LH Rebuild?
#1
Thread Starter
Rennlist Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 10,710
Likes: 53
From: Southern Alberta, Canada
LH Rebuild?
With our latest dump of the wet and cold white stuff my mind wandered toward winter projects this morning and the question of rebuilding the LH brain.
My car performs well (I think, only ever compared it to a Testarossa, see thread) but do realise that components are +17 years old and may have reached or exceeded life expectancy and as such may require refreshing before the 'headstone' is ordered.
I'm looking for input re. rebuilding the existing LH brain vs buying a 'spare' vs doing nothing..............you out there John Speake?
My car performs well (I think, only ever compared it to a Testarossa, see thread) but do realise that components are +17 years old and may have reached or exceeded life expectancy and as such may require refreshing before the 'headstone' is ordered.
I'm looking for input re. rebuilding the existing LH brain vs buying a 'spare' vs doing nothing..............you out there John Speake?
#3
Rich at Electronik Repair will rebuild your unit for ~580USD. My LH had been rebuilt previously and was dying--I had a rich idle and poor gas mileage. I swapped my LH for a rebuilt unit at Sharktoberfest, and saw much better idle conditions and improved mileage. I've never heard of anyone having their LH rebuilt just because it was old, but if you've run out of other things to do, well, then go for it.
Talk to Rich about the process he uses versus other rebuilders. I don't believe all rebuilds are created equal, although I don't possess the technical acumen to back up such a statement.
Talk to Rich about the process he uses versus other rebuilders. I don't believe all rebuilds are created equal, although I don't possess the technical acumen to back up such a statement.
#5
The ready availability of spares and services locally is somewhat less than in, say, California. With that in mind, I picked up a '91 GT LH & EZK (ebay for a whopping $155), a new MAF for less - and a used MAF for far less.
I understand the LH death spiral to be more a longevity issue than usage - excusing voltage spikes, etc. - so playing the odds, should my LH die, I have a statistical 3 years of life/test unit availability in hand ( ref. an '88 S4). This unit has already proven its worth by keeping Jeffs '89 on the road this summer while we had his LH rebuilt. Similarly, I stuck the 'used' MAF in his car with success after demonstrating that his original MAF would not allow my car to run.
Conclusion - it cannot hurt to have certain spares available: you never know when they may be called into service - and are just the trick for trouble shooting. As for shelling out 5-6 bills on a LH in a premptive move, I'd be tempted to wait until it dies: the lay-up time to get a replacement is mere days.
I understand the LH death spiral to be more a longevity issue than usage - excusing voltage spikes, etc. - so playing the odds, should my LH die, I have a statistical 3 years of life/test unit availability in hand ( ref. an '88 S4). This unit has already proven its worth by keeping Jeffs '89 on the road this summer while we had his LH rebuilt. Similarly, I stuck the 'used' MAF in his car with success after demonstrating that his original MAF would not allow my car to run.
Conclusion - it cannot hurt to have certain spares available: you never know when they may be called into service - and are just the trick for trouble shooting. As for shelling out 5-6 bills on a LH in a premptive move, I'd be tempted to wait until it dies: the lay-up time to get a replacement is mere days.
#6
Thread Starter
Rennlist Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 10,710
Likes: 53
From: Southern Alberta, Canada
Originally Posted by bd0nalds0n
Rich at Electronik Repair will rebuild your unit for ~580USD. My LH had been rebuilt previously and was dying--I had a rich idle and poor gas mileage. I swapped my LH for a rebuilt unit at Sharktoberfest, and saw much better idle conditions and improved mileage. I've never heard of anyone having their LH rebuilt just because it was old, but if you've run out of other things to do, well, then go for it.
Talk to Rich about the process he uses versus other rebuilders. I don't believe all rebuilds are created equal, although I don't possess the technical acumen to back up such a statement.
Talk to Rich about the process he uses versus other rebuilders. I don't believe all rebuilds are created equal, although I don't possess the technical acumen to back up such a statement.
Its not that I've run out of things to do but rather being proactive vs reactive (dead at the side of the road) and I do somewhat posses the technical aspects hence my hope of a response from Rich/ John S et al.
#7
i have a comment
Rich at http://www.electronikrepair.com/ has more knowledge in his brain about LH units...... and to boot, hes a really nice guy, really helped me out-twice....here is his email address electronikrepair@earthlink.net tell him Kyle from Erie pa sent you.
Trending Topics
#9
Thread Starter
Rennlist Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 10,710
Likes: 53
From: Southern Alberta, Canada
Originally Posted by ErnestSw
Malcom,
You're bored? Need something to do?
