Yet another Should I buy this 944 post (needs a motor)
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
![Question](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon5.gif)
Hey all, I am looking at a late 1985 model (has the oval dash) normally aspirated 5spd that's here in my area for $5500. It has 300k miles. Has bilsteins and some aftermarket exhaust. The interior has been redone, not all to stock look, but its okay. Current owner just got it, verified everything was working, then had an engine tapping sound show up and he parked it and there are metal shavings in the oil pan. On talking to him, he has paperwork that it had a rebuild not that many miles ago. Says all other systems are go. Might need a little bodywork on the front chin spoiler, I haven't seen it in person yet. This would strictly be a project car, not depending on it being running anytime soon. Budget would be $5k more. Could be more, but I hope that would do it and wouldn't make sense to put that much in. I see cherry ones for $20-25 pop up.
So doing a little research, I've seen that a replacement engine might be $1k or less for used? And I saw some rebuild kits through the place in OKC (sorry forgot the name) that's ~$1k ($2k to do water pump, timing belts and everything). I've pulled a couple engines before, have worked on a few VWs and a few other cars and motorcycles.
What I'm not sure is how to know if it's rebuildable? are there common failure scenarios? I see a lot of mention of some things that can be done with the engine still in the car? Does the engine have to be removed from below? I don't have a car lift, but can get an engine hoist and stand. If it's a piston or ring issue, is it possible to overbore these, or do you need to have it sleeved.
General thoughts or links to rebuild threads appreciated!
So doing a little research, I've seen that a replacement engine might be $1k or less for used? And I saw some rebuild kits through the place in OKC (sorry forgot the name) that's ~$1k ($2k to do water pump, timing belts and everything). I've pulled a couple engines before, have worked on a few VWs and a few other cars and motorcycles.
What I'm not sure is how to know if it's rebuildable? are there common failure scenarios? I see a lot of mention of some things that can be done with the engine still in the car? Does the engine have to be removed from below? I don't have a car lift, but can get an engine hoist and stand. If it's a piston or ring issue, is it possible to overbore these, or do you need to have it sleeved.
General thoughts or links to rebuild threads appreciated!
The following 2 users liked this post by 931guru:
Micah (08-06-2022),
Tiger03447 (08-18-2022)
The following 2 users liked this post by T&T Racing:
bobinnova (08-09-2022),
Tiger03447 (08-18-2022)
#4
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Don't even give it another thought...leave it alone. The only way I would consider it is if it was like $1k-1500...maybe. The cars (NA's especially) selling for 20k+ are still few and far between and are usually BAT auctions which are not necessarily representative of the real world. They also usually have 20-50k miles on them, all records, etc. There is nothing wrong with a car with high miles that has been maintained but no way would I pay 5k+ for one with a blown motor. You have no way of confirming the condition of the clutch, gearbox, etc. There are tons of people selling running examples for near the price you were looking to spend for a non-runner/questions car.
The following 2 users liked this post by papasmurf:
bobinnova (08-09-2022),
Tiger03447 (08-18-2022)
#6
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Don't even give it another thought...leave it alone. The only way I would consider it is if it was like $1k-1500...maybe. The cars (NA's especially) selling for 20k+ are still few and far between and are usually BAT auctions which are not necessarily representative of the real world. They also usually have 20-50k miles on them, all records, etc. There is nothing wrong with a car with high miles that has been maintained but no way would I pay 5k+ for one with a blown motor. You have no way of confirming the condition of the clutch, gearbox, etc. There are tons of people selling running examples for near the price you were looking to spend for a non-runner/questions car.
It is a 1986, 944. I Love the car, it is reliable, and drives great. Due to my age and health, I have a hard time getting in and out of it. Windows work and the radio is a Pioneer with FM and CD and works.
[edit since fb link wouldn't work]
Last edited by vwbrd; 08-07-2022 at 12:57 AM.
