Safety of 20 Year Old Airbags?
#16
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I worked on the sensors for the first series of airbags. The sensors are good forever, but that's not the issue.
I've asked the same kind of questions. It used to be that the explosive material was pretty sensitive to humidity, age, etc. I know the DOT required all kinds of safety specs for the charge, so I'm concerned about 20 YO airbags more for their ability to deploy when needed rather than an inadvertent deployment.
The sensors are mounted at the inside base of the A pillar against the wall of the junction of the door support and just inside the firewall. They are mounted horizontally and have a three wire connection that comes off the sensor, through a pigtail that has a waterproof rubber connector boot. The reference resistance is 10Ohms, and it can often throw a fault when the resistance goes up with age.
There are two sensors, one left and right. For the airbag to deploy, both sensors must show a dead short from the reference resistance within a few milliseconds of each other. It takes a jolt of about +8Gs for the bags to deploy. This eliminates false deployments in a front end crash where the likelyhood of injury is pretty low. You really have to knock someone hard for them to go off.
I'd like to think the airbags are available new, but I'm pretty sure the only thing you would get from Porsche now is NOS. It would be interesting to know the date of last mfg. I'm sure if you could find newer ones they would be $$$$$,$$$$$$$.
I've asked the same kind of questions. It used to be that the explosive material was pretty sensitive to humidity, age, etc. I know the DOT required all kinds of safety specs for the charge, so I'm concerned about 20 YO airbags more for their ability to deploy when needed rather than an inadvertent deployment.
The sensors are mounted at the inside base of the A pillar against the wall of the junction of the door support and just inside the firewall. They are mounted horizontally and have a three wire connection that comes off the sensor, through a pigtail that has a waterproof rubber connector boot. The reference resistance is 10Ohms, and it can often throw a fault when the resistance goes up with age.
There are two sensors, one left and right. For the airbag to deploy, both sensors must show a dead short from the reference resistance within a few milliseconds of each other. It takes a jolt of about +8Gs for the bags to deploy. This eliminates false deployments in a front end crash where the likelyhood of injury is pretty low. You really have to knock someone hard for them to go off.
I'd like to think the airbags are available new, but I'm pretty sure the only thing you would get from Porsche now is NOS. It would be interesting to know the date of last mfg. I'm sure if you could find newer ones they would be $$$$$,$$$$$$$.
#17
Race Car
If you want, put a call into PCNA tomorrow: 800-767-7243 and see what they say. They might refer you back to a dealer or they might get a solid answer.
I am glad to read what "blown 87" wrote as your concern has been mine as I've been researching not only 928 but also other older vehicles.
While I never go anywhere front or back seat without a seatbelt, I am a short person. The airbags in older vehicles are not usually the multi-stage type found in today's vehicles and fully deploy which can sometimes cause more harm than an actual accident.
I would assume these are single-stage type.
Michael
I am glad to read what "blown 87" wrote as your concern has been mine as I've been researching not only 928 but also other older vehicles.
While I never go anywhere front or back seat without a seatbelt, I am a short person. The airbags in older vehicles are not usually the multi-stage type found in today's vehicles and fully deploy which can sometimes cause more harm than an actual accident.
I would assume these are single-stage type.
Michael
#18
Been selling Twinkies on Ebay,
have some extra cash right now.
Rennlist Member
have some extra cash right now.
Rennlist Member
#19
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#20
Been selling Twinkies on Ebay,
have some extra cash right now.
Rennlist Member
have some extra cash right now.
Rennlist Member
Do you know if the 8G's required to trip them is a common figure for other cars? Or is it less because they're away from the crush zones? As in, the crumple zones sustain higher G's (as they are being deformed) than the passenger compartment. Just curious.
#21
Rest in Peace
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Bird lover in Sharpsburg
Posts: 9,903
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
I worked on the sensors for the first series of airbags. The sensors are good forever, but that's not the issue.
I've asked the same kind of questions. It used to be that the explosive material was pretty sensitive to humidity, age, etc. I know the DOT required all kinds of safety specs for the charge, so I'm concerned about 20 YO airbags more for their ability to deploy when needed rather than an inadvertent deployment.
The sensors are mounted at the inside base of the A pillar against the wall of the junction of the door support and just inside the firewall. They are mounted horizontally and have a three wire connection that comes off the sensor, through a pigtail that has a waterproof rubber connector boot. The reference resistance is 10Ohms, and it can often throw a fault when the resistance goes up with age.
There are two sensors, one left and right. For the airbag to deploy, both sensors must show a dead short from the reference resistance within a few milliseconds of each other. It takes a jolt of about +8Gs for the bags to deploy. This eliminates false deployments in a front end crash where the likelyhood of injury is pretty low. You really have to knock someone hard for them to go off.
I'd like to think the airbags are available new, but I'm pretty sure the only thing you would get from Porsche now is NOS. It would be interesting to know the date of last mfg. I'm sure if you could find newer ones they would be $$$$$,$$$$$$$.
I've asked the same kind of questions. It used to be that the explosive material was pretty sensitive to humidity, age, etc. I know the DOT required all kinds of safety specs for the charge, so I'm concerned about 20 YO airbags more for their ability to deploy when needed rather than an inadvertent deployment.
The sensors are mounted at the inside base of the A pillar against the wall of the junction of the door support and just inside the firewall. They are mounted horizontally and have a three wire connection that comes off the sensor, through a pigtail that has a waterproof rubber connector boot. The reference resistance is 10Ohms, and it can often throw a fault when the resistance goes up with age.