There are those of us without the means to even consider a Testarossa who would gladly sacrifice our left (fill in the blank) for an SC kit.
You're bored? Need something to do?
There are those of us without the means to even consider a Testarossa who would gladly sacrifice our left (fill in the blank) for an SC kit.
I'm still to young in my 48th year to be bored.............as they say back home.
Lang may yer lung reek!
#10
Captain Obvious
Super User
Super User
Joined: Aug 2003
Posts: 22,846
Likes: 340
From: Cambridge, Ontario, Canada
Originally Posted by FlyingDog
If it ain't broke, don't fix it.
I agree!!!! Especially if you are planning on buying a spare and fixing that one. There is a good chance you LH will never fail. You MAF on the other hand does have a life span. Maybe replace that first, before rebuilding a fully functioning brain.
But at the end it's your $$$$!
You don't need 30 years to get an SC...... The winters are long in AB, so build one!
#11
Malcom,
I have a problem with my S4 too... it is running rich and stinks at the rear. I will post a link in the forum. In the meanwhile, my suggestion to you is to contact Rich from Electronik Repair. He is really nice and knows his LH stuff inside out. Talk to him, the worst that can happen is getting an honest diagnostics on your car.
Sincerely,
Khaled
I have a problem with my S4 too... it is running rich and stinks at the rear. I will post a link in the forum. In the meanwhile, my suggestion to you is to contact Rich from Electronik Repair. He is really nice and knows his LH stuff inside out. Talk to him, the worst that can happen is getting an honest diagnostics on your car.
Sincerely,
Khaled
#12
As many have said, DON'T waste your money on a LH rebuilding if your engine
runs fine. The key problematic issue with the LH unit is overvoltaging the result
of; a charging of a fully dead battery via a strong charger, or an overcharging
alternator. Some rebuild their LH units when it's not necessary, thinking it's
the source of a running problem when it's not.
Check here ( www.systemsc.com/failuremodes.htm ) for info on 928 ECU problems.
Bottom line: There're many 928s running with their original LH units without any
problems!
runs fine. The key problematic issue with the LH unit is overvoltaging the result
of; a charging of a fully dead battery via a strong charger, or an overcharging
alternator. Some rebuild their LH units when it's not necessary, thinking it's
the source of a running problem when it's not.
Check here ( www.systemsc.com/failuremodes.htm ) for info on 928 ECU problems.
Bottom line: There're many 928s running with their original LH units without any
problems!
#13
Hello Malcolm,
The best thiug you can do is to get your LH checked out with a repairer who has a test jig. Then you will know if the problem lies there or not.
All the evidence is that LH ECUs will eventually fail. This is time dependant, not mileage. This week I rebuilt an LH from an '89 car with 23,000 miles on it. It is true that abuse can also shorten the life.
I do have people who have their working LH ECUs rebuilt as a precautionary measure.
BTW I charge 450USD fro a full rebuild.
Regards
The best thiug you can do is to get your LH checked out with a repairer who has a test jig. Then you will know if the problem lies there or not.
All the evidence is that LH ECUs will eventually fail. This is time dependant, not mileage. This week I rebuilt an LH from an '89 car with 23,000 miles on it. It is true that abuse can also shorten the life.
I do have people who have their working LH ECUs rebuilt as a precautionary measure.
BTW I charge 450USD fro a full rebuild.
Regards
#14
The 35 pin LHs (Porsche, Volvo, Saab) that use a custom hybrid circuit are failing at a higher rate than other ECUs (L-Jets, 25 pin LHs, Motronics, etc). I've seen failures in low and high mile cars - and have had several customers opt to rebuild their LH before it dies on them. The LH can die at the worst possible time and can ruin a trip as you wait for a replacement.
I do not advise buying a used 35 pin 928 LH as a spare. It can die sitting on the shelf just as it can die when in the car. I had a customer that bought a used LH and six months later it was dead.
I do not advise buying a used 35 pin 928 LH as a spare. It can die sitting on the shelf just as it can die when in the car. I had a customer that bought a used LH and six months later it was dead.
#15
Thread Starter
Rennlist Member
Joined: Oct 2004
Posts: 10,710
Likes: 53
From: Southern Alberta, Canada
Originally Posted by Rich9928p
The LH can die at the worst possible time and can ruin a trip as you wait for a replacement.
I do not advise buying a used 35 pin 928 LH as a spare. It can die sitting on the shelf just as it can die when in the car
I do not advise buying a used 35 pin 928 LH as a spare. It can die sitting on the shelf just as it can die when in the car
Can you advise want entails a full test on a 'jig' and the required updated and repair dependant on status.