Looking for suggestion of dedicated track car
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Looking for suggestion of dedicated track car
Hi:
I am new to this community but have found a lot of useful information here. My beloved E92 M3 track car quit working recently and I feel that I should invest a bit more for a factory spec race car. The car will be for HPDE track event use, no competition, currently I track the car for about 15-20 day every year and I am capable for doing all kinds of oil / brake changes and easy repairs, I also plan to keep use car for 4-6 days, maybe longer. My initial purchase budget is around $200K and my concerns are below :
1) Relatively low running cost, no need for engine and gearbox rebuild;
2) More reliable as I prefer less down time;
3) Car can run without need for expensive factory track side support;
4) Parts are available without long wait;
5) Easy to maintain and repair.
After some research, I have locked down to the following options:
1), New 718 Cayman GT4 clubsport: I have heard a lot of good things about this one, but feel it maybe a bit underpowered if not for spec car racing. It may not have enough power after 1-2 years as my skill develops.
2), Used but recently refreshed 911 GT3 Cup: Enough power, good platform but I concern the long time running reliability since it is used.
3), New McLaren 570S GT4: More advanced platform and most powerful GT4 cup car (ECU can be flashed to remove spec power restriction). Not sure if this car can run without McLaren track side support, also concern about long time running cost.
4), Buy a 911 GT3/RS with a long warranty remaining, do a simply preparation, then track it hard, sell it after warranty has expired.
Would love to hear you guys' suggestion. Thank you!
I am new to this community but have found a lot of useful information here. My beloved E92 M3 track car quit working recently and I feel that I should invest a bit more for a factory spec race car. The car will be for HPDE track event use, no competition, currently I track the car for about 15-20 day every year and I am capable for doing all kinds of oil / brake changes and easy repairs, I also plan to keep use car for 4-6 days, maybe longer. My initial purchase budget is around $200K and my concerns are below :
1) Relatively low running cost, no need for engine and gearbox rebuild;
2) More reliable as I prefer less down time;
3) Car can run without need for expensive factory track side support;
4) Parts are available without long wait;
5) Easy to maintain and repair.
After some research, I have locked down to the following options:
1), New 718 Cayman GT4 clubsport: I have heard a lot of good things about this one, but feel it maybe a bit underpowered if not for spec car racing. It may not have enough power after 1-2 years as my skill develops.
2), Used but recently refreshed 911 GT3 Cup: Enough power, good platform but I concern the long time running reliability since it is used.
3), New McLaren 570S GT4: More advanced platform and most powerful GT4 cup car (ECU can be flashed to remove spec power restriction). Not sure if this car can run without McLaren track side support, also concern about long time running cost.
4), Buy a 911 GT3/RS with a long warranty remaining, do a simply preparation, then track it hard, sell it after warranty has expired.
Would love to hear you guys' suggestion. Thank you!
#2
Rennlist Member
I have not heard anyone say that they have ever had enough power in a track car. Ever.
Remember, you want three things in a track car. Fast, Reliable, and Cheap. You can only have 2.
The Cayman Clubsport, both platforms, meet many of your screens. They don't require the same refresh rate on components, and they are not as fussy as other factory race cars.
The need for trackside support is relative, depending on your skill set and your desires. You do not need a shop to help you with a Cup Car if you have the right background, tools, and spend the effort. It is much easier to run with a shop to support you and you only have to concentrate on two things. Driving the car and paying the bills.
I loved my 996 Cup and now my 997.2. Isringhausen has a great deal on a 997.1 cup right now for a lower price of entry. (no relationship - just know that they have this and are good people)
https://www.isringhausenporsche.com/...f9284fcda6.htm
The per hour running cost of any Cup prior to the 991.2 is significant. The Cayman is way less. The Street GT3 is lower, but you don't have the safety gear integrated.
I would go with a Porsche - reliability is a known quantity. Pick your favorite!