#8
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
There are a number of desirable 944 options that can raise the valuation like sport seats (see recent thread), Fuchs wheels, a non-sunroof car, original radio, and seller upgrades like Euro bumpers (look cleaner than the US versions) and manual steering rack (over the leak-prone PS). The seller may not even know about this desirability. See if the seller can get you the options codes from the rear hatch area (https://944online.com/944_option_codes) and post them in the forum. If there are enough of these options and upgrades, they can make up for a non-running engine IMO.
Last edited by austin944; 08-08-2022 at 01:09 PM.
#9
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
okay found another one that does seem to prove the point above. 1984 5spd Burgundy (was that a factory option?). $6500 with 145,000 miles. new tires. Exterior looks great, pretty sure it's got fuchs wheels. listing says runs and drives great. interior is in great shape, only thing i can see wrong is the typical dash crack.
Only problem is it's too good! I was wanting a project to work on with my son. Hmmm
Only problem is it's too good! I was wanting a project to work on with my son. Hmmm
#10
Drifting
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
okay found another one that does seem to prove the point above. 1984 5spd Burgundy (was that a factory option?). $6500 with 145,000 miles. new tires. Exterior looks great, pretty sure it's got fuchs wheels. listing says runs and drives great. interior is in great shape, only thing i can see wrong is the typical dash crack.
Only problem is it's too good! I was wanting a project to work on with my son. Hmmm
Only problem is it's too good! I was wanting a project to work on with my son. Hmmm
#11
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thoughts on this one? Yes, that's a picture of a photo.
"1984 Porsche 944 -59,000 miles, 2.5 litre aluminum 4 cylinder engine-5 speed -sable brown exterior with tan cloth interior. New paint job in 2010. New clutch & pressure plate & throwout bearing.blankplunt stereo, factory sunroof, Been in storage since 2016 - will need a new battery & Gas to run - since I drained the tank at storage time."
I'm trying to get more info, but assuming it was running before he stored it, I know I'd need timing belt and most vacuum lines, probably fuel lines, too. Price is probably a little high for the amount of work it would need, but depends on the interior state, too.
"1984 Porsche 944 -59,000 miles, 2.5 litre aluminum 4 cylinder engine-5 speed -sable brown exterior with tan cloth interior. New paint job in 2010. New clutch & pressure plate & throwout bearing.blankplunt stereo, factory sunroof, Been in storage since 2016 - will need a new battery & Gas to run - since I drained the tank at storage time."
I'm trying to get more info, but assuming it was running before he stored it, I know I'd need timing belt and most vacuum lines, probably fuel lines, too. Price is probably a little high for the amount of work it would need, but depends on the interior state, too.
#12
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Thoughts on this one? Yes, that's a picture of a photo.
"1984 Porsche 944 -59,000 miles, 2.5 litre aluminum 4 cylinder engine-5 speed -sable brown exterior with tan cloth interior. New paint job in 2010. New clutch & pressure plate & throwout bearing.blankplunt stereo, factory sunroof, Been in storage since 2016 - will need a new battery & Gas to run - since I drained the tank at storage time."
I'm trying to get more info, but assuming it was running before he stored it, I know I'd need timing belt and most vacuum lines, probably fuel lines, too. Price is probably a little high for the amount of work it would need, but depends on the interior state, too.
"1984 Porsche 944 -59,000 miles, 2.5 litre aluminum 4 cylinder engine-5 speed -sable brown exterior with tan cloth interior. New paint job in 2010. New clutch & pressure plate & throwout bearing.blankplunt stereo, factory sunroof, Been in storage since 2016 - will need a new battery & Gas to run - since I drained the tank at storage time."
I'm trying to get more info, but assuming it was running before he stored it, I know I'd need timing belt and most vacuum lines, probably fuel lines, too. Price is probably a little high for the amount of work it would need, but depends on the interior state, too.
#14
Racer
![Default](https://rennlist.com/forums/images/icons/icon1.gif)
Probably true about the miles being much higher. The car has Fuchs and sport seats, so there’s value there beyond the car. I would want to confirm that the motor turns freely and I would want to look over that respray very carefully. It’s amazing how people try to sell cars. At least wash it and roll it out into daylight!
The following users liked this post:
Tiger03447 (08-18-2022)
#15
Burning Brakes