Michelin PS4S like driving on soap!
#16
#17
Rennlist Member
@Shooter50 First I'd like to thank your people (mine too) for the tebirkes at Emmery's. I've had them at several locations and the ones at Noreport are the best. They just nail the balance between creaminess and crisp carmelization better than any other location. Also, they always seem freshest there.
Back to the tires - we have a good resource here in the US where you can determine somewhat reliably the general characteristics of tires (performance in wet, dry, comfort and treadwear) plus lots of user reviews.
Just enter your car here and any US zip code (46228 might be a good one as it is TR headquarters and might improve your selection for research).
https://www.tirerack.com/content/tir.../homepage.html
Everyone else is right - put some miles on carefully first.
Back to the tires - we have a good resource here in the US where you can determine somewhat reliably the general characteristics of tires (performance in wet, dry, comfort and treadwear) plus lots of user reviews.
Just enter your car here and any US zip code (46228 might be a good one as it is TR headquarters and might improve your selection for research).
https://www.tirerack.com/content/tir.../homepage.html
Everyone else is right - put some miles on carefully first.
#18
Nordschleife Master
Appropriate tire pressure may vary with compound but it is mostly defined by vehicle mass and tire patch size. It was long determined that for the 997.2 a good street value is 33/37PSI (at 68F). 32/36 can work too if the car has no load (1 driver), but that would not be a good value to set when hot. Hot (rubber temp 100F or so), the rears should hover around 40PSI.
#19
Instructor
Join Date: Jun 2009
Location: San Francisco Bay Area
Posts: 142
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Old thread revival from someone who hasn't posted in a long time....
I just replaced aged-out MPSS with MPS4S on all wheels of my 2009 997.2S. Date codes 0521 and 0921, so fresh tires. Also had an alignment done, only a minor adjustment was needed on 1 wheel.
I understand that traction will be compromised until the tires are broken-in. However, do the PS4S start out noisier and then quiet down once broken in? I've driven approx 50 miles so far. At freeway speeds I am getting road noise that is noticeably louder than what I experienced with several sets of MPSS with comparable mileage after installation. Its not a constant noise either - it rhythmically varies slightly in pitch even at constant speed. Below 60mph the road noise seems normal. The underbody looks normal, although I have not examined the car while on a lift.
TIA for sharing your experiences.
I just replaced aged-out MPSS with MPS4S on all wheels of my 2009 997.2S. Date codes 0521 and 0921, so fresh tires. Also had an alignment done, only a minor adjustment was needed on 1 wheel.
I understand that traction will be compromised until the tires are broken-in. However, do the PS4S start out noisier and then quiet down once broken in? I've driven approx 50 miles so far. At freeway speeds I am getting road noise that is noticeably louder than what I experienced with several sets of MPSS with comparable mileage after installation. Its not a constant noise either - it rhythmically varies slightly in pitch even at constant speed. Below 60mph the road noise seems normal. The underbody looks normal, although I have not examined the car while on a lift.
TIA for sharing your experiences.
Last edited by SY-997; 05-12-2021 at 09:44 PM.
#20
I would say the 4S is very good, but fairly loud even after break in, but it's very dependent on road surface, on uneven highway concrete it's not nice, however a smooth stretch of fresh blacktop and you barely notice the noise.
I feel like a bit higher than recommended pressure seems like they roll smoother, could be a placebo effect.
I feel like a bit higher than recommended pressure seems like they roll smoother, could be a placebo effect.
#22
As for the soap part, I can’t say the same’s true for me. They feel great and are very quiet compared to my prior RE050A tires that the dealer installed in the CPO process. Those were terrible in comparison.
#23
I put MP4S all around 22.5K miles ago and loved them. The rears wore out so I put new ones on yesterday before a 500 mile drive today (mostly freeway). The rhythmic noises you describe were there. The car is floating and pulling. It took effort to drive straight. At triple digit speeds it was uncomfortable. It made for a long day.
That being said, my tire guy inflates high and I didn't lower the pressure before departure. The rears raised to 50 psi while the fronts were at 44 once they were warmed up. Tomorrow when they are cool I'll lower the pressures and see what happens with some spirited twisties. We have about an 8 hour loop planned out so by the end of the day I'll know better.
I remain hopeful.
That being said, my tire guy inflates high and I didn't lower the pressure before departure. The rears raised to 50 psi while the fronts were at 44 once they were warmed up. Tomorrow when they are cool I'll lower the pressures and see what happens with some spirited twisties. We have about an 8 hour loop planned out so by the end of the day I'll know better.
I remain hopeful.
#24
Instructor
This is a timely post for me. I just put Pilot 4S tires on my '07 Carrera S and completely lost my handling ability. I took it to the track and the turn in is terrible and the car doesn't feel connected anymore. I'm going to have it aligned but if this doesn't work I'm returning the tires to Tirerack. I can't figure out why they get such good reviews. Traction, ride, noise quality is fantastic but now steering inputs result in a lot of body roll.
