Porsche PCM 3.0, SAT, Ipod and BT - Porsche behind the curve?
#1
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
Porsche PCM 3.0, SAT, Ipod and BT - Porsche behind the curve?
Updates..Have an 09 997.2 Carrera S which replaced my previous '05 997.1 Carrera base and while both cars are marvels of driving and handling and that classic 911 look..I have to say PCM 3.0 while much better than PCM 2.0 leaves a bit to be desired in terms of ability to add things after the fact. Its like Porsche purposely made it so its an all or none deal and you can't get anything after the car has left the factory. Also is it me or does Porsche seem to always be like a generation behind the latest and best A/V stuff in their cars? Its like MB, Audi, and other brands have hired and stole all the best electronics design guys or they don't read any of the auto A/V industry stuff cause you never see it in a Porsche until its like 4-5-6 yrs old it seems. Anybody remember the interior radios in the 996? It was my 1st Porsche and I must say I almost walked away like are you kidding when I saw the radio options. LOL I know they are meant to drive but A/V is a significant part of most of our auto experiences now a days especially as we spend more time in our vehicles and in traffic it seems or on our way on vacation avoiding the horrendous costs of airfare now adays due to gas prices.
So where am I going here? SAT radio intergration or shall I say RETROFIT into a PCM 3.0...just blows. Recently found out that I Nav-TV does offer a PCM 3.0 Sirrus module however it seems to work ONLY with certain versions of PCM 3.0 (ones without NAV). Important glitch that any of you considering this is that you NEED to check which PCM version your car has thru a screen before ordering/installation. I just had my dealer try it and they stopped at the step where the instructions said DO NOT INSTALL NON Compatible with this ver PCM 3.0 when they were prompted to check the PCM versions. My Porsche tech even checked with NAV-TV and affirmed that YES they haven't yet reached full operability with PCM 3.0 and it seems that the way Porsche is guarding the enable codes it may never happen as he said he tried quite a few ways to re-code the car and force PCM to enable/see the Sirius unit and it would error everytime saying NO PCM detected even with the new Sirius PCM module from Nav Tech. Talking to him further he says Sat radio seems to be hard wired as part of the new PCM 3.0 radios as a CPU module rather than a separate fxn which makes it VERY difficult to add on afterwise without replacing the entire PCM unit but on contrast since Porsche will NOT unlock the codes or release them for cars NOT built with Sat and PCM 3.0 off the factory floor it looks like 3 yrs out (2009+) there still are/will be NO good options for this.
His observation...Porsche is always about 2-4 yrs behind A/V stuff in their cars and get beat by everyone else before they are like hey that's a good idea (i.e. updated PCM 3.0 vs PCM 2.0). Am leaning toward agreement on that one. For example...my 2012 Audi A7 has google integrated NAV and Hi Res maps, allows me to navigate from a saved address on my phone (contacts), is its own mobile hotspot, and has a 40 gig harddrive which I can upload music to using SD AND has Sat radio and Ipod by just checking the Audi MMI option on the order sheet! My previous 09 BMW could upload CDC's straight into the NAV and also store stuff on a 40 gig HD.
Behind the road curve...maybe not as far as driving goes but behind the electron curve...yes...c'mon Porsche get with it!
So where am I going here? SAT radio intergration or shall I say RETROFIT into a PCM 3.0...just blows. Recently found out that I Nav-TV does offer a PCM 3.0 Sirrus module however it seems to work ONLY with certain versions of PCM 3.0 (ones without NAV). Important glitch that any of you considering this is that you NEED to check which PCM version your car has thru a screen before ordering/installation. I just had my dealer try it and they stopped at the step where the instructions said DO NOT INSTALL NON Compatible with this ver PCM 3.0 when they were prompted to check the PCM versions. My Porsche tech even checked with NAV-TV and affirmed that YES they haven't yet reached full operability with PCM 3.0 and it seems that the way Porsche is guarding the enable codes it may never happen as he said he tried quite a few ways to re-code the car and force PCM to enable/see the Sirius unit and it would error everytime saying NO PCM detected even with the new Sirius PCM module from Nav Tech. Talking to him further he says Sat radio seems to be hard wired as part of the new PCM 3.0 radios as a CPU module rather than a separate fxn which makes it VERY difficult to add on afterwise without replacing the entire PCM unit but on contrast since Porsche will NOT unlock the codes or release them for cars NOT built with Sat and PCM 3.0 off the factory floor it looks like 3 yrs out (2009+) there still are/will be NO good options for this.