Remember, you want three things in a track car. Fast, Reliable, and Cheap. You can only have 2.
The Cayman Clubsport, both platforms, meet many of your screens. They don't require the same refresh rate on components, and they are not as fussy as other factory race cars.
The need for trackside support is relative, depending on your skill set and your desires. You do not need a shop to help you with a Cup Car if you have the right background, tools, and spend the effort. It is much easier to run with a shop to support you and you only have to concentrate on two things. Driving the car and paying the bills.
I loved my 996 Cup and now my 997.2. Isringhausen has a great deal on a 997.1 cup right now for a lower price of entry. (no relationship - just know that they have this and are good people)
https://www.isringhausenporsche.com/...f9284fcda6.htm
The per hour running cost of any Cup prior to the 991.2 is significant. The Cayman is way less. The Street GT3 is lower, but you don't have the safety gear integrated.
I would go with a Porsche - reliability is a known quantity. Pick your favorite!
#3
Nordschleife Master
A GT4 Clubsport is plenty fast; it’s a sub 2 minute car at Watkins Glen. Unless you are going to race in a pro-am series, buy a used one. There’s a nice 981 CS MR for sale (no affiliation) for 137k in the Clubsport section.
A similar speed car is a 996 cup. Nice ones are in the 60s. The engines and gearbox are incredibly robust and can go many many hours without needing anything. Once you get into the sequential cars, the cost rises dramatically.
The big advantage of the Clubsport is it’s easier to drive and less physically demanding than even the 6cup. Get one with AC!
A similar speed car is a 996 cup. Nice ones are in the 60s. The engines and gearbox are incredibly robust and can go many many hours without needing anything. Once you get into the sequential cars, the cost rises dramatically.
The big advantage of the Clubsport is it’s easier to drive and less physically demanding than even the 6cup. Get one with AC!
Last edited by 38D; 02-21-2021 at 01:12 PM.
The following users liked this post:
zracer196 (02-22-2021)
#4
Rennlist Member
I would agree with those comments on the Clubsport - super fun, easier to drive, and comfortable. The 996 cup is a blast - very visceral. plenty for sale if you go searching. The 996 cup is no harder to deal with than a street GT3 and way less fussy.
#6
Rennlist Member
3rd for 996 Cup but I am totally bias - pure drivers race car very rewarding and very underrated
Entry money not an issue the 991.2 there should be a bunch for sale as the 992 Cups are delivered
Entry money not an issue the 991.2 there should be a bunch for sale as the 992 Cups are delivered
#7
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Thank you for the suggestion. I used to own a 996 generation RUF back to 2000s but that was before I started my motorsport hobby. Are we saying that generation is still some of the best on the track?
Trending Topics
#9
Basic Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
Rennlist
Site Sponsor
It will give you the greatest track experience for the money. The cars are raw, exciting, and fast. They have an H pattern shifter, so much less expense when a trans rebuild is needed.
The advantage of something like a box stock (or close to it) cup is that it is the way the factory built it, not an individual builder, so there are a lot more people who know the cars.
A bonus is that they will appreciate in value over time as all Porsche factory race cars have.
Thanks
Ed
The advantage of something like a box stock (or close to it) cup is that it is the way the factory built it, not an individual builder, so there are a lot more people who know the cars.
A bonus is that they will appreciate in value over time as all Porsche factory race cars have.
Thanks
Ed
__________________
https://demonspeed.com/
Engineered Race and Track Products for your Porsche
https://www.goodaero.com/
Race Designed Aerodynamics
https://racingtirewarmers.com/
Win more races with tire warmers
Great products for racers by racers
ed@demonspeed.com
Demon Speed Motorsports is a proud sponsor of PCA and the Club Racing Program
https://demonspeed.com/
Engineered Race and Track Products for your Porsche
https://www.goodaero.com/
Race Designed Aerodynamics
https://racingtirewarmers.com/
Win more races with tire warmers
Great products for racers by racers
ed@demonspeed.com
Demon Speed Motorsports is a proud sponsor of PCA and the Club Racing Program
Last edited by Ed@Demonspeed; 02-22-2021 at 02:12 PM.
