Teaching Good Habits-is it limiting?
#16
Originally Posted by 2BWise
How is this TD? Its just that after reading this it seesm to be a contradiction. How can you have a smooth car with abrupt inputs (for a smooth track, bumps, curbs not considered)? The inputs make the car move, if you jerk the wheel, the car jerks in response, and if you turn the wheel slowly the car smoothly transfers weight. Now I won't argue that there aren't instants and the necessity to make quick, possibly abrupt inputs, but that won't make the car smooth. The goal should always be smooth inputs. Abrupt input: EX: jumping on the brakes, 0-100% brakes almost instantly; car goes from full traction to full lock up because weight transfer occurs slower than the movement to 100% braking. EX: Whipping the wheel to the left to make a left-hand turn; car goes from grip to no grip because there is not enough time to transfer the weight and create grip. If your inputs are occurring faster than the car can physically respond than it isn't smooth and its isnt quick. But thats also why smooth inputs in a stock 944 and those in a formula ford look completely different. The response time of the formula ford allows the input to be quicker, but it will not happen faster than the car can transfer the weight and create the corresponding grip.
Newbies can, and do, smooth input themselves right off the track sometimes.
#17
Race Director
Originally Posted by TD in DC
George, I am pretty sure we are talking about different things. All I am saying is that students need to be taught that the goal is to keep the CAR smooth. "Most" of the time, smooth inputs are the best way to keep the car smooth. But that is not always true, and students need to do what is necessary to keep their car settled and on the track.
Students just need to have their priorities straight. Smooth car with abrupt input is far superior to unsettled car with smooth inputs.
Students just need to have their priorities straight. Smooth car with abrupt input is far superior to unsettled car with smooth inputs.
#18
Race Director
Originally Posted by doc2s
i agree with what you said except that smooth inputs does not have to be slow.
#19
Mr. Excitement
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Along with the good stuff already posted (that is about the original topic ) much of what I work on with a Green student is UN-learning the bad habits of street driving. Things like looking at the bumper of the car in front, poor hand placement, and creeping over before turn in and the like.
Reinforcing the basics is or should be a requirement for early students and not so new drivers alike. + and - before multiplication and division. A solid grasp of and foundation built on the simple basics will give the student the freedom and mental room to advance. He can work on fine tuning his line and car control inside the envelope of a complete information frame work. I would think that this would help the student make sense of advanced concepts and lowers the frustration factor.
Reinforcing the basics is or should be a requirement for early students and not so new drivers alike. + and - before multiplication and division. A solid grasp of and foundation built on the simple basics will give the student the freedom and mental room to advance. He can work on fine tuning his line and car control inside the envelope of a complete information frame work. I would think that this would help the student make sense of advanced concepts and lowers the frustration factor.
#20
Three Wheelin'
How about getting comfortable with being in the car, and I don't mean not sitting on your cellphone, although your cell shouldn't be with you in the car anyways. But more importantly, being comfortable with being on track, going relatively fast (even if just in a straight line), being comfortable with others on track, and being comfortable with your personal driving limits. I know that those first few times on track are nerve-wracking and can make a person drive worse. If you can get a person relaxed it makes learning that much easier.
#21
Originally Posted by 2BWise
How about getting comfortable with being in the car, and I don't mean not sitting on your cellphone, although your cell shouldn't be with you in the car anyways. But more importantly, being comfortable with being on track, going relatively fast (even if just in a straight line), being comfortable with others on track, and being comfortable with your personal driving limits. I know that those first few times on track are nerve-wracking and can make a person drive worse. If you can get a person relaxed it makes learning that much easier.
#23
Burning Brakes
Here is my not so smooth input to the thread as a blue student
BOTS... what ever the heck it is that the national seems to be hot on teaching green students; Break, yada yada yada, Throttle, Steer. A load of crap if you ask me. I had an instructor trying to teach me to do that to be smooth; it was terrible, my whole timing and rythm went out of the window and I wasted my whole weekend trying to please this instructor... yeah I got a 5 for my 'learning ability", whoopdie doo!
