A dumb question about tracking . . .
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
A dumb question about tracking . . .
Second weekend of track duty with my 7.2, and I don’t know how else to describe the behavior I’m noticing other than to say that the motor doesn’t seem to slow down as quickly as the car does ? ? Is that a thing?
In 15 years of tracking other cars (GT4, 987 race car, old 911, BMWs, etc.), I’ve never really encountered what I’m trying to describe. Even on slicks with serious brake setups. It’s as though the revs don’t fall fast enough to match the physical slowing of the car. Downshifting sooner or later seems to have no affect on the dynamic. It just feels like the flywheel and revs are fighting to keep up with the braking.
Is this a thing? Would a LWFW help if it is ? It’s unsettling, because it’s interfering with my normal brake points, resulting in much earlier braking to net smoothness.
Insight greatly appreciated as always.
In 15 years of tracking other cars (GT4, 987 race car, old 911, BMWs, etc.), I’ve never really encountered what I’m trying to describe. Even on slicks with serious brake setups. It’s as though the revs don’t fall fast enough to match the physical slowing of the car. Downshifting sooner or later seems to have no affect on the dynamic. It just feels like the flywheel and revs are fighting to keep up with the braking.
Is this a thing? Would a LWFW help if it is ? It’s unsettling, because it’s interfering with my normal brake points, resulting in much earlier braking to net smoothness.
Insight greatly appreciated as always.
#2
Rennlist Member
Strange.
Want to make sure I understand. If you heel/toe and go hard on the brakes, you're saying that the revs are hanging? Have you tried braking hard with clutch in and see if the revs are hanging as you brake independently?
IIRC, this car is somewhat new to you correct? Was it possibly tuned? Not sure what else it could be but possibly mechanical issue as I never had the behavior you're describing in my 997.2 GT3. GT2...a little but more from boost overrun but that's definitely not an issue for you
Want to make sure I understand. If you heel/toe and go hard on the brakes, you're saying that the revs are hanging? Have you tried braking hard with clutch in and see if the revs are hanging as you brake independently?
IIRC, this car is somewhat new to you correct? Was it possibly tuned? Not sure what else it could be but possibly mechanical issue as I never had the behavior you're describing in my 997.2 GT3. GT2...a little but more from boost overrun but that's definitely not an issue for you
#4
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Strange.
Want to make sure I understand. If you heel/toe and go hard on the brakes, you're saying that the revs are hanging? Have you tried braking hard with clutch in and see if the revs are hanging as you brake independently?
IIRC, this car is somewhat new to you correct? Was it possibly tuned? Not sure what else it could be but possibly mechanical issue as I never had the behavior you're describing in my 997.2 GT3. GT2...a little but more from boost overrun but that's definitely not an issue for you
Want to make sure I understand. If you heel/toe and go hard on the brakes, you're saying that the revs are hanging? Have you tried braking hard with clutch in and see if the revs are hanging as you brake independently?
IIRC, this car is somewhat new to you correct? Was it possibly tuned? Not sure what else it could be but possibly mechanical issue as I never had the behavior you're describing in my 997.2 GT3. GT2...a little but more from boost overrun but that's definitely not an issue for you
I have not tried to just clutch in and brake. That’s a good idea. But I’m not over-revving on heel-toe. It’s after the blip, and fully into the in-gear / brake phase where I notice it.
#5
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Strange.
IIRC, this car is somewhat new to you correct? Was it possibly tuned? Not sure what else it could be but possibly mechanical issue as I never had the behavior you're describing in my 997.2 GT3. GT2...a little but more from boost overrun but that's definitely not an issue for you
IIRC, this car is somewhat new to you correct? Was it possibly tuned? Not sure what else it could be but possibly mechanical issue as I never had the behavior you're describing in my 997.2 GT3. GT2...a little but more from boost overrun but that's definitely not an issue for you
Got some Garmin footage today, but don’t have my laptop with me. Will upload when I can to see if what I’m describing is noticeable on camera.
#6
Rennlist Member
Yes, exactly. Like today at Barber, there are a couple 110-120 to 45 corners, and every time, as I heel-toe from 4th to 3rd (and occasionally 2nd to play with gearing), the brakes seem to overcome the revs, which lag behind.
I have not tried to just clutch in and brake. That’s a good idea. But I’m not over-revving on heel-toe. It’s after the blip, and fully into the in-gear / brake phase where I notice it.
I have not tried to just clutch in and brake. That’s a good idea. But I’m not over-revving on heel-toe. It’s after the blip, and fully into the in-gear / brake phase where I notice it.
#7
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
interesting... when I am hard on the brakes doing a 4->3. Im in 4th until most/all of my braking is done and then heel-toe to get into 3rd. Based on your previous posts you have much more experience than I so my technique could be non-optimal. But I haven't noticed this using the technique I've used. I don't think there is a track I normally drive where I need to come down from 110+ to 45. But this is all fresh in my mind as I just did two days at Area 27.
Last edited by jreifler; 06-04-2023 at 02:35 AM.
Trending Topics
#8
Rennlist Member
This video shows the 2 sequences I’m talking about. @:30 and :50 approximately in the video. That’s in my GT4, but those are the turns.
https://youtu.be/ewrKOInRbEU
https://youtu.be/ewrKOInRbEU
#9
Rennlist Member
I will say without a doubt my heal toe is easier w/LWFW, I found I kinda would end up over reaching my foot in my GT3 because it felt almost all or nothing
Actually I have a little of that habit still and my blips are a bit over zealous now
#10
Rennlist Member
Assuming that what you feel is actually happening, is there any explanation other than a slipping clutch? There is no other way an engine could hold an RPM higher than what’s normal for any given gear and wheel speed when the clutch has the engine and trans mechanically connected. It’s strange that you would only notice it on downshifts though, but they may be more abrupt than your acceleration so that could be the explanation.
#11
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
I’m having a hard time visualizing… do you have the tach by chance in the gt3 vid?
I will say without a doubt my heal toe is easier w/LWFW, I found I kinda would end up over reaching my foot in my GT3 because it felt almost all or nothing
Actually I have a little of that habit still and my blips are a bit over zealous now
I will say without a doubt my heal toe is easier w/LWFW, I found I kinda would end up over reaching my foot in my GT3 because it felt almost all or nothing
Actually I have a little of that habit still and my blips are a bit over zealous now
Assuming that what you feel is actually happening, is there any explanation other than a slipping clutch? There is no other way an engine could hold an RPM higher than what’s normal for any given gear and wheel speed when the clutch has the engine and trans mechanically connected. It’s strange that you would only notice it on downshifts though, but they may be more abrupt than your acceleration so that could be the explanation.
Uploaded a couple laps here:
Here, in the same braking zones as the prior video (and on the braking zone for the first straight), you can hear what I'm describing. A strained / slow engine speed deceleration under heavy braking that transitions into "normal" engine speed deceleration immediately after heavy braking and into trail braking. Forgive the inelegant 2d gear blip in the first lap . . .
#12
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
You're right. In that clip, I do go 4-3-2, but the fast way around that corner is to stay in 3rd. With the tall gearing in the GT4 I was always stuck between wanting to leave it in 3rd for smoothness and momentum, and dropping down to 2nd to power out. So the *right* way to take that turn in most cars is just to leave in 3rd, and I often would, but also often played with 2nd for the torque.
#13
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Assuming that what you feel is actually happening, is there any explanation other than a slipping clutch? There is no other way an engine could hold an RPM higher than what’s normal for any given gear and wheel speed when the clutch has the engine and trans mechanically connected. It’s strange that you would only notice it on downshifts though, but they may be more abrupt than your acceleration so that could be the explanation.
#14
Rennlist Member
How's your diff?
The diff has a massive impact on braking and steadiness on these cars. If it's stock or not upgraded with GT parts this is the first thing I'd consider.
I'm not sure I see anything odd in the videos from my experience.
If your throttle is sticking open or you are pressing throttle in braking your data will show that easily (Throttle position and throttle body position)
The diff has a massive impact on braking and steadiness on these cars. If it's stock or not upgraded with GT parts this is the first thing I'd consider.
I'm not sure I see anything odd in the videos from my experience.
If your throttle is sticking open or you are pressing throttle in braking your data will show that easily (Throttle position and throttle body position)
The following users liked this post:
jreifler (06-06-2023)
#15
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
How's your diff?
The diff has a massive impact on braking and steadiness on these cars. If it's stock or not upgraded with GT parts this is the first thing I'd consider.
I'm not sure I see anything odd in the videos from my experience.
If your throttle is sticking open or you are pressing throttle in braking your data will show that easily (Throttle position and throttle body position)
The diff has a massive impact on braking and steadiness on these cars. If it's stock or not upgraded with GT parts this is the first thing I'd consider.
I'm not sure I see anything odd in the videos from my experience.
If your throttle is sticking open or you are pressing throttle in braking your data will show that easily (Throttle position and throttle body position)
Edit - Given I don't really know the car on track yet, I'm also still running with TC on, which Alex said will further exacerbate the issue when the diff isn't doing its job . . .
I inspected the throttle and it's not sticking. So, ordered GT internals to beef up the diff, which was on my list anyway, but I figured I could track for a season first without the upgrade. Not so much.
Last edited by jreifler; 06-06-2023 at 02:35 PM.