17in vs 18in
I went from 17" Cups to 18" Solid Twists. Very happy with the change overall. There are a number of variable's to consider when switching diameters. Aside from weight, I think your choice of tires will have the most great impact on the change. Every tire selection has a unique set of handling characteristics. Although 18's have a shorter sidewall, some tires will have a softer sidewall and some stiffer. Bottom line....very happy with the change to 18's (simply looks way better). If it looks better, it must handle better. ;-)
I added the Technical Service Bulletin (TSB) brace mentioned above.
The part I wanted to comment on is the myth that staying in 17" offers more of a variety. I found variety is not greater, but price is what I call reasonably more expensive when trying to find rubber in 235/285 sizes. The only 17" options close to 235/285 were Hoosier A6 and Kumho V710 and even then, I had to go to 225 front and either 275 or 295 rear, not to mention you won't get that many heat cycles out of these tires so replacement is frequent and expensive. Yokohama Advan AO48 only went to a 255 rear, Pirelli PZero Corsa wasn't an option, and Michelin PSC only had 225/275 as an option. As soon as I started looking at 18", there were many more sizes available in 10mm increments including the 235/285 combination I was trying to achieve. The interesting thing is that when comparing the 17" to 18" in price, the 18s were only about $30-$40 more per tire on average, but you were getting more rubber front and rear for the extra money.
For example, the 225/275/17 MPSCs are $250/$288 at Tirerack. By way of comparison, the 235/285/18 MPSCs are $283/$328. Another example is Yokohama Advan AO48s where 235/255/17s are $271/$266 while 235/285/18s are $289/$314.
As Bill mentioned, the tires run cooler but since the contact patch is bigger, you are spreading all the forces of the car onto a larger patch and thus, wear rate is also better. An 18" tire of the same size and compound as a 17" tire will have better longevity because of this.
This is what I determined anyway and even if anyone disagrees, please let me live in my imaginary world with these comforts.
the shape of the patch is what changes, the lower profile tire of the same width will have a wider but shorter patch, this is good for grip as grip is developed more at the leading edge of the contact patch than at the trailing edge and temp due to lower slip angles distorting the rubber less for the same grip. It's bad for feedback as there is less warning at the edge of grip. As w/ brakes the cooler the greater the lifespan
I went from 17" Cups to 18" Solid Twists. Very happy with the change overall. There are a number of variable's to consider when switching diameters. Aside from weight, I think your choice of tires will have the most great impact on the change. Every tire selection has a unique set of handling characteristics. Although 18's have a shorter sidewall, some tires will have a softer sidewall and some stiffer. Bottom line....very happy with the change to 18's (simply looks way better). If it looks better, it must handle better. ;-)



