Shaved rain gutters and high speed aerodynamics
#16
Pro
Chris,
First thing I thought when I saw that first PIC was that I'd trade you flying lessons for driving lessons in that car. Then I saw the second PIC and realized you don't need flying lessons. Although it looks like your runway alignment could use a little work! Nice flare though!
First thing I thought when I saw that first PIC was that I'd trade you flying lessons for driving lessons in that car. Then I saw the second PIC and realized you don't need flying lessons. Although it looks like your runway alignment could use a little work! Nice flare though!
#17
RL Technical Advisor
Originally Posted by Geoffrey
My understanding from someone who raced a 993RSR at Daytona that the A pillar farings were worth 6mph on the banking.
While I couldn't afford wind tunnel time, we DID do a lot of tuft-testing and filmed the car while on the road at varing speeds. The airflow was not as turbulent and appeared to be more laminar down the side windows of the car. Airflow going to the tail was also less disturbed but we had no way to measure downforce aside from driver seat-of-pants inputs.
Being self-sponsored, we didn't have the big bucks so we improvised a lot.
#18
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
Steve,
Here's my old IMSA car at Riverside. I used white duct tape on the a-pillers to act as a poor man's fairing. This was about 25 years ago. Maybe I saw you out there?
So, bottom line, you feel that shaving the gutters improved your aerodynamics at high speed?
Here's my old IMSA car at Riverside. I used white duct tape on the a-pillers to act as a poor man's fairing. This was about 25 years ago. Maybe I saw you out there?
So, bottom line, you feel that shaving the gutters improved your aerodynamics at high speed?
#19
Guru
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
While I am not a proper aerodynamicist, I do have some experience with ground effect cars. I would venture to guess blocking the frontal area of the rain gutters could easily yield 5 mph (speed squared law) straight line, losing the top of the rain gutters may decrease directional stability. Whether it could be felt with a car so soft with respect to pitch and roll remains to be seen. Gotta tap into the extensive experience in the folks like Mr. Weiner and go from there
Here is an image of some rather simple flo-vis (flow visualization) techniques we sometimes do with full scale cars to better understand what exactly airflow is doing. Its just a little dye mixed with gearbox oil
Edit: Notice the funky airflow around the 1" hole on the roll hoop above the Toyota decal. More evidence that holes or features like these need to be taped-up to minimize drag. It all adds up!!
Here is an image of some rather simple flo-vis (flow visualization) techniques we sometimes do with full scale cars to better understand what exactly airflow is doing. Its just a little dye mixed with gearbox oil
Edit: Notice the funky airflow around the 1" hole on the roll hoop above the Toyota decal. More evidence that holes or features like these need to be taped-up to minimize drag. It all adds up!!
#20
From a safety point of view. YOu'll notice when Ruf shaves the gutters he puts in a full cage or his IRC. All the strength in the ruf...I mean roof is I understand is in the welded lip. I considered doing mine, but don't want to run a full cage...so I'll probably just do the a-pillar farings. Plus here in LA, you got to get up at like 4:30 am if you're going to do a +200mph run. Great way to start the day.
#21
Guru
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
Orrrrrr, one can do some theoretical analysis in CFD --
Notice the orange-red colors as high drag areas or hotspots --
Notice the orange-red colors as high drag areas or hotspots --
#22
IMHO- it looks WAY better with the gutters removed... (yes, my car still HAS the gutters)
Steve, your not in it for the speed, your in it to look good... plus, those rain gutteres must weigh at least 2 lbs (per side)!
Steve, your not in it for the speed, your in it to look good... plus, those rain gutteres must weigh at least 2 lbs (per side)!
#23
RL Technical Advisor
Originally Posted by ca993twin
Steve,
Here's my old IMSA car at Riverside. I used white duct tape on the a-pillers to act as a poor man's fairing. This was about 25 years ago. Maybe I saw you out there?
So, bottom line, you feel that shaving the gutters improved your aerodynamics at high speed?
Here's my old IMSA car at Riverside. I used white duct tape on the a-pillers to act as a poor man's fairing. This was about 25 years ago. Maybe I saw you out there?
So, bottom line, you feel that shaving the gutters improved your aerodynamics at high speed?
I never raced at Riverside but plenty of other tracks on the circuit. We were at Portland, Sears (oops, Infineon), Laguna, Road America, Brainerd, Mid-Ohio and Daytona, of course,..
We didn't shave the gutters on our car; I simply installed a set of 935 rubber A-pillar fairings per some advice from some factory engineers. For drag reduction, it worked. I cannot say for certain that I felt a major change in stability since we used the superior AIR front & rear RSR fenders and ran a vertically-extended RSR tail that was better than factory RSR bodywork.......
Chris and others raise a point about the possible role that the gutters might play in high-speed stability but I have no data about that. We did race a 935 for some time (after the RSR) that didn't have any gutters and it was stable as a rock. I think that was due to the completely different aerodynamics of that car and less about whether it had gutters or not.
Like Chris, I'm certainly no aerodynamicist but having owned and flown several aircraft over the past 35+ years, it seems like the gutters are not positioned suchly nor tall enough to make a big difference, at least to compared to other things. Without hard windtunnel data, thats only an semi-educated guess.
#24
Technical Guru
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
Originally Posted by chris walrod
I have the wind tunnel...Orrrrrr, one can do some theoretical analysis in CFD
#26
Guru
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
Lifetime Rennlist
Member
Rennlist Small
Business Sponsor
Originally Posted by JasonAndreas
If you have a stereolithography machine I have a laser scanned, cleaned up and triangulated 993TT.
#28
Nordschleife Master
Thread Starter
That is a GREAT article on the 993TT aero issues. Thanks for shairng that. The Ruf areo mirrors, shaved a-piller and flush rear glass look like some easy fixes... but the big problem is with the entire rear of the car.
#29
Having looked over a couple of genuine RUF CTR (yellowbird) based on the 911 bodyshell of the late '80s, they had all the guttering removed. There must be something in it, have you asked RUF directly?
#30
How about installing Rain cutter spoiler set instead of cutting it?
FVD :
http://shop.fvd.de/shop/?VID=123823&...Body=&CarYear=
or RUF
FVD :
http://shop.fvd.de/shop/?VID=123823&...Body=&CarYear=
or RUF