S4 bad idle
#1
Three Wheelin'
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Central New Jersey, where 287 and 78 meet.
Posts: 1,656
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
S4 bad idle - RESOLVED!!
I am at wits end and need some help.
Symptoms:
From a cold start car starts and runs fine. 750RPM solid. Once the car is up to operating temp, the idle fluctuates up and down a few hundred RPM. If the throttle is blipped, the speed will dip below 750, come up and start to bounce, settle down and start to swing in smaller amount. The ARM-1 display goes from full lean to rich corresponding to the idle speed. There is also popping in the exhaust during deceleration.
What I have done.
- Intake R&R. No air leaks, 100000% sure of this.
- Knock sensors replaced.
- Injectors cleaned.
- New fuel regulator, dampers, filter.
- New fuel lines.
- New Temp II
- Rebuilt MAF.
- New O2 sensor.
- Checked TPS at LH connector and it was good.
- Plugs, caps, rotors and air filter (stock, no K&N)
- 5 year old Nology wires. #2 did not ohm out but does carry spark.
- Did I mention no air leaks? (I know this will come up again ).
- Coils, visual inspection shows no scratches or cracks and seem to ohm out fine.
- Slight hesitation when throttle is blipped.
I did not replace the ISV, I cleaned it and was satisfied that it operated correctly before I put the intake back on. Stable idle when cold seems to indicate that it is functional, but maybe a heat issue ?
I have not looked at the LH or EZK yet and fuel pressure is an unknown at this point.
Car starts up with no problems, seems to have plenty of power and pull.
Any thoughts? Smooth idle seems to be something of a holy grail seeing as there are a number of posts about this.
thanks...
Symptoms:
From a cold start car starts and runs fine. 750RPM solid. Once the car is up to operating temp, the idle fluctuates up and down a few hundred RPM. If the throttle is blipped, the speed will dip below 750, come up and start to bounce, settle down and start to swing in smaller amount. The ARM-1 display goes from full lean to rich corresponding to the idle speed. There is also popping in the exhaust during deceleration.
What I have done.
- Intake R&R. No air leaks, 100000% sure of this.
- Knock sensors replaced.
- Injectors cleaned.
- New fuel regulator, dampers, filter.
- New fuel lines.
- New Temp II
- Rebuilt MAF.
- New O2 sensor.
- Checked TPS at LH connector and it was good.
- Plugs, caps, rotors and air filter (stock, no K&N)
- 5 year old Nology wires. #2 did not ohm out but does carry spark.
- Did I mention no air leaks? (I know this will come up again ).
- Coils, visual inspection shows no scratches or cracks and seem to ohm out fine.
- Slight hesitation when throttle is blipped.
I did not replace the ISV, I cleaned it and was satisfied that it operated correctly before I put the intake back on. Stable idle when cold seems to indicate that it is functional, but maybe a heat issue ?
I have not looked at the LH or EZK yet and fuel pressure is an unknown at this point.
Car starts up with no problems, seems to have plenty of power and pull.
Any thoughts? Smooth idle seems to be something of a holy grail seeing as there are a number of posts about this.
thanks...
Last edited by NickT; 05-13-2008 at 09:29 PM.
#2
Craic Head
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Are you sure you have no air leaks in intake?
Just kidding, how about the throttle cable, is it adjusted properly? I'm not following the whole part where the rpms drop slightly when you hit the gas, but that seems key to me.
edit: 5 year old wires where one is questionable might be a good place to look also.
also possibly timing? Popping during decel and the hesitation could possibly be caused by this I think.
Just kidding, how about the throttle cable, is it adjusted properly? I'm not following the whole part where the rpms drop slightly when you hit the gas, but that seems key to me.
edit: 5 year old wires where one is questionable might be a good place to look also.
also possibly timing? Popping during decel and the hesitation could possibly be caused by this I think.
#3
Rennlist Member
Next time the idle hunts up and down; pop the hood, walk around to the engine, manually close the throttle with your hand. Just push it back towards the fire wall. See if this stops the "hunting". If the idle switch is not closing, the idle will hunt up and down.
