Differences between 17” and 18” wheels
#16
Instructor
Join Date: Mar 2010
Location: Kansas City
Posts: 115
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I recently added a set of Carrera III's to my car in 18x8/10 running RE-11s, in place of Cup IIs running Conti DWs (not DWSs) - besides more available grip, the ride on the same suspension is actually more controlled and smoother on the new 18s. I was pleasantly surprised.
Christian
'95 Carrera
Christian
'95 Carrera
#19
Why is it a bigger tire?
it's fairly easy to find a combination of 18" wheel and tire that wil be lighter than 17" Cup and 17" tire. Don't forget, in 17" tire you have an extra inch of sidewall, which is not light. Hell, let's look at some examples, shall we? These are specs for Dunlop ZII: http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....el=Direzza+ZII The difference in weight between the 255/40-17 and 265/35-18, the two tires I've personally used on my 993s, is one lb. About the same holds true for a Michelin PS2: http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....ilot+Sport+PS2 Surely, a light 18" wheels can easily be found that would be more than 1 lb lighter than 9" Cup II at 22 lbs. Heck, OZ Alleggerita in 18x10 are 3 lbs lighter.
Having said all that... for a street car... it doesn't matter, in my opinion. I have about 250+ autocross events under my belt, maybe about 2,000 runs in 100+ different cars. Including my own 2,100 lb CSP car that I've been driving for 11 seasons on 25 lb 13x8.5 wheel and tire combo (sic) and 33 lb 15x10 wheel and tire combo. I'll be damned if I can really feel the diference in acceleration due to weight. Maybe others have a much finer calibrated butt dyno, I don't know.
it's fairly easy to find a combination of 18" wheel and tire that wil be lighter than 17" Cup and 17" tire. Don't forget, in 17" tire you have an extra inch of sidewall, which is not light. Hell, let's look at some examples, shall we? These are specs for Dunlop ZII: http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....el=Direzza+ZII The difference in weight between the 255/40-17 and 265/35-18, the two tires I've personally used on my 993s, is one lb. About the same holds true for a Michelin PS2: http://www.tirerack.com/tires/tires....ilot+Sport+PS2 Surely, a light 18" wheels can easily be found that would be more than 1 lb lighter than 9" Cup II at 22 lbs. Heck, OZ Alleggerita in 18x10 are 3 lbs lighter.
Having said all that... for a street car... it doesn't matter, in my opinion. I have about 250+ autocross events under my belt, maybe about 2,000 runs in 100+ different cars. Including my own 2,100 lb CSP car that I've been driving for 11 seasons on 25 lb 13x8.5 wheel and tire combo (sic) and 33 lb 15x10 wheel and tire combo. I'll be damned if I can really feel the diference in acceleration due to weight. Maybe others have a much finer calibrated butt dyno, I don't know.
What got me to assume that it would be an increase in weight when switching from 17" to 18" is the mention made by the OP that he was considering 18" RUFs which are virtual boat anchors as compared to the stock Cup II's.
#20
Three Wheelin'
I changed from 17"s to 18"s two years ago on my 96 targa. Can hardly tell any difference. Tire longevity seems to be about the same and in spite of hearing the glass targa top cannot take the additional stiffness, I've experienced no problems. I also do not notice much change in braking. I have to say that I like how the 18"s look on my car.
Perhaps a more experienced track driver could feel the difference, but it all just feels "right" to me.
#21
I thought the cup II are 18 lbs front and 19.5 lbs rear. I have had some 18" BBS LM wheels on my car for a few weeks and I went back to 17" because I didn't like the ride and feel of it. For me the selection was mostly based on look, cost, and feel. I think any performance merit (on street driving) is mostly a placebo effect.
#22
Having said all that... for a street car... it doesn't matter, in my opinion. I have about 250+ autocross events under my belt, maybe about 2,000 runs in 100+ different cars. Including my own 2,100 lb CSP car that I've been driving for 11 seasons on 25 lb 13x8.5 wheel and tire combo (sic) and 33 lb 15x10 wheel and tire combo. I'll be damned if I can really feel the diference in acceleration due to weight. Maybe others have a much finer calibrated butt dyno, I don't know.
Last edited by nine9six; 09-09-2014 at 07:19 PM.
#23
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
#24
Nordschleife Master
When I went from cup IIs to MY02s, I noticed handling and ride changes.
Can't say there was any difference in acceleration or not, but steering response was crisper, and the ride was a little harsher.
That may have also been attributed to tire and tire pressure differences though and NOT just the wheel difference. The cup II tires were Sumitomo HTR Z IIIs and the MY02s had Michelin Pilot Sports. I had them mounted at the shop and don't know what pressure their in the Michelins.