#10
Maybe not a bad option either....Brand new $120K all in. 450 HP for $25K more is a waste...You can easily tune it to street car specs for much less...Factory race car, cool interior / electronics / etc.
I know...Not a Porsche...LOL!
https://www.bmw-motorsport.com/en/to...cs-racing.html
I know...Not a Porsche...LOL!
https://www.bmw-motorsport.com/en/to...cs-racing.html
Last edited by zracer196; 02-22-2021 at 03:06 PM.
#11
Three Wheelin'
If you do DE getting a 718/981 club sport enables you to be the fastest in your run group unless a racer shows up with a Gtb1, club sport or cup car
I drove a 981 gt4 streetcar in DE on street tires and was held up by corvettes and enjoyed chasing down gt3s
Get a club sport and have fun; anything faster will be annoying in a DE with limited passing in corners. You will just drive from point by to point by
I drove a 981 gt4 streetcar in DE on street tires and was held up by corvettes and enjoyed chasing down gt3s
Get a club sport and have fun; anything faster will be annoying in a DE with limited passing in corners. You will just drive from point by to point by
#12
Rennlist Member
Join Date: May 2008
Location: Somewhere in a galaxy far, far away....
Posts: 17,108
Likes: 0
Received 259 Likes
on
173 Posts
I have the car for you.
the fastest 2019 718 GT4 Cayman in the country.
don’t waste your time looking at anything else in your price point.
For doing 20 track days a year the clubsport will perform and progress you forward. No fooling around with engine or tranny rebuilds.
Forget Cup. anything with a sequential is going to cost you service. Forget street car. For 20 days of track you will be better off with roll cage clubsport for safety and resale. Nobody wants a beat on RS especially when you are done hauling it out of a tire wall.
the fastest 2019 718 GT4 Cayman in the country.
don’t waste your time looking at anything else in your price point.
For doing 20 track days a year the clubsport will perform and progress you forward. No fooling around with engine or tranny rebuilds.
Forget Cup. anything with a sequential is going to cost you service. Forget street car. For 20 days of track you will be better off with roll cage clubsport for safety and resale. Nobody wants a beat on RS especially when you are done hauling it out of a tire wall.
The following users liked this post:
zracer196 (02-22-2021)
#13
Rennlist Member
As a life long P car guy I switched to a Ford Mustang for track work.
Ford racing crate motor is10k with 500 RWHP and 24 month factory warranty. Its a beautiful thing. Rebuilding my P car engine was painful.
Ford racing crate motor is10k with 500 RWHP and 24 month factory warranty. Its a beautiful thing. Rebuilding my P car engine was painful.
#14
Nordschleife Master
Just saw an interesting car:
https://www.teambgb.com/Articles.asp?ID=264
Is this kind of shop built have an actual lower running cost compared to clubsport?
https://www.teambgb.com/Articles.asp?ID=264
Is this kind of shop built have an actual lower running cost compared to clubsport?
Real wisdom here. There is such as thing as “too fast for DE”. A Clubsport (or 996 cup) will be fast enough that you can with most anything, but not so fast as to be annoying.
#15
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
It looks like the any CUP car with sequential (high running cost) and road car (no full cage) are really off the table now. So I will be looking between 996 CUP and 981/718 clubsport. A bit surprised that not even one mentioned McLaren but I think I know the reason. There is one 570 GT4 for sell at $190K at McLaren Houston. It is very good price for a brand new factory built McLaren race car but I am wondering if I will be in the rabbit hole if I get this one:
https://www.mclarenhouston.com/new-H...13CAT6HW007640
Last edited by wxq99; 02-23-2021 at 12:48 AM.