Teaching good habits are essential, no doubt. In the green and blue groups, that is all we really got, the precious time with instructors... once we go white, it is mostly up to the student to find new ways to attack the track while not forgetting what we learned previously. If a student gets to white without a good foundation, it will only get worse later on IMO.
That does not mean teach 'em BOTS or just the DE line and to keep it at 8/10th all the time. You don't want a blue student go into white without having explored the non-convential lines or driving at 9-10/10th or increasing the speed of his/her inputs to have the car in control without totally rocking the boat. The foundation has to mean the student has to be able to alter his/her line regularly while keeping the speed up and experimenting with different input/output scenarios. A blue student should have at least gone through 2 or 3 sessions without any brakes, or driving the entire course completely off-line, or driven in the rain nearly as competently as in the dry by fully understanding the car and its behaviour to inputs.
Please, don't let us out of the blue group without all that above experienced, otherwise we'll put ourselves and others at risk.
BOTS... what ever the heck it is that the national seems to be hot on teaching green students; Break, yada yada yada, Throttle, Steer. A load of crap if you ask me. I had an instructor trying to teach me to do that to be smooth; it was terrible, my whole timing and rythm went out of the window and I wasted my whole weekend trying to please this instructor... yeah I got a 5 for my 'learning ability", whoopdie doo!
Teaching good habits are essential, no doubt. In the green and blue groups, that is all we really got, the precious time with instructors... once we go white, it is mostly up to the student to find new ways to attack the track while not forgetting what we learned previously. If a student gets to white without a good foundation, it will only get worse later on IMO.
That does not mean teach 'em BOTS or just the DE line and to keep it at 8/10th all the time. You don't want a blue student go into white without having explored the non-convential lines or driving at 9-10/10th or increasing the speed of his/her inputs to have the car in control without totally rocking the boat. The foundation has to mean the student has to be able to alter his/her line regularly while keeping the speed up and experimenting with different input/output scenarios. A blue student should have at least gone through 2 or 3 sessions without any brakes, or driving the entire course completely off-line, or driven in the rain nearly as competently as in the dry by fully understanding the car and its behaviour to inputs.
Please, don't let us out of the blue group without all that above experienced, otherwise we'll put ourselves and others at risk.
#24
Lifetime Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by 2BWise
How is this TD? Its just that after reading this it seesm to be a contradiction. How can you have a smooth car with abrupt inputs (for a smooth track, bumps, curbs not considered)? The inputs make the car move, if you jerk the wheel, the car jerks in response, and if you turn the wheel slowly the car smoothly transfers weight. Now I won't argue that there aren't instants and the necessity to make quick, possibly abrupt inputs, but that won't make the car smooth. The goal should always be smooth inputs. Abrupt input: EX: jumping on the brakes, 0-100% brakes almost instantly; car goes from full traction to full lock up because weight transfer occurs slower than the movement to 100% braking. EX: Whipping the wheel to the left to make a left-hand turn; car goes from grip to no grip because there is not enough time to transfer the weight and create grip. If your inputs are occurring faster than the car can physically respond than it isn't smooth and its isnt quick. But thats also why smooth inputs in a stock 944 and those in a formula ford look completely different. The response time of the formula ford allows the input to be quicker, but it will not happen faster than the car can transfer the weight and create the corresponding grip.
A good example is T11 at Mid Ohio, at the limit. You brake under some cornering load and turn in smoothly. But the track is going to make the car slide so you make fast corrections (often jerky looking) because there is less grip just before the apex. At the apex the grip gets better (corner banking and increasing radius) then you are good to go. When you hit the crest of the hill, the car may twitch a bit if you have a touch of steering left in the car. You better make very fast (and jerky looking) corrections unless you want to chat with Mr. Wall. So this corner has two sections where the car will bobble. I can pretty much guarantee that if you take this corner with smooth steering all the way through, then you are not at the limit.
