The silver car has CPO until Feb 2012, and looks decent. The red one has full leather interior and lower miles. Both look appealing, depending on what color you like and what options are important. But be patient, as cars come on the market all the time. I would decide what color and options were important to me, and search until the right deal came along. It could take months, but worth the wait IMO. I have never purchased without a personal first hand look and test drive. Good luck.

 

I've bought all my P-cars "sight unseen" based on PPI's and very thorough pictures. I have yet to be disappointed!!

 

First of all I want to thank all the members here with your great inputs. This forum is awesome!
I’ve been on forums where you post a question and no one is willing to share their thoughts.
The silver one seems to be a great car and a solid deal. Good price, color is common for resale and easy to maintain. (I’ve had two black cars and will never go back even though they look amazing the first 10 min or so after cleaning)
Red however is THE color for me. Always wanted a red sports car but the ones I had are just not good enough for red. This red one also seems to have sports seat but not power seat from the pic.
Lower millage and the ideal color; let’s see if the condition and value supports the $5,000 difference in price.
Thanks again!