OT: Cayman GT4
#1921
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Mid-Atlantic (on land, not in the middle of the ocean)
Posts: 12,443
Received 3,798 Likes
on
2,196 Posts
Just to clarify, I wasn't referring to just the previous GT cars nor was I singling out the GT4 re: the mechanical LSD. It's just a fact that they've been a known weak point in Porsches for many years. I'm hoping the electronic LSD in the GT3 will fare better in the long run.
#1922
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Just to clarify, I wasn't referring to just the previous GT cars nor was I singling out the GT4 re: the mechanical LSD. It's just a fact that they've been a known weak point in Porsches for many years. I'm hoping the electronic LSD in the GT3 will fare better in the long run.
#1923
Race Director
In the GT3, the e-diff and shocks are two clever items which are essential to the performance of the car, and could be expensive to replace when worn. I hope there proves to be some good way of detecting the progression of their wear, other than realizing one day that the car isn't performing like it used to, but not knowing why.
#1924
Rennlist Member
#1925
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#1926
Three Wheelin'
#1927
Just to clarify, I wasn't referring to just the previous GT cars nor was I singling out the GT4 re: the mechanical LSD. It's just a fact that they've been a known weak point in Porsches for many years. I'm hoping the electronic LSD in the GT3 will fare better in the long run.
In the GT3, the e-diff and shocks are two clever items which are essential to the performance of the car, and could be expensive to replace when worn. I hope there proves to be some good way of detecting the progression of their wear, other than realizing one day that the car isn't performing like it used to, but not knowing why.
Finally here again is Matt Monson's response in a recent Rennlist thread that is relevant to this conversation:
Hi Guys,
Eduardo pinged me and asked me to pop in and shed some light on this. Let's start with a picture since everyone likes pictures. And then I will explain.
This is a picture of the LSD found in the 991 GT3. It is called PTV+. PTV is used in the other vehicles. PTV+ is only used in the 991 GT3, the Turbo and the Carrera S. What you are looking at is how the LSD is actuated to provide variable locking rates in real time. That double row ring with bearings is to distribute the load when force is applied from the outside. The pin he's putting back in the LSD body is what the ring presses down on to apply more force to the clutches, and thus more locking factor.
There is an oil pressure feed that clamps the rings. When the car detects wheelslip the ring is pressurized. It is truly a zero preload LSD with 0% lock in steady state.
Porsche first used this approach back on the 959 and 964 C4 gearboxes. Back then there were slave cylinders applying the force though. This is the next wave in high tech LSDs. At this point we see zero reason to attempt to do better.
The only other thing I would add is that PTV is also a mechanical LSD in conjunction with electronic babysitters. Our LSD will replace that one with a more aggressive unit for owners of 991 Carreras.
Eduardo pinged me and asked me to pop in and shed some light on this. Let's start with a picture since everyone likes pictures. And then I will explain.
This is a picture of the LSD found in the 991 GT3. It is called PTV+. PTV is used in the other vehicles. PTV+ is only used in the 991 GT3, the Turbo and the Carrera S. What you are looking at is how the LSD is actuated to provide variable locking rates in real time. That double row ring with bearings is to distribute the load when force is applied from the outside. The pin he's putting back in the LSD body is what the ring presses down on to apply more force to the clutches, and thus more locking factor.
There is an oil pressure feed that clamps the rings. When the car detects wheelslip the ring is pressurized. It is truly a zero preload LSD with 0% lock in steady state.
Porsche first used this approach back on the 959 and 964 C4 gearboxes. Back then there were slave cylinders applying the force though. This is the next wave in high tech LSDs. At this point we see zero reason to attempt to do better.
The only other thing I would add is that PTV is also a mechanical LSD in conjunction with electronic babysitters. Our LSD will replace that one with a more aggressive unit for owners of 991 Carreras.
Saludos,
Eduardo
Carmel
#1928
Race Director
#1930
Rennlist Member
Don't mean to derail, but how do I know that my LSD is shot and it needs a rebuild? I need to check the PO records but I think my (996 gt3) LSD is still the original one from new. Can't imagine this car being any more fun at the track than it already is (with a presumably shot LSD).
#1931
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Don't mean to derail, but how do I know that my LSD is shot and it needs a rebuild? I need to check the PO records but I think my (996 gt3) LSD is still the original one from new. Can't imagine this car being any more fun at the track than it already is (with a presumably shot LSD).
#1932
Rennlist Member
Good to know, John. Thx!
#1934
Nordschleife Master
Now on to PTV. As described in the section Eduardo linked, PTV is a mechanical LSD AND braking. It's really just marketing with some slight changes to the electronics in the ABS ECU. It's pretty much the same as the ABD and traction control that has been in the cars for a number of years now, with a new name. Not all iterations in the past had a mechanical LSD. Now they do.
For those interested in seeing the Cayman LSD up close, you can review this thread:
http://www.planet-9.com/987-cayman-b...dissected.html
Just be aware that any comments about making clutches or ramps for it are completely obsolete. We won't be doing that ever. Not cost effective.