
There will be a much larger initial surge current than the steady state amps.
Simulate a large inductive load in your Spice model. Get your boys to measure the inductance of the fan windings.
Simulate a large inductive load in your Spice model. Get your boys to measure the inductance of the fan windings.
Last edited by John Speake; 08-29-2012 at 01:01 PM.
#55
Almost Deleted
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Ha! "Spice" is a computer modeling tool for electronic circuits. It simulates the function of a given circuit based upon different input. It allows us to verify that the circuit is truly correct before taping out and having one built.
John,
WTH is a "spice" model? Isn't that some sort of look good girl singing group?
Maybe one of the more electron enlightened crowd could chime in on the current requirement. I do
believe that each fan uses a 30 amp fuse, though.
Either way you do it would be okay with me since I and people like me have extras. The "core"method would hurt the folk that do not have an extra and also the onesy's that will occur after the intial rush but contact you when their controller fails, but it would probably be the most economical and I guess, aesthetically pleasing (since it will look like original)
WTH is a "spice" model? Isn't that some sort of look good girl singing group?
Maybe one of the more electron enlightened crowd could chime in on the current requirement. I do
believe that each fan uses a 30 amp fuse, though.
Either way you do it would be okay with me since I and people like me have extras. The "core"method would hurt the folk that do not have an extra and also the onesy's that will occur after the intial rush but contact you when their controller fails, but it would probably be the most economical and I guess, aesthetically pleasing (since it will look like original)
#56
Rennlist Member
Yes do not neglect the inductive load in the model!! I prefer the new unit to direct plug into the same spot as the old one, I'll send a core. I even have a spare.
#59
Almost Deleted
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
G8RB8, I believe we can get this setup. Shouldn't be a problem.
fraggle, thanks for the donation! This will be greatly appreciated. We also have a few others floating around the DFW group.
fraggle, thanks for the donation! This will be greatly appreciated. We also have a few others floating around the DFW group.
#60
Chronic Tool Dropper
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Fan reads about 17 Amps steady load, inrush/surge was less than 20 Amps.
Unplugged both fuses so the controller would see a fault when testing just one, and force high speed. AC running to get the fans on. Middle speed is about 10 Amps running.