Incidentally, the Cup IIs and the MY02s are pretty close in weight, don't know about the tires.
Can't say there was any difference in acceleration or not, but steering response was crisper, and the ride was a little harsher.
That may have also been attributed to tire and tire pressure differences though and NOT just the wheel difference. The cup II tires were Sumitomo HTR Z IIIs and the MY02s had Michelin Pilot Sports. I had them mounted at the shop and don't know what pressure their in the Michelins.
Incidentally, the Cup IIs and the MY02s are pretty close in weight, don't know about the tires.
#26
Addict
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I believe that both are direct result of shorter sidewall. With results exactly as expected.
#27
Don't dismiss the fun factor!
It's fun to pick out 18 wheels that suit your style, making the car feel a bit more tailored to your personality.
Buy at set of 18 inch wheels/tires at fair price, keep your 17s until to your ready to let them go knowing the ride/feel has met your expectations. You can always sell the 18s too if not.
It's fun to pick out 18 wheels that suit your style, making the car feel a bit more tailored to your personality.
Buy at set of 18 inch wheels/tires at fair price, keep your 17s until to your ready to let them go knowing the ride/feel has met your expectations. You can always sell the 18s too if not.
#28
Addicted Specialist
Rennlist Member
Rennlist Member
I will concur: "feel" is due largely to sidewall and one's tire choice. Go to an R-comp in 17", say, and you'll know all you need to know about stiffness and will likely forget all about the need to go to an 18" (just a point of comparison, not that I advocate an R-comp for street use ).
There is much to be said about the light weight of the Cup IIs, not to mention their simple, elegant lines. I submit most want to go to bigger wheels more for looks than any real consideration of function. So if aesthetics are the chief concern, just go with what you like since at street speeds you'll likely notice no diffs in handling between 17" and 18" wheels, but will almost certainly notice a diff in comfort.
BTW, may I humbly submit that the stock Cup IIs ain't hard to look at
Edward
There is much to be said about the light weight of the Cup IIs, not to mention their simple, elegant lines. I submit most want to go to bigger wheels more for looks than any real consideration of function. So if aesthetics are the chief concern, just go with what you like since at street speeds you'll likely notice no diffs in handling between 17" and 18" wheels, but will almost certainly notice a diff in comfort.
BTW, may I humbly submit that the stock Cup IIs ain't hard to look at
Edward
#29
1) weight - whether or not the driver notices, increasing the rotating weight is a bad thing - it will blunt acceleration, braking and, well, everything. 17" wheels and especially tires (which are furthest away from the center of rotation and therefore have a big effect) are usually lighter then the wider 18s
2) width on the front - the biggest difference that you notice immediately is the feel of the difference in width between 205 and 225 section tires - for track or road, the steering precision of the 205 is almost telepathic compared to the (also heavier) 225. Sure a 205 has less grip, but there's plenty of grip on a 993 anyway - if you are driving at speeds where this becomes an issue, then you should be enrolling with an F1 team.
3) Feel - a great deal depends on tire choice - for example Bridgestone S-02s have a very hard sidewall, so 17s wearing 205/50 and 255/40 will feel 'precise' allowing good turn-in and driver feedback. Softer sidewalls will feel like marshmallow in comparison. Yes 18s with a shorter sidewall tighten things up in this respect, but see 1) and 2) above.
No matter what you want to do, keep the OE so-called Cup2 wheels. You will go back to them one day and immediately think 'wow - this is the best wheel/tire combo ever!'
#30
Nordschleife Master
I will concur: "feel" is due largely to sidewall and one's tire choice. Go to an R-comp in 17", say, and you'll know all you need to know about stiffness and will likely forget all about the need to go to an 18" (just a point of comparison, not that I advocate an R-comp for street use ).
There is much to be said about the light weight of the Cup IIs, not to mention their simple, elegant lines. I submit most want to go to bigger wheels more for looks than any real consideration of function. So if aesthetics are the chief concern, just go with what you like since at street speeds you'll likely notice no diffs in handling between 17" and 18" wheels, but will almost certainly notice a diff in comfort.
BTW, may I humbly submit that the stock Cup IIs ain't hard to look at
Edward
There is much to be said about the light weight of the Cup IIs, not to mention their simple, elegant lines. I submit most want to go to bigger wheels more for looks than any real consideration of function. So if aesthetics are the chief concern, just go with what you like since at street speeds you'll likely notice no diffs in handling between 17" and 18" wheels, but will almost certainly notice a diff in comfort.
BTW, may I humbly submit that the stock Cup IIs ain't hard to look at
Edward