His observation...Porsche is always about 2-4 yrs behind A/V stuff in their cars and get beat by everyone else before they are like hey that's a good idea (i.e. updated PCM 3.0 vs PCM 2.0). Am leaning toward agreement on that one. For example...my 2012 Audi A7 has google integrated NAV and Hi Res maps, allows me to navigate from a saved address on my phone (contacts), is its own mobile hotspot, and has a 40 gig harddrive which I can upload music to using SD AND has Sat radio and Ipod by just checking the Audi MMI option on the order sheet! My previous 09 BMW could upload CDC's straight into the NAV and also store stuff on a 40 gig HD.
Behind the road curve...maybe not as far as driving goes but behind the electron curve...yes...c'mon Porsche get with it!
#2
I agree with your sentiment 100%. I recall that for years getting an iPod to work in any Porsche required 3rd party solutions that left a lot to be desired. That was at a time when even rental cars allowed you to easily plug and play your ipods!
Maybe now that Porsche/Audi are under the same ownership (VW) things will change.
Would like to hear more about your experience with the A7. Nice article about it in WSJ yesterday.
Maybe now that Porsche/Audi are under the same ownership (VW) things will change.
Would like to hear more about your experience with the A7. Nice article about it in WSJ yesterday.
#3
Instructor
Join Date: May 2005
Location: Charlotte, NC
Posts: 191
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Definitely agree that the AV technology in these cars isn't exactly up to the $100k car standards in lux alternatives out there. Flip side of the coin is that those technological performers aren't in the same ballpark when it comes to the performance and drive that we've got in the 911. Each has a purpose. I'm in the process of selling my BMW 550 and just sold my 996 to move back into a 997 as a daily driver. When it came down to it, the heated/cooled seats, touchscreen nav, ipod integration, etc is more than enough technology for what I want in my daily drive. When our family needs more creature comforts in the trip, we'll take the technology-loaded SUV. All this said, I'm in the same situation as you with the 997 and Sirius and not too thrilled about it. Guess I'll now just be adding a separate tuner and running it through the AUX like I did in my 996. Not the factory integrated look, but I'll have a custom installer make it look pretty good and the features will be 10x better than the stock option. There's almost always puts and takes...
My $.02.
My $.02.
#4
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
I agree with your sentiment 100%. I recall that for years getting an iPod to work in any Porsche required 3rd party solutions that left a lot to be desired. That was at a time when even rental cars allowed you to easily plug and play your ipods!
Maybe now that Porsche/Audi are under the same ownership (VW) things will change.
Would like to hear more about your experience with the A7. Nice article about it in WSJ yesterday.
Maybe now that Porsche/Audi are under the same ownership (VW) things will change.
Would like to hear more about your experience with the A7. Nice article about it in WSJ yesterday.
Definitely agree that the AV technology in these cars isn't exactly up to the $100k car standards in lux alternatives out there. Flip side of the coin is that those technological performers aren't in the same ballpark when it comes to the performance and drive that we've got in the 911. Each has a purpose. I'm in the process of selling my BMW 550 and just sold my 996 to move back into a 997 as a daily driver. When it came down to it, the heated/cooled seats, touchscreen nav, ipod integration, etc is more than enough technology for what I want in my daily drive. When our family needs more creature comforts in the trip, we'll take the technology-loaded SUV. All this said, I'm in the same situation as you with the 997 and Sirius and not too thrilled about it. Guess I'll now just be adding a separate tuner and running it through the AUX like I did in my 996. Not the factory integrated look, but I'll have a custom installer make it look pretty good and the features will be 10x better than the stock option. There's almost always puts and takes...
My $.02.
My $.02.
Just a shame...but i too will likely get an Sirius unit to plug into the PCM 3.0 and use either the AUX input or FM as my dealer tech said that's really the only option unless Porsche decides to uncode/recode their Sat options.
#5
I wish Porsche would go the opposite route and just offer a no-frills 911. Give me power locks/windows/A/C and not much else.
Rob - it's tough to compare Porsche's A/V stuff when Audi is always pushing the standards... Thank goodness you've got one of each to keep you balanced.
