Sewer Lids vs D90
#17
Race Car
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Sewer lids are forged wheels. The club sport wheels are the sewer lids with larger cutouts. I have heard of people cutting out the extra material from sewer lids to get them like club sports.
The D90's are a cast wheel.
IMHO the downside to sewer lids on the track is two fold.
1) limited cooling due to so much wheel? I am guessing here...
2) limited hand hold and vision to line up the studs. My race car sees wheel changes 2-3 times were weekend so it is really nice to be able to qucikly see the studs and be able to grab the center of the wheel to hold it.
The D90's are a cast wheel.
IMHO the downside to sewer lids on the track is two fold.
1) limited cooling due to so much wheel? I am guessing here...
2) limited hand hold and vision to line up the studs. My race car sees wheel changes 2-3 times were weekend so it is really nice to be able to qucikly see the studs and be able to grab the center of the wheel to hold it.
As for holding the wheel it is super simple since the sections between the vents are so narrow.
The back side of the wheels are sort of radially ribbed, so I would imagine it acts like a giant fan forcing air out the slots, and the wheels should vent very well. (I'm no engineer so don't hold me to this, that is just how it works in my head)
#18
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Guys, reality check. A 928 is a Porsche and Dr. Porsche said many a time that any car with his name on it is a race car. Hence, i would venture to guess the 928 sewer lids offer enough cooling for a much heavier 928 so they should be more than sufficient for the uber light uber agile 944 that has a motor with only half weight of the much heavier 928 motor to slow down before a turn.
#19
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The manhole wheels are forged and lightweight. If you're skilled with an angle grinder you can even cut open the slots to make them like club sports - a lister did that once.
#20
Race Director
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The thing about cooling is hot air extraction.
I have cooling ducts that bring the air into the rotor and that gets extracted at the wheel. No/limited extraction point and the air does not flow.
Still I don't know the numbers involved so they might be fine.
Also I set of BBS style basket weave wheels that came on my 944. Back in the autocross days I ran these and still do for storing the car. It is MUCH harder to get the wheel on and fine a stud with them as compared to the cookie cutters. The reason? I can't look through the wheel to find the stud as easily. Try taking tires on/off the car 3 times in one day and you will get tired of trying to line them up and missing. Heck that happens even in the dark with my cookies and I hate it.
When you race and have lots of minor work to do that is repetitive you want to find easier ways to do it. I have an electric drill I used to spin the nuts off the studs since doing it by hand takes for ever. That was a time saver that is well worth it. I also have marks on the side of the car to tell me where the jack point is. That is handy so I don't need to look for it each time I pull the jack out. I also have a dedicated 19mm socket and extentsion just for wheels. This again makes it faster loosen and torque the wheels. BTW... my torque wrench is never set (always loose) since leaving them set can slowly wear them down.
I have cooling ducts that bring the air into the rotor and that gets extracted at the wheel. No/limited extraction point and the air does not flow.
Still I don't know the numbers involved so they might be fine.
Also I set of BBS style basket weave wheels that came on my 944. Back in the autocross days I ran these and still do for storing the car. It is MUCH harder to get the wheel on and fine a stud with them as compared to the cookie cutters. The reason? I can't look through the wheel to find the stud as easily. Try taking tires on/off the car 3 times in one day and you will get tired of trying to line them up and missing. Heck that happens even in the dark with my cookies and I hate it.
When you race and have lots of minor work to do that is repetitive you want to find easier ways to do it. I have an electric drill I used to spin the nuts off the studs since doing it by hand takes for ever. That was a time saver that is well worth it. I also have marks on the side of the car to tell me where the jack point is. That is handy so I don't need to look for it each time I pull the jack out. I also have a dedicated 19mm socket and extentsion just for wheels. This again makes it faster loosen and torque the wheels. BTW... my torque wrench is never set (always loose) since leaving them set can slowly wear them down.
#22
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
The sewer lids are indeed forged wheels and are pretty much identical to the 944 club sports, but with a smaller vent hole. I can't speak to cooling, but I can tell you that my club sport wheels are noticeably lighter than my phone dials. When I switch wheel sets, the difference is obvious. For my money, I'd go for the sewer lids and polish them.
#24
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
#25
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Sorry - just sold them a couple days ago. They were posted last week in the rennlist member for sale section...
I think there was someone else there who had a set as well, but I would just be careful of the offsets on these if you're using them on the 944 - they're a high-offset and I have no idea if they will bolt up to the S2 without spacers.
I think there was someone else there who had a set as well, but I would just be careful of the offsets on these if you're using them on the 944 - they're a high-offset and I have no idea if they will bolt up to the S2 without spacers.
#26
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hello! I think I met you briefly at the tech inspection for the PCA Potomac Autocross #7. My 944S had a loose screw on the spark plug wire holder... I came in dead last for the times that day but I can't wait till they start again Spring 09!!!
Anyway, here's some 944 wheel weights. Go to
http://www.944racing.de/
then click
Felgengewichte (under "Informationen")
and then you can convert it to English if you want.
The 8x16 Fuchs sewer lids ("Gullydeckel") weigh the same as the 8x16 Phone Dials, which is 20 lbs or so, which in my opinion is pretty lightweight for a "stock" wheel in that size.
Sewer lid aesthetics... well, that's up to you
Anyway, here's some 944 wheel weights. Go to
http://www.944racing.de/
then click
Felgengewichte (under "Informationen")
and then you can convert it to English if you want.
The 8x16 Fuchs sewer lids ("Gullydeckel") weigh the same as the 8x16 Phone Dials, which is 20 lbs or so, which in my opinion is pretty lightweight for a "stock" wheel in that size.
Sewer lid aesthetics... well, that's up to you
![Wink](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/wink.gif)
#27
Burning Brakes
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Hello! I think I met you briefly at the tech inspection for the PCA Potomac Autocross #7. My 944S had a loose screw on the spark plug wire holder... I came in dead last for the times that day but I can't wait till they start again Spring 09!!!
Anyway, here's some 944 wheel weights. Go to
http://www.944racing.de/
then click
Felgengewichte (under "Informationen")
and then you can convert it to English if you want.
The 8x16 Fuchs sewer lids ("Gullydeckel") weigh the same as the 8x16 Phone Dials, which is 20 lbs or so, which in my opinion is pretty lightweight for a "stock" wheel in that size.
Sewer lid aesthetics... well, that's up to you![Wink](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/wink.gif)
Anyway, here's some 944 wheel weights. Go to
http://www.944racing.de/
then click
Felgengewichte (under "Informationen")
and then you can convert it to English if you want.
The 8x16 Fuchs sewer lids ("Gullydeckel") weigh the same as the 8x16 Phone Dials, which is 20 lbs or so, which in my opinion is pretty lightweight for a "stock" wheel in that size.
Sewer lid aesthetics... well, that's up to you
![Wink](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/smilies/wink.gif)
Thanks for the info, I will have to check it out. That was me at Tech. Glad you had a good time. I started off the year doing well, I then updated my suspension and have been getting faster; however, so has everyone else and the seem to be doing it a little faster than me. I am going to pick up a spare set of wheels to run some R compounds. Most of the 944 guys are already running them since we have no stock class. At least that is what I am blaming the difference in time on. I don't care for the looks of the sewer lids but if they are light and the right offset then they will be fine for me for autocrossing. Hope to see you at some events.
#28
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
http://www.928registry.org/928-wheels-S4-flat-disc.htm