There are two sensors, one left and right. For the airbag to deploy, both sensors must show a dead short from the reference resistance within a few milliseconds of each other. It takes a jolt of about +8Gs for the bags to deploy. This eliminates false deployments in a front end crash where the likelyhood of injury is pretty low. You really have to knock someone hard for them to go off.
I'd like to think the airbags are available new, but I'm pretty sure the only thing you would get from Porsche now is NOS. It would be interesting to know the date of last mfg. I'm sure if you could find newer ones they would be $$$$$,$$$$$$$.
Have you ever heard of one that did not go off when commanded to?
#23
Former Sponsor
All of the airbag problems I've had with 928's have been with the control units, except for a couple of steering wheel contact problems with the "winding spring".
I did have a customer with a 1990 that deployed the passenger airbag (interesting that it only set off one side), but he had been ignoring the airbag warning light for months, before this happened.
Model year 1990 used a system that had the loom hard wired to the brain and the sensors. When anything goes wrong, it needs to be updated to the later system, which has two separate looms with a separate brain and crash sensors. Major dollars to update. Model year 1991 and later used this style system.
We seem to replace quite a few of the control units on the later systems...I always keep my ear open for good used control units, as they do seem a bit hard to find, at times.
I've never seen any information from Porsche about replacing the airbags after a certain age.
I did have a customer with a 1990 that deployed the passenger airbag (interesting that it only set off one side), but he had been ignoring the airbag warning light for months, before this happened.
Model year 1990 used a system that had the loom hard wired to the brain and the sensors. When anything goes wrong, it needs to be updated to the later system, which has two separate looms with a separate brain and crash sensors. Major dollars to update. Model year 1991 and later used this style system.
We seem to replace quite a few of the control units on the later systems...I always keep my ear open for good used control units, as they do seem a bit hard to find, at times.
I've never seen any information from Porsche about replacing the airbags after a certain age.
#24
Race Car
All of the airbag problems I've had with 928's have been with the control units, except for a couple of steering wheel contact problems with the "winding spring".
I did have a customer with a 1990 that deployed the passenger airbag (interesting that it only set off one side), but he had been ignoring the airbag warning light for months, before this happened.
Model year 1990 used a system that had the loom hard wired to the brain and the sensors. When anything goes wrong, it needs to be updated to the later system, which has two separate looms with a separate brain and crash sensors. Major dollars to update. Model year 1991 and later used this style system.
We seem to replace quite a few of the control units on the later systems...I always keep my ear open for good used control units, as they do seem a bit hard to find, at times.
I've never seen any information from Porsche about replacing the airbags after a certain age.
I did have a customer with a 1990 that deployed the passenger airbag (interesting that it only set off one side), but he had been ignoring the airbag warning light for months, before this happened.
Model year 1990 used a system that had the loom hard wired to the brain and the sensors. When anything goes wrong, it needs to be updated to the later system, which has two separate looms with a separate brain and crash sensors. Major dollars to update. Model year 1991 and later used this style system.
We seem to replace quite a few of the control units on the later systems...I always keep my ear open for good used control units, as they do seem a bit hard to find, at times.
I've never seen any information from Porsche about replacing the airbags after a certain age.
#25
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I'm sure each mfg and each design is a bit different. You wouldn't use the same settings for a Corolla as you would for a Bentley.
#26
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Model year 1990 used a system that had the loom hard wired to the brain and the sensors. When anything goes wrong, it needs to be updated to the later system, which has two separate looms with a separate brain and crash sensors. Major dollars to update. Model year 1991 and later used this style system.
.
.
The earliest cars in the late 70s and early 80s did have a problem with false deployment. It lead to a few fatalities, one notable in the US that put back our development several years. Mercedes went ahead with development and was ahead of the US mfg for a while.
The 928 got the last of the series one systems for 1990 and went with S2 type bags in 1991.
#27
Instructor
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: London, U.K.
Posts: 148
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I remember a few years ago, various European manufacturers did some testing as airbags were approaching their 10 year recommended service life and there was concern this could be a "ticking time bomb" esp for the used car market.
Testing showed no noticeable degradation in performance, and it seemed to be pretty much across the board (for the makes that concerned me at the time, anyway!) that service bulletins were being updated to extend to 20 years and they envisaged this could be extended yet further when the time rolled around.
I wish I could find the original link, it came complete with a list of manufacturers and their new recommendations, but here's an example..
Testing showed no noticeable degradation in performance, and it seemed to be pretty much across the board (for the makes that concerned me at the time, anyway!) that service bulletins were being updated to extend to 20 years and they envisaged this could be extended yet further when the time rolled around.
I wish I could find the original link, it came complete with a list of manufacturers and their new recommendations, but here's an example..
#28
Instructor
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Sydney Australia
Posts: 157
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#29
Shameful Thread Killer
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Older airbag sensors just use a weighted toggle with a mass setting. There were two and the signals had to arrive at the receiver within a few milliseconds of each other or no blow.
#30
Rennlist Member
There is one other concern with our 928's. Someone told me (Jim Bailey???) that when the passenger airbag deploys, it bends the "A" pillar. When that happens, your insurance company will declare the car a total loss! The cost of replacing the "A" pillar along with the other repairs necessary will far exceed the current value of your beloved 928.
Just food for thought.
Just food for thought.