Rob - it's tough to compare Porsche's A/V stuff when Audi is always pushing the standards... Thank goodness you've got one of each to keep you balanced.
#6
Rennlist Member
Thread Starter
I wish Porsche would go the opposite route and just offer a no-frills 911. Give me power locks/windows/A/C and not much else.
Rob - it's tough to compare Porsche's A/V stuff when Audi is always pushing the standards... Thank goodness you've got one of each to keep you balanced.
Rob - it's tough to compare Porsche's A/V stuff when Audi is always pushing the standards... Thank goodness you've got one of each to keep you balanced.
#7
Nordschleife Master
Trending Topics
#8
Drifting
I'm all for them not chasing the latest tech until its got traction, so I'm fine with a little lag. But this is why I didn't buy a 997 until the 997.2 came out.
Porsche does seem to go vertical-software-market-enable-code happy with their internal configs but then do such a stupid job on the design and features of the system that its either factory original Porsche option or you don't get that feature by 3rd party means. They should ease off the whole -enable code- nonsense unless it is to turn on a feature built into the car/PCM, but that should not prevent 3rd party module additions.
But then this is sorta like the "$5,000 Tag-Heuer Watch" vs "$200 Casio Watch" issue: one is very expensive and has very few features and is way behind in timekeeping technology. The other lets you do modern whiz-bang stuff like temp, elevation, compass, multiple time zones, etc... and costs way less.
Porsche does seem to go vertical-software-market-enable-code happy with their internal configs but then do such a stupid job on the design and features of the system that its either factory original Porsche option or you don't get that feature by 3rd party means. They should ease off the whole -enable code- nonsense unless it is to turn on a feature built into the car/PCM, but that should not prevent 3rd party module additions.
But then this is sorta like the "$5,000 Tag-Heuer Watch" vs "$200 Casio Watch" issue: one is very expensive and has very few features and is way behind in timekeeping technology. The other lets you do modern whiz-bang stuff like temp, elevation, compass, multiple time zones, etc... and costs way less.
#9
All good but is there a way to add BT Audio streaming on PCM 3.0 v2.2? I've checked the manual and have downloaded a UTube video but I don't get the Aux BT as the video says I should.
#10
Rocky Mountain High
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I agree with these comments.
I have PCM 2.1 in my 997 and it is primitive compared to the MMI system in my wife's Audi SQ5. I did add a Mobridge system to my 997 that gives me bluetooth telephone connectivity as well as streaming bluetooth audio. I don't have satellite radio and I have no interest in adding it. I thought I wanted it until I used it in the Audi. I don't think the programming that is available is worth the money. I much prefer streaming Spotify or Pandora.
I have PCM 2.1 in my 997 and it is primitive compared to the MMI system in my wife's Audi SQ5. I did add a Mobridge system to my 997 that gives me bluetooth telephone connectivity as well as streaming bluetooth audio. I don't have satellite radio and I have no interest in adding it. I thought I wanted it until I used it in the Audi. I don't think the programming that is available is worth the money. I much prefer streaming Spotify or Pandora.
#11
Rennlist Member
I'm fine with the capability of my PCM 3.0 997 although I'm glad it has the Universal Audio Interface option (iPod + USB input). For music, I just pop in a 16GB USB stick loaded w/ tunes and it's been great.
It would be nice to be able to stream music via Bluetooth from my phone (should I happen to want to stream Slacker Radio) but I can always use the 1/8" wired audio input for this. I don't need to do this badly enough. If I did I'd probably just order up something like this and stuff it in the armrest:
My car also came with XM Radio. SiriusXM is letting everyone get a free taste these past couple weeks. Personally I think the audio quality is garbage. I'd never pay for it. Maybe if I went on a long road trip I'd activate it for a month but otherwise, no way...
It would be nice to be able to stream music via Bluetooth from my phone (should I happen to want to stream Slacker Radio) but I can always use the 1/8" wired audio input for this. I don't need to do this badly enough. If I did I'd probably just order up something like this and stuff it in the armrest:
Amazon.com: [New Version] Mpow® Streambot Mini Wireless Bluetooth 4.0 Audio Music Streaming Receiver Adapter with 3.5 mm Stereo Output and Hands Free Calling for Car: Cell Phones & Accessories
My car also came with XM Radio. SiriusXM is letting everyone get a free taste these past couple weeks. Personally I think the audio quality is garbage. I'd never pay for it. Maybe if I went on a long road trip I'd activate it for a month but otherwise, no way...
