BC luxury tax surcharge
#32
Never understood how they keep charging tax on a 2nd hand car - when the tax was paid on it when it was bought new...... it's the gift that just keep giving - to the government anyway....
#34
Rennlist Member
Some reasons that come to mind—it's convenient to tax cars, since you have to register them. (Couldn't tax, say, watches this way—people would just buy them in Alberta or elsewhere.) Also cars are expensive, so it brings in enough revenue to be worth the effort. These apply to other vehicles like boats too, as well as real estate. Finally, a very small percentage of the population are buying $100k+ cars, so you **** off relatively few voters. (And the ones wealthy enough to hurt you in other ways aren't bothered by a paying a few thousand more for their cars.)
#35
#36
Burning Brakes
Well as a resident of BC I now have a mildly socialist provincial government (well until the next budget when the "real" NDP will rear its ugly head) and a far left socialist Federal government.
I have yet to get a reasonable (to me anyways) answer as to why any citizen should have pay a marginal tax of over 50% as income taxes.
In other words why should the government get to keep more than I do on my work?
When combined with property taxes and consumption taxes (PST and GST) anyone in the highest marginal bracket is taxed at over 60% of their income.
How is that even healthy for an economy?
I know sorry this is completely off topic and political so no response to this commentary please.
I have yet to get a reasonable (to me anyways) answer as to why any citizen should have pay a marginal tax of over 50% as income taxes.
In other words why should the government get to keep more than I do on my work?
When combined with property taxes and consumption taxes (PST and GST) anyone in the highest marginal bracket is taxed at over 60% of their income.
How is that even healthy for an economy?
I know sorry this is completely off topic and political so no response to this commentary please.
#38
Well as a resident of BC I now have a mildly socialist provincial government (well until the next budget when the "real" NDP will rear its ugly head) and a far left socialist Federal government.
I have yet to get a reasonable (to me anyways) answer as to why any citizen should have pay a marginal tax of over 50% as income taxes.
In other words why should the government get to keep more than I do on my work?
When combined with property taxes and consumption taxes (PST and GST) anyone in the highest marginal bracket is taxed at over 60% of their income.
How is that even healthy for an economy?
I know sorry this is completely off topic and political so no response to this commentary please.
I have yet to get a reasonable (to me anyways) answer as to why any citizen should have pay a marginal tax of over 50% as income taxes.
In other words why should the government get to keep more than I do on my work?
When combined with property taxes and consumption taxes (PST and GST) anyone in the highest marginal bracket is taxed at over 60% of their income.
How is that even healthy for an economy?
I know sorry this is completely off topic and political so no response to this commentary please.
It's healthy for liberal vote counts.
#40
#41
#42
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2013
Location: West Vancouver and San Francisco
Posts: 4,178
Received 1,139 Likes
on
560 Posts
As long as it's not California. There taxes are the same as in BC (and higher on capital gains) and you get nothing for that, plus everyone openly hates anyone even marginally more successful. Vandalized cars or any other "luxuries" are a painfully common thing. There is no perfect place - if a place becomes too nice, someone in power tries to benefit from that, turning it to crap.
#43
Burning Brakes
#44
Rennlist Member
Wow! I had no idea some Canadian provinces were on the march to that level of taxes! I'd be poor if retired in Vancouver.
Just for comparison, here in my Suburban Orlando Florida county, sales tax on any auto is 6.25%. 93 octane premium gasoline is $2.90/gallon (about $.75/L), there is no state income tax, and real estate taxes are low (typically around 1% of actual home value/year). Home prices are still reasonable, typically $160 to $200/sq ft for new homes and less for late model used homes, and the tech sector here is growing with lots of job openings in engineering and IT. Auto insurance? My 2015 991.1 C2S is insured to the max $500k with $500 deductibles and $100k uninsured motorist, and costs about $950/year. Those are some of the reasons we retired here.
Just for comparison, here in my Suburban Orlando Florida county, sales tax on any auto is 6.25%. 93 octane premium gasoline is $2.90/gallon (about $.75/L), there is no state income tax, and real estate taxes are low (typically around 1% of actual home value/year). Home prices are still reasonable, typically $160 to $200/sq ft for new homes and less for late model used homes, and the tech sector here is growing with lots of job openings in engineering and IT. Auto insurance? My 2015 991.1 C2S is insured to the max $500k with $500 deductibles and $100k uninsured motorist, and costs about $950/year. Those are some of the reasons we retired here.
Last edited by PCA1983; 02-27-2018 at 10:21 PM.
#45
Drifting
Wow! I had no idea some Canadian provinces were on the march to that level of taxes! I'd be poor if retired in Vancouver.
Just for comparison, here in my Suburban Orlando Florida county, sales tax on any auto is 6.25%. 93 octane premium gasoline is $2.90/gallon (about $.75/L), there is no state income tax, and real estate taxes are low (typically around 1% of time value/year). Home prices are still reasonable, typically $160 to $200/sq ft for new homes and less for late model used homes, and the tech sector here is growing with lots of job openings in engineering and IT. Auto insurance? My 2015 991.1 C2S is insured to the max $500k with $500 deductibles and $100k uninsured motorist, and costs about $950/year. Those are some of the reasons we retired here.
Just for comparison, here in my Suburban Orlando Florida county, sales tax on any auto is 6.25%. 93 octane premium gasoline is $2.90/gallon (about $.75/L), there is no state income tax, and real estate taxes are low (typically around 1% of time value/year). Home prices are still reasonable, typically $160 to $200/sq ft for new homes and less for late model used homes, and the tech sector here is growing with lots of job openings in engineering and IT. Auto insurance? My 2015 991.1 C2S is insured to the max $500k with $500 deductibles and $100k uninsured motorist, and costs about $950/year. Those are some of the reasons we retired here.