Annual Oil Change? That's BS isn't it?
#31
Originally Posted by H2
So...some modern cars now recommend oil changes every 20K miles??? Wouldn't that imply that it doesn't need to be changed every 12 months? If changing oil out EVERY 12 MONTHS OR 20 20K MILES, whichever comes first would be good, why would they not state it this way? Perhaps modern cars can handle it? Or is it the oil?
I equate oil/filter changes on my 928 as a required right of ownership; why wait 'till it implodes?
#33
Cottage Industry Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Joined: Oct 2001
Posts: 25,784
Likes: 150
From: Silly Valley, CA
Originally Posted by FlyingDog
My SAAB mechanic hates the 20,000 mile oil changes. It's not because the oil can't go that long, it's that people don't check their oil level. He said a lot of people ignore the oil level or pressure light because they had not yet reached the oil change time in miles.
C'mon, what's easier - checking your oil every 3000 miles, or having it replaced every 3000 miles?
Actually, it's easier on
- your time
- your check book
- the environment
Last edited by Nicole; 05-22-2007 at 04:07 AM.
#34
Just a little material for thought for those of you who lay your cars up for the winter...
A gasoline engine generates just over one gallon of water for every gallon of fuel burned. Obviously, most of this goes out the exhaust pipe, but some makes it into the crankcase. This water combines with other combustion by-products to make several types of acids.
If you drive the car until the oil gets very warm, the condensate will be mostly driven off. (Back in the day, some folks would tell you that their car never burned oil around town, but used oil on a trip. They were adding water to the oil on the short trips, then cooking it out on the first road trip...)
If you let the car sit for a few months, and don't crank the engine at all, a Fall oil change looks better. If you crank the engine for a few minutes every so often, perhaps a Spring oil change looks better.
As in everything in life, there are trade-offs...
A gasoline engine generates just over one gallon of water for every gallon of fuel burned. Obviously, most of this goes out the exhaust pipe, but some makes it into the crankcase. This water combines with other combustion by-products to make several types of acids.
If you drive the car until the oil gets very warm, the condensate will be mostly driven off. (Back in the day, some folks would tell you that their car never burned oil around town, but used oil on a trip. They were adding water to the oil on the short trips, then cooking it out on the first road trip...)
If you let the car sit for a few months, and don't crank the engine at all, a Fall oil change looks better. If you crank the engine for a few minutes every so often, perhaps a Spring oil change looks better.
As in everything in life, there are trade-offs...
#35
Originally Posted by the flyin' scotsman
My 2003 Chev Duramax diesel states 16k kms oil changes but its a work horse truck not an exotic supercar.
I equate oil/filter changes on my 928 as a required right of ownership; why wait 'till it implodes?
I equate oil/filter changes on my 928 as a required right of ownership; why wait 'till it implodes?
#36
Dinosaur juice deteriorates after a while, regardless of use or disuse. This is for the same reason that gasoline goes bad after just sitting in the tank for a while.
If you run synthetic it won't break down, but may be just very dirty, so I'd recommend changing it before you start driving it again.
If you run synthetic it won't break down, but may be just very dirty, so I'd recommend changing it before you start driving it again.
#37
I've really enjoyed this thread! Lot's of good info here...both sides of the coin kinda stuff. I chuckled out loud at Shark Attacks corvette story! As a scientist, I've made the decision to make baseline measurements and not use oil at all.
#38
Owns the Streets
Needs Camber
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Needs Camber
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Joined: May 2003
Posts: 10,292
Likes: 1
From: New York
I myself use Slick 50. Those teflon particles will make sure whatever I do there will be ZERO abrasion damage to the moving parts of the engine.
Anyone remember Slick 50 oil additive.
My knowledgeable friend yelled at me and made me run some engine flush treatment and immediately drain that poisoned oil out.
So how does the teflon particles know which metal bits to stick to?
Anyone remember Slick 50 oil additive.
My knowledgeable friend yelled at me and made me run some engine flush treatment and immediately drain that poisoned oil out.
So how does the teflon particles know which metal bits to stick to?
#39
Originally Posted by checkmate1996
Not to be offensive or the like, but your implications with your sentence means that porsche makes a crappy engine vs the duramax. Exotic cars are not built well so baby them.
As such I maintain it well recognising its age, performance, the way its driven and also its parked for our severe winter weather.
The Duramax is a good engine but in a very, very different league and comments were in reference to the 'newer vehicles longer oil change interval' topic.
#40
All oil should always be changed once per year. It's not BS. Oil picks up moisture and contaminates, and 1 years' worth is plenty. It needs to come out of the engine, and changing it is the only way.
#41
Originally Posted by ew928
So how does the teflon particles know which metal bits to stick to?
You just don't understand modern technology, do you?
#42
Supercharged
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Joined: May 2002
Posts: 18,925
Likes: 66
From: Back in Michigan - Full time!
Originally Posted by H2
When car companies (and oil companies) are advertising increasingly long mileage intervals between oil changes...and no mention is made of time intervals...why would anyone change the oil in their 928 annually if it's only driven a few thousand miles a year? It shouldn't deteriorate just sitting there. Annual oil changes under this circumstance doesn't make sense to me? Am I missing something?
Hx2
Hx2
Ok all joking aside, there is only one way to know for sure. UOA. Used Oil Analysis I'll be using Blackstone-labs' free test kit. Hope this helps.
http://www.blackstone-labs.com/free_test_kit.html
#43
In order to have a fair comparison, I'll volunteer to continue to change my oil at least twice a year and those who believe it is all bunk can go for some sort of record, adding as necessary of course. It occurred to me that with all we spend on these cars, we ought not "cut off our nose to spite our face". But hey----someone out there call the oil companies' bluff. If you're right, all you get is sludge buildup. If you're wrong, you rebuild sooner than necessary. G
#44
Originally Posted by FlyingDog
My SAAB mechanic hates the 20,000 mile oil changes. It's not because the oil can't go that long, it's that people don't check their oil level. He said a lot of people ignore the oil level or pressure light because they had not yet reached the oil change time in miles.
Along with oil breather issues and sludging problems.
#45
Originally Posted by WallyP
If you let the car sit for a few months, and don't crank the engine at all, a Fall oil change looks better. If you crank the engine for a few minutes every so often, perhaps a Spring oil change looks better.
As in everything in life, there are trade-offs...
As in everything in life, there are trade-offs...
If you DO crank the engine..
You will whip up bad oil to places you dont want it to be.
You would have to drive the car for quite some time to get it hot enough to actually cook moisture etc out of the oil. Its not enough to just run it until its warm and then kill it..
So my conclusion is... If you must crank the engine during winter storage (I cant see any reason to why you would like to do that..) you probably need two oil changes. One in the fall and one in the spring.
If you dont crank it, an oil change in the spring would be enough.