I like the look of the Targa better and it is a more rare car, with hopefully better resale. With the top up it is more coupe-like and secure, and it has AWD as standard, which is important as a yearly DD where I live. Read some reviews online of the Targa and decide (Jalopnik has a good one). The downside to Targas and Cabs are no winter auto car washes, hand wash only.