Trouble with 3-2 shift on threshold braking
#31
-Mike
#32
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,227
Likes: 3,378
From: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
In my PCA side-seat instructor sessions and my Skip Barber racing school (ten years ago granted) I was taught to downshift while threshold braking. I'm not new to the track (no expert either) and I've not heard that instruction to wait to downshift until easing off the brake.
__________________
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
-Peter Krause
www.peterkrause.net
www.gofasternow.com
"Combining the Art and Science of Driving Fast!"
Specializing in Professional, Private Driver Performance Evaluation and Optimization
Consultation Available Remotely and at VIRginia International Raceway
#33
Added a couple vids to the watch list.. thanks for that.
I'll challenge you on that data analysis though. I can still be at max brake or threshold braking and be decreasing brake pressure. In fact, you physically have to decrease brake pressure as velocity decreases in order to avoid lockup (or ABS engagement). If it wasn't clear, that's exactly what I'm doing and still having issues going from 3-2.
I'll challenge you on that data analysis though. I can still be at max brake or threshold braking and be decreasing brake pressure. In fact, you physically have to decrease brake pressure as velocity decreases in order to avoid lockup (or ABS engagement). If it wasn't clear, that's exactly what I'm doing and still having issues going from 3-2.
#34
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,227
Likes: 3,378
From: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
Hell, I go into first gear at max brake pressure. Since I trail brake, I don't come off max brake pressure until just before I start to turn in while trail braking. The trail braking/turn-in traction balancing act is far more diabolical than threshold braking, at least for me. So I want all my shifting done before I turn in which means I need to get it done while threshold braking in a straight line.
#35
Added a couple vids to the watch list.. thanks for that.
I'll challenge you on that data analysis though. I can still be at max brake or threshold braking and be decreasing brake pressure. In fact, you physically have to decrease brake pressure as velocity decreases in order to avoid lockup (or ABS engagement). If it wasn't clear, that's exactly what I'm doing and still having issues going from 3-2.
I'll challenge you on that data analysis though. I can still be at max brake or threshold braking and be decreasing brake pressure. In fact, you physically have to decrease brake pressure as velocity decreases in order to avoid lockup (or ABS engagement). If it wasn't clear, that's exactly what I'm doing and still having issues going from 3-2.
Point 2: we seem to have terminology confusion here...when I asked if you were at max pressure, that means exactly that: your maximum braking for that corner. If you are already fading out of brakes by the time you are trying to go to 2nd gear, you are NOT at max braking...
#36
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,227
Likes: 3,378
From: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
#37
Point 1: it works on the street but not the track...so something in your use of it at the track is at least magnifying the issue
Point 2: we seem to have terminology confusion here...when I asked if you were at max pressure, that means exactly that: your maximum braking for that corner. If you are already fading out of brakes by the time you are trying to go to 2nd gear, you are NOT at max braking...
Point 2: we seem to have terminology confusion here...when I asked if you were at max pressure, that means exactly that: your maximum braking for that corner. If you are already fading out of brakes by the time you are trying to go to 2nd gear, you are NOT at max braking...
#38
As I said, terminology confusion. Back on page 1 I asked if you were at maximum braking and what you meant by threshold braking. Your answer prompted my comments that followed. But you didn't mean maximum and the two terms are not synonyms.
Anyway...moving on... I am still surprised it works fine on the street but totally balks on track.
Anyway...moving on... I am still surprised it works fine on the street but totally balks on track.
#39
Point 2: we seem to have terminology confusion here...when I asked if you were at max pressure, that means exactly that: your maximum braking for that corner. If you are already fading out of brakes by the time you are trying to go to 2nd gear, you are NOT at max braking...
Now you are just trying to sneak your way out of your mistake.
When people are threshold braking it means they are using the max brake pressure allowed for the situation...even as it changes and the actual required pressure on the pedal changes. That is "max braking".
You wrote:
Why are you downshifting while "threshhold braking"?
So no, you were not talking about "maximum pressure". Threshold braking is not a specific "pressure" on the pedal.
#40
I mean threshold braking in it's literal sense. The max vehicle deceleration rate as a function of brake pedal force and vehicle velocity at a given point in time. I wasn't confused.
Edit: Right what winders said.
Edit: Right what winders said.
#41
Rennlist
Basic Site Sponsor
Basic Site Sponsor
Joined: Jun 2008
Posts: 19,227
Likes: 3,378
From: Durham, NC and Virginia International Raceway
#42
OMG. Now you are just trying to sneak your way out of your mistake. When people are threshold braking it means they are using the max brake pressure allowed for the situation...even as it changes and the actual pressure on the pedal changes. That is "max braking". You wrote: Why are you downshifting while "threshhold braking"? So no, you were not talking about "maximum pressure". Threshold braking is not a specific "pressure" on the pedal.
Sorry Scott but when I look at data with clients and we look at max braking in a particular brake zone, it means just that: max brake pressure . For example 700 psi. That is why I asked the OP the specific question I did and also asked how he was defining threshold.
To the OP, thanks, now I understand what you meant.
#43
This would be easier if it were very obvious (maybe this is obvious to some). But again, I'm no expert. So, I'll take it to the guys who are. Either way, I would never have considered the synchros before starting this thread so thanks to all for chiming in. I'll do some test drives and edit a YT video to post here this weekend (if my wife doesn't pop.. due date tomorrow). Stay tuned.
#45
Pretty serious and interesting side discussion here.
I have a 996 and had trouble w/ the 3-2 shift where 2nd wouldn't be ready on clutch out
as if it were in neutral. Retry would be fine. Annoying, but rare enough, not like the consistency
you describe. I switched to the 997 GT3 shifter (a bit shorter) and haven't had problems
at all. There is an alignment tool you use to center the stick so you can adjust the cables.
But I tilted the stick more towards me, and then set the cables.
I still have a 2-3 shift annoyance and have put in Turbo motor mounts and the occasional
problem occurs when powering out of a turn. Synchros take a beating on the 2nd try. Now
I suspect THAT is technique by being in too big a hurry.
Just a longshot...
I have a 996 and had trouble w/ the 3-2 shift where 2nd wouldn't be ready on clutch out
as if it were in neutral. Retry would be fine. Annoying, but rare enough, not like the consistency
you describe. I switched to the 997 GT3 shifter (a bit shorter) and haven't had problems
at all. There is an alignment tool you use to center the stick so you can adjust the cables.
But I tilted the stick more towards me, and then set the cables.
I still have a 2-3 shift annoyance and have put in Turbo motor mounts and the occasional
problem occurs when powering out of a turn. Synchros take a beating on the 2nd try. Now
I suspect THAT is technique by being in too big a hurry.
Just a longshot...