#25
Originally Posted by SundayDriver
I think you misunderstand what TD is saying. You use smooth inputs to make the car do what you want. You do whatever input is needed to bring the car back to what you want. If you are at the limit, the car is going to slip and bobble. The CAR is no longer smooth and you will end up making what appears to be jerky inputs to make the car smooth out.
A good example is T11 at Mid Ohio, at the limit. You brake under some cornering load and turn in smoothly. But the track is going to make the car slide so you make fast corrections (often jerky looking) because there is less grip just before the apex. At the apex the grip gets better (corner banking and increasing radius) then you are good to go. When you hit the crest of the hill, the car may twitch a bit if you have a touch of steering left in the car. You better make very fast (and jerky looking) corrections unless you want to chat with Mr. Wall. So this corner has two sections where the car will bobble. I can pretty much guarantee that if you take this corner with smooth steering all the way through, then you are not at the limit.
A good example is T11 at Mid Ohio, at the limit. You brake under some cornering load and turn in smoothly. But the track is going to make the car slide so you make fast corrections (often jerky looking) because there is less grip just before the apex. At the apex the grip gets better (corner banking and increasing radius) then you are good to go. When you hit the crest of the hill, the car may twitch a bit if you have a touch of steering left in the car. You better make very fast (and jerky looking) corrections unless you want to chat with Mr. Wall. So this corner has two sections where the car will bobble. I can pretty much guarantee that if you take this corner with smooth steering all the way through, then you are not at the limit.
#26
Instructor
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: Morris County, NJ
Posts: 131
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Good Habits Increase Bandwidth
I'm in green (soon to be blue - I hope) with about 25 total track days, mostly in a 944 NA with a very good suspension and R-compounds. I totally agree that good driving is built on a strong foundation.
Habits are things people do consistently without conscious thought. The more elements of driving that can be done out of habit, the more bandwidth the driver has for specific things that can't be done without conscious thought (this corner, that pass, etc,). At the very beginning, I had to think about everything, and wasn't consistent about anything, so I had limited bandwidth for learning how to go fast. As good instructors emphasized consistency, I was able to do more and more without active thought and thus had more capacity to move beyond the basics. I even developed a couple of bad habits, one of which (a braking problem) my instructor and I just spent the whole weekend working on at Mid-Ohio.
Habits are things people do consistently without conscious thought. The more elements of driving that can be done out of habit, the more bandwidth the driver has for specific things that can't be done without conscious thought (this corner, that pass, etc,). At the very beginning, I had to think about everything, and wasn't consistent about anything, so I had limited bandwidth for learning how to go fast. As good instructors emphasized consistency, I was able to do more and more without active thought and thus had more capacity to move beyond the basics. I even developed a couple of bad habits, one of which (a braking problem) my instructor and I just spent the whole weekend working on at Mid-Ohio.
#27
Rennlist Hoonigan
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Back on topic a little.....
I agree with you Rick. My basic philosophy for people with <10 days is to simply teach them the line, basics like being smooth, vision, and the sequence for taking a corner (i.e. brake, off brake, turn in, apex, throttle, track out).
I agree with you Rick. My basic philosophy for people with <10 days is to simply teach them the line, basics like being smooth, vision, and the sequence for taking a corner (i.e. brake, off brake, turn in, apex, throttle, track out).
#28
Addict
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Oct 2005
Location: On Rennlist, apparently
Posts: 4,447
Likes: 0
Received 37 Likes
on
18 Posts
Hi Matt
Thank you for the agreement; I guess if it works its right.
I love to see how threads wander around; I guess its just like face to face communication (though with more opportunity for misunderstandings).
Off to Rennsport next week; what's your next event?
Thank you for the agreement; I guess if it works its right.
I love to see how threads wander around; I guess its just like face to face communication (though with more opportunity for misunderstandings).
Off to Rennsport next week; what's your next event?
#29
Rennlist Hoonigan
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
which cost no drachmas
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
I haven't signed up for anything yet. I've been busy working on the new house and traveling a little. I need to get a track fix soon....