#25
Rennlist Member
This is a timely post for me. I just put Pilot 4S tires on my '07 Carrera S and completely lost my handling ability. I took it to the track and the turn in is terrible and the car doesn't feel connected anymore. I'm going to have it aligned but if this doesn't work I'm returning the tires to Tirerack. I can't figure out why they get such good reviews. Traction, ride, noise quality is fantastic but now steering inputs result in a lot of body roll.
#26
Intermediate
This is a timely post for me. I just put Pilot 4S tires on my '07 Carrera S and completely lost my handling ability. I took it to the track and the turn in is terrible and the car doesn't feel connected anymore. I'm going to have it aligned but if this doesn't work I'm returning the tires to Tirerack. I can't figure out why they get such good reviews. Traction, ride, noise quality is fantastic but now steering inputs result in a lot of body roll.
The following users liked this post:
pro1200 (05-13-2021)
#27
RL Community Team
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
2009 C2S 171K miles
I think I am one of the only ones here who are not totally enamored with the 4S tire. Yes, the soapyness will go away, but you will still be left with the disappointing affects of a softer sidewall. The tire is supposed to grip in corners the same or better than its predecessors so say test after test..... but it sure doesn't feel like it.
Peace
Bruce in Philly
I think I am one of the only ones here who are not totally enamored with the 4S tire. Yes, the soapyness will go away, but you will still be left with the disappointing affects of a softer sidewall. The tire is supposed to grip in corners the same or better than its predecessors so say test after test..... but it sure doesn't feel like it.
Peace
Bruce in Philly
The following users liked this post:
pro1200 (05-13-2021)
#28
I reduced my pressures this morning. Yesterday was just short of 500 miles to remove the mold release. Today will be just under 500 miles of twisties. More to be revealed.
FWIW, at 22.5K miles, the 4S rears gave 10% less service than the sets of previous PSS tires. But that's within the range of noise and driving conditions. Still, perhaps an indicator. The fronts look like they will be less than the PSS average of 36K miles as well.
Yeah, to get that much wear I've got my toe and camber settings at their minimum. I used to do a lot of commuting and for canyon carving there is still a lot of handling window left. I'll gladly admit that the car is definitely not set up for the track. Now retired, I'm debating getting aggressive on alignment settings. But yesterday's instability was well beyond the norm.
I have really liked the PS4S. I don't mean to berate them. The next couple days after this one will put another 1000+ miles on so I think I'll know by then.
FWIW, at 22.5K miles, the 4S rears gave 10% less service than the sets of previous PSS tires. But that's within the range of noise and driving conditions. Still, perhaps an indicator. The fronts look like they will be less than the PSS average of 36K miles as well.
Yeah, to get that much wear I've got my toe and camber settings at their minimum. I used to do a lot of commuting and for canyon carving there is still a lot of handling window left. I'll gladly admit that the car is definitely not set up for the track. Now retired, I'm debating getting aggressive on alignment settings. But yesterday's instability was well beyond the norm.
I have really liked the PS4S. I don't mean to berate them. The next couple days after this one will put another 1000+ miles on so I think I'll know by then.
#29
This funny. Every time Michelin comes out with a new tire, it is declared the "best ever". I am sure, as with almost everything, things do get better over time, incrementally. But this all reminds me of when the Pilot Super Sports came out. " Much, much better than the PS2s..... best ever". Then the comments came out about "greasiness" and a few blowouts. It seems like no one even talks about them now. PS4 comments are giving me Deja Vu. Perhaps they are more comfortable than the PS2s. I replaced my P Zero Rossos that came with my car with PS2s. They now have a fair amount of miles on them ( 18K?) and they are still quiet compare to the thump, thump, thump of he Pirellis with 12K miles at low speeds. Yes, my PS2s did feel strange when I first got them with some "squiggly" behavior/feel before the mold release wore off but they have been great. Handling is still great.
My guess is that Michelin is making their UHP tires a bit more like their all-seasons to get a bit more life, a bit more comfort and reduced noise. Let's not forget that sports car are becoming even less important in the market. I am sure there have been many relatively new (<2yr) used 911s on the market as the original owner thought it was a cool prestige brand only to find it is an extreme hard-core sports car. Even BMWs have become more flabby as they are seen more as a status symbol rather than an "ultimate driving machine".
My guess is that Michelin is making their UHP tires a bit more like their all-seasons to get a bit more life, a bit more comfort and reduced noise. Let's not forget that sports car are becoming even less important in the market. I am sure there have been many relatively new (<2yr) used 911s on the market as the original owner thought it was a cool prestige brand only to find it is an extreme hard-core sports car. Even BMWs have become more flabby as they are seen more as a status symbol rather than an "ultimate driving machine".
#30
Instructor
I'm glad that some owners feel the same way about these tires. I, too, feel the sidewalls are too weak for good handling. When I was on the track with them I remember one incidence that was a pucker up moment. I was at the end of a long straight at about 140 MPH heading into the banked turn and all of a sudden the car shifted. It didn't lose traction-it felt like the whole body shifted to the outside. The way it handled was not the way a 911 should go through a turn.
Last edited by pro1200; 05-14-2021 at 08:52 AM.