#4
Three Wheelin'
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Central New Jersey, where 287 and 78 meet.
Posts: 1,656
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Are you sure you have no air leaks in intake?
Just kidding, how about the throttle cable, is it adjusted properly? I'm not following the whole part where the rpms drop slightly when you hit the gas, but that seems key to me.
edit: 5 year old wires where one is questionable might be a good place to look also.
also possibly timing? Popping during decel and the hesitation could possibly be caused by this I think.
Just kidding, how about the throttle cable, is it adjusted properly? I'm not following the whole part where the rpms drop slightly when you hit the gas, but that seems key to me.
edit: 5 year old wires where one is questionable might be a good place to look also.
also possibly timing? Popping during decel and the hesitation could possibly be caused by this I think.
I did pick up the Porkens 32Vr timing tool and plan on checking the timing soon.
Thanks guys.
#7
Rennlist Member
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>
That depends on whether there was a problem still remaining. So how did you fix it ?
It appears in the above case that most possible causes have been eliminated, so an idle adaptation may help. But it won't mask a underlying problem.
That depends on whether there was a problem still remaining. So how did you fix it ?
It appears in the above case that most possible causes have been eliminated, so an idle adaptation may help. But it won't mask a underlying problem.
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
What you describe closely matches my own issue, detailed in this thread:
https://rennlist.com/forums/showthre...ight=jp+rodkey
By description and process of elimination, if you can't get your hands on some diagnostic equipment, sounds like the ISV is likely culprit.
https://rennlist.com/forums/showthre...ight=jp+rodkey
By description and process of elimination, if you can't get your hands on some diagnostic equipment, sounds like the ISV is likely culprit.
#10
Owns the Streets
Needs Camber
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs Camber
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Emptied about 1 whole bottle of WD-40 over the course of 1-2 weeks into the ISV. That helped a bit.
Swapping in healthier alternator with new voltage regulator definitely helped settle idle.
Hot idle would drop the old alternator to not so healthy voltage levels. Finally culminating in car dying at idle with lights on.
That's my story.
Hi, my name is Ernest and I own a 928 . . .
Swapping in healthier alternator with new voltage regulator definitely helped settle idle.
Hot idle would drop the old alternator to not so healthy voltage levels. Finally culminating in car dying at idle with lights on.
That's my story.
Hi, my name is Ernest and I own a 928 . . .
#11
Three Wheelin'
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2003
Location: Central New Jersey, where 287 and 78 meet.
Posts: 1,656
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Checked my valve timing this weekend.. Not that, both sides were spot on.
Car does have a huge bog when you blip the throttle. Reminds me of the old double pumpers dumping too much gas in.
I do need to recheck the TPS, I did check it at the LH but I want to verify that (my memory is failing). I know John had a failed one that seemed to check out so I might just put a new one in anyway.
ahhh I just want to drive the car.
Car does have a huge bog when you blip the throttle. Reminds me of the old double pumpers dumping too much gas in.
I do need to recheck the TPS, I did check it at the LH but I want to verify that (my memory is failing). I know John had a failed one that seemed to check out so I might just put a new one in anyway.
ahhh I just want to drive the car.
#13
Rennlist Member
#14
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Join Date: Oct 2003
Location: Gone. On the Open Road
Posts: 16,547
Received 1,678 Likes
on
1,088 Posts
Just to be 100% certain of what works and what doesn't: Both the LH and EZK get signals from the idle/WOT switch. Check both at both ECUs (you wrote that you checked the LH.) Same goes for Temp-II - check resistance at both ECUs.
The ISV can also be tested from the ECU pins.
The ISV can also be tested from the ECU pins.
#15
I noticed that the MAF was rebuilt. I would suggest as a quick test unplugging the MAF and determining if there is any discernible difference. Quite possibly not; but unplugging mine causes some reasonably broad and varying hunting.
Mike
Mike