#13
I'm fine with the capability of my PCM 3.0 997 although I'm glad it has the Universal Audio Interface option (iPod + USB input). For music, I just pop in a 16GB USB stick loaded w/ tunes and it's been great. It would be nice to be able to stream music via Bluetooth from my phone (should I happen to want to stream Slacker Radio) but I can always use the 1/8" wired audio input for this. I don't need to do this badly enough. If I did I'd probably just order up something like this and stuff it in the armrest: Video Link: http://www.amazon.com/Streambot-Wireless-Bluetooth-Streaming-Receiver/dp/B00MJMV0GU/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&qid=1417121355&sr=8-2&keywords=bluetooth+audio+receiver+car My car also came with XM Radio. SiriusXM is letting everyone get a free taste these past couple weeks. Personally I think the audio quality is garbage. I'd never pay for it. Maybe if I went on a long road trip I'd activate it for a month but otherwise, no way...
#14
Rennlist Member
Strange isn't it and a bit befuddling that people get a car for it's driving dynamics together with a high degree of practicability, leading one to assume that they are car enthusiasts. Then the same persons gripe ad nauseam about the lack of audio/video options and/or flexibility.
Forgive me for being a bit naive in my assumption, but who in the boody hell cares about A/V crap that one can only hear at a marginal level at best?
Shouldn't these people pay attention to their angles of attack and/or exit on a nice curve on their daily drive, while monitoring the oil temp, oil pressure gauge while in "sport" and enjoy a daily driving experience second to none? Shouldn't they be listening to their engine in an effort to know its sound when in good shape so that they can quickly spot potential problems if any?
Please, try to enjoy your car for its avowed purpose, letting those frilly things be where they belong: in the background. Realize that you are member of a small group of car "nuts" that truly value the driving experience whether in stop and go traffic, the boring freeway or the curvy country road. Try to revel in the mechanical marvel under your seat, the way it works so seamlessly together, the precision of it all, the way it does precisely what you tell it, the way it saves your *** when you get stupid and/or careless.
Guys, this is not a common car, it is a Porsche. Drive it and A/V be damned!
Forgive me for being a bit naive in my assumption, but who in the boody hell cares about A/V crap that one can only hear at a marginal level at best?
Shouldn't these people pay attention to their angles of attack and/or exit on a nice curve on their daily drive, while monitoring the oil temp, oil pressure gauge while in "sport" and enjoy a daily driving experience second to none? Shouldn't they be listening to their engine in an effort to know its sound when in good shape so that they can quickly spot potential problems if any?
Please, try to enjoy your car for its avowed purpose, letting those frilly things be where they belong: in the background. Realize that you are member of a small group of car "nuts" that truly value the driving experience whether in stop and go traffic, the boring freeway or the curvy country road. Try to revel in the mechanical marvel under your seat, the way it works so seamlessly together, the precision of it all, the way it does precisely what you tell it, the way it saves your *** when you get stupid and/or careless.
Guys, this is not a common car, it is a Porsche. Drive it and A/V be damned!
#15
Rennlist Member
Strange isn't it and a bit befuddling that people get a car for it's driving dynamics together with a high degree of practicability, leading one to assume that they are car enthusiasts. Then the same persons gripe ad nauseam about the lack of audio/video options and/or flexibility. Forgive me for being a bit naive in my assumption, but who in the boody hell cares about A/V crap that one can only hear at a marginal level at best? Shouldn't these people pay attention to their angles of attack and/or exit on a nice curve on their daily drive, while monitoring the oil temp, oil pressure gauge while in "sport" and enjoy a daily driving experience second to none? Shouldn't they be listening to their engine in an effort to know its sound when in good shape so that they can quickly spot potential problems if any? Please, try to enjoy your car for its avowed purpose, letting those frilly things be where they belong: in the background. Realize that you are member of a small group of car "nuts" that truly value the driving experience whether in stop and go traffic, the boring freeway or the curvy country road. Try to revel in the mechanical marvel under your seat, the way it works so seamlessly together, the precision of it all, the way it does precisely what you tell it, the way it saves your *** when you get stupid and/or careless. Guys, this is not a common car, it is a Porsche. Drive it and A/V be damned!