Went to the dyno today, but....
#16
Originally Posted by BrianKeithSmith
Geoffrey - I can agree with that as well. I would expect a small fluctuation, due to the factors you mentioned, but not a full 1.0-1.5 points on the scale...
Therefore, I would expect 2nd gear results to be pretty much in line with 3rd gear results (which is pretty much what I see on the track).
Brian
Therefore, I would expect 2nd gear results to be pretty much in line with 3rd gear results (which is pretty much what I see on the track).
Brian
It is system dependant , it all boils down to how much filtering your Lambda system is setup for . This filtering value along with exhaust speed and temp will alter the A/F , you will find the A/F will be more stable after you have brought everything up to temperature, On the Dyno jet what you should have done was an all gear pass, this would have brought up your egt's and you would see a more accurate A/F value thru 3/4/5 gears.
#17
Originally Posted by BrianKeithSmith
I'm not trying to cause a "war" between ECU manufacturers and dyno tuning techniques... I just simply wanted to try to understand/figure out why the AFRs are so different on the dyno vs the street.
I guess I need to find a stretch of open road where I can hit 3rd gear WOT/Full Boost, log it, review it, and post the results.... (that was sort of the point of going to the dyno though)
320Kpa is approx 20-22psi right?
Brian
I guess I need to find a stretch of open road where I can hit 3rd gear WOT/Full Boost, log it, review it, and post the results.... (that was sort of the point of going to the dyno though)
320Kpa is approx 20-22psi right?
Brian
Neither am I just some techno banter , while i help another racer . Just figure i had to explain my position..... as i use/have used almost everytype of
dyno made, while the dynojet has it's weakness, it has positives like all dynos' it requres a different procedure to go , but it will go, of all the dynos i have used over the years i have only encountered 2 that was totally useless , but unless you happen to be in Italy , this should not be a worry ...
Forget the streets go back to the Dyno jet and do an all gear pull to 4th , then stop check your A/F adjust accordingly , then make an all gear pull to 5th when you have the A/F where you need them . remember to watch temps , keep the I/C temps stable , so the runs are comparable..
#20
Wayne, I'm not trying to start a war here, I have and do use steady state tuning for all engines I tune and I have done several non Porsche engines that make over 320kPa (32psi of boost). I dial the dyno to 5000rpm and set the boost controller to run 32psi of boost and will steady state the engine to find the optimum ignition angle. Want me to call you the next time I do it?
#21
Originally Posted by Geoffrey
Wayne, I'm not trying to start a war here, I have and do use steady state tuning for all engines I tune and I have done several non Porsche engines that make over 320kPa (32psi of boost). I dial the dyno to 5000rpm and set the boost controller to run 32psi of boost and will steady state the engine to find the optimum ignition angle. Want me to call you the next time I do it?
NO war here geoffrey , just giving my opinion for mutual exchange
Would love to see the steady state tune at 5250, 32 psi on a Dyno dynamics. we should get together .. you can use mine if you want.
Last edited by A.Wayne; 05-08-2007 at 11:38 AM.
#23
Originally Posted by Geoffrey
With the exception of in-cylinder pressure analysis equipment, I honestly don't know how to find the optimum ignition angle any other way.
#24
Well, I just scheduled some more dyno time on Friday with a shop that has a DynaPack. 1 hr away though...
We'll see what they show... This is the same dyno I tuned it on a while back...
Brian
We'll see what they show... This is the same dyno I tuned it on a while back...
Brian
#25
Originally Posted by BrianKeithSmith
Well, I just scheduled some more dyno time on Friday with a shop that has a DynaPack. 1 hr away though...
We'll see what they show... This is the same dyno I tuned it on a while back...
Brian
We'll see what they show... This is the same dyno I tuned it on a while back...
Brian
#26
Brian,
This might sound stupid but I put my car on a dynojet once and the operator put a fan blowing from the back (into the exhaust pipes). My AFRs were in the 14-16s during the run, which is obviously incorrect as I run rather rich. I did not have any other explanation than it was the fans that were fooling the numbers as a result of the amount of air thrown at the sensors.
As I said, it sounds impossible maybe , but true.
This might sound stupid but I put my car on a dynojet once and the operator put a fan blowing from the back (into the exhaust pipes). My AFRs were in the 14-16s during the run, which is obviously incorrect as I run rather rich. I did not have any other explanation than it was the fans that were fooling the numbers as a result of the amount of air thrown at the sensors.
As I said, it sounds impossible maybe , but true.
#27
I could definitely see where that could throw off the AFR reading... Doesn't apply to my particular situation, but interesting to consider for future dyno runs for sure!
thanks Jean!
Brian
thanks Jean!
Brian
#28
Well, went back to the dyno today. Spent about 2.5 hrs making adjustments.
Ended up with 447.8RWHP at .87 bar... (somewhere between .85 and .90, I'll have to look at datalogs). Most of the changes centered around timing, which obviously forced changes to fuel as well.
ALSO, had the wonderful pleasure of meeting Olli today. Olli, I hope next time, we'll see one another at a venue where we can actually talk, and things aren't so hectic...
Anyway, 2 weeks from now I'll be at the track!
Brian
This was my 3rd time on a DynaPack, and every time I leave, I wish I had the money to buy one....
Ended up with 447.8RWHP at .87 bar... (somewhere between .85 and .90, I'll have to look at datalogs). Most of the changes centered around timing, which obviously forced changes to fuel as well.
ALSO, had the wonderful pleasure of meeting Olli today. Olli, I hope next time, we'll see one another at a venue where we can actually talk, and things aren't so hectic...
Anyway, 2 weeks from now I'll be at the track!
Brian
This was my 3rd time on a DynaPack, and every time I leave, I wish